"Splitting" magnetic catalysis effect prevents vacuum superconductivity in strong magnetic fields

Abstract

By comparing the two- and three-flavor Nambu--Jona-Lasinio (NJL) models, we demonstrate that the naively expected vacuum superconductivity (VSC) in constant magnetic field ${\bf B}=B\hat z$ is disfavored due to the splitting magnetic catalysis effect (MCE) to chiral condensates with different quark flavors. Based on the simple two-flavor NJL model, we illuminate, in the lowest Landau level approximation, the similar origins of $π^0$ and $\barρ^+_1$ ($ρ^+$ meson with spin $S_z=1$) mass reductions with smaller $B$ and their different features at larger $B$. With the full Landau levels, the two-flavor NJL model is found to be invalid to study the magnetic field effect to $\barρ^+_1$ meson with physical vacuum mass $775~{\rm MeV}$. Then, restricted to $ρ$ meson mass below two-quark threshold in vacuum, that is $m_ρ^v<2m_q^v$, it is found that $π^0$ mass decreases and then increases with $B$ slowly, and $\barρ^+_1$ mass vanishing point is delayed to larger $B$ compared to the point particle result. In the more realistic three-flavor NJL model, all the quark masses split in strong magnetic field as a combinatorial result of their different current masses and electric charges. By choosing a vacuum mass closer to the physical one, $\barρ^+_1$ meson mass is found to be consistent with the LQCD results semi-quantitatively in smaller $B$ region but increase in larger $B$ region. These features are mainly outcomes of the interplay between the $S_z-B$ coupling effect and splitting MCE to the composite $u$ and $d$ quarks, which definitely disfavors VSC when the latter dominates. Furthermore, mesonic flavor mixing is modified by $B$ among the neutral pseudoscalars: $π^0,η_0$ and $η_8$, which is very important to suppress the mass enhancement of the effective mass eigenstates at large $B$.