Universal friction law at granular solid-gas transition explains scaling of sediment transport load with excess fluid shear stress

Abstract

A key interest in geomorphology is to predict how the shear stress $τ$ exerted by a turbulent flow of air or liquid onto an erodible sediment bed affects the transport load $M\tilde g$ (i.e., the submerged weight of transported nonsuspended sediment per unit area) and its average velocity when exceeding the sediment transport threshold $τ_t$. Most transport rate predictions in the literature are based on the scaling $M\tilde g\proptoτ-τ_t$, the physical origin of which, however, has remained controversial. Here we test the universality and study the origin of this scaling law using particle-scale simulations of nonsuspended sediment transport driven by a large range of Newtonian fluids. We find that the scaling coefficient is a universal approximate constant and can be understood as an inverse granular friction coefficient (i.e., the ratio between granular shear stress and normal-bed pressure) evaluated at the base of the transport layer (i.e., the effective elevation of energetic particle-bed rebounds). Usually, the granular flow at this base is gaslike and rapidly turns into the solidlike granular bed underneath: a liquidlike regime does not necessarily exist, which is accentuated by a nonlocal granular flow rheology in both the transport layer and bed. Hence, this transition fundamentally differs from the solid-liquid transition (i.e., yielding) in dense granular flows even though both transitions are described by a friction law. Combining this result with recent insights into the nature of $τ_t$, we conclude that the transport load scaling is a signature of a steady rebound state and unrelated to entrainment of bed sediment.