arXiv · 1001.3210
Comment on "Surface roughness effect on ultracold neutron interaction with a wall and implications for computer simulations" A. Steyerl et.al., arxiv: 0911.4115v1 [1]
Abstract
In above mentioned article [1] assumptions of possible systematic errors of our experiment on measuring of the neutron lifetime [2] have been made. In the given comment we are obliged to explain, that assumptions made in [1] are erroneous. They are caused by an inattentive reading of our work [2] and by the improper understanding the methods used in our work [2]. Simulation of experiment [2] carried out in [1] seems to be imperfect and doesn't describe the experimental results. Therefore it is impossible to do any conclusions from such simulation.
Explore related subjects
Keep this discovery
A. Serebrov, A. Fomin, V. Varlamov. 2010-01-19. Comment on "Surface roughness effect on ultracold neutron interaction with a wall and implications for computer simulations" A. Steyerl et.al., arxiv: 0911.4115v1 [1]. https://arxiv.org/abs/1001.3210
Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.