Problem of Time and Background Independence: classical version's higher Lie Theory

Abstract

A local resolution of the Problem of Time has recently been given, alongside reformulation as a local theory of Background Independence. The classical part of this requires just Lie's Mathematics, much of which is basic: i) Lie derivatives to encode Relationalism. ii) Lie brackets for Closure giving Lie algebraic structures. iii) Observables defined by a Lie brackets relation, in the constrained canonical case as explicit PDEs to be solved using Lie's flow method, and themselves forming Lie algebras. iv) Lattices of constraint algebraic substructures induce dual lattices of observables subalgebras. The current Article focuses on two pieces of `higher Lie Theory' that are also required. Preliminarily, we extend Dirac's Algorithm for Constraint Closure to `Lie's Algorithm' for Generator Closure. 1) We then reinterpret `passing families of theories through the Dirac Algorithm' - a method used for Spacetime Construction (from space) and getting more structure from less structure assumed more generally - as the Dirac Rigidity subcase of Lie Rigidity. We also provide a Foundations of Geometry example of specifically Lie rather than Dirac Rigidity, to illustrate merit in extending from Dirac to Lie Algorithms. We point to such rigidity providing a partial cohomological (and thus global) selection principle for the Comparative Theory of Background Independence. 2) We finally pose the universal (theory-independent) analogue of GR's Refoliation Invariance for the general Lie Theory: Reallocation of Intermediary-Object Invariance. This is a commuting pentagon criterion: in evolving from an initial object to a final object, does switching which intermediary object one proceeds via amount to at most a difference by an automorphism of the final object? We argue for this to also be a selection principle in the Comparative Theory of Background Independence.