Rolling of asymmetric disks on an inclined plane

Abstract

In a recent papers, Turner and Turner (2010 {\em Am. J. Phys.} {\bf 78} 905-7) and Jensen (2011 {\em Eur. J. Phys.} {\bf 32} 389-397) analysed the motion of asymmetric rolling rigid bodies on a horizontal plane. These papers addressed the common misconception that the instantaneous point of contact of the rolling body with the plane can be used to evaluate the angular momentum $\mathbf L$ and the torque $\boldsymbolτ$ in the equation of motion $d\mathbf L/dt = \boldsymbolτ$. To obtain the correct equation of motion, the "phantom torque" or various rules that depend on the motion of the point about which $\mathbf L$ and $\boldsymbolτ$ are evaluated were discussed. In this paper, I consider asymmetric disks rolling down an inclined plane and describe the most basic way of obtaining the correct equation of motion; that is, to choose the point about which $\mathbf L$ and $\boldsymbolτ$ are evaluated that is stationary in an inertial frame.