Concordance models of reionization: implications for faint galaxies and escape fraction evolution

Abstract

Recent observations have constrained the galaxy UV luminosity function up to z~10. However, these observations alone allow for a wide range of reionization scenarios due to uncertainties in the abundance of faint galaxies and the escape fraction of ionizing photons. We show that requiring continuity with post-reionization (z<6) measurements, where the Lya forest provides a complete probe of the cosmological emissivity of ionizing photons, significantly reduces the permitted parameter space. Models that are simultaneously consistent with the measured UV luminosity function, the Thomson optical depth to the CMB, and the Lya forest data require either: 1) extrapolation of the galaxy luminosity function down to very faint UV magnitudes M_lim ~ -10, corresponding roughly to the UV background suppression scale; 2) an increase of f_esc by a factor > ~10 from z=4 (where the best fit is 4%) to z=9; or 3) more likely, a hybrid solution in which undetected galaxies contribute significantly and f_esc increases more modestly. Models in which star formation is strongly suppressed in low-mass, reionization-epoch haloes of mass up to ~10^10 M_sun (e.g., owing to a metallicity dependence) are only allowed for extreme assumptions for the evolution of f_esc. However, variants of such models in which the suppression mass is reduced (e.g., assuming an earlier or higher metallicity floor) are in better agreement with the data. Concordance scenarios satisfying the available data predict a consistent redshift of 50% ionized fraction z_reion(50%) ~ 10. On the other hand, the duration of reionization is sensitive to the relative contribution of bright versus faint galaxies, with scenarios dominated by faint galaxies predicting a more extended reionization event. Scenarios relying too heavily on high-z dwarfs are disfavored by kinetic Sunyaev-Zeldovich measurements, which prefer a short reionization history.