Inaccessible information in probabilistic models of quantum systems, non-contextuality inequalities and noise thresholds for contextuality

Abstract

Classical probabilistic models of (noisy) quantum systems are not only relevant for understanding the non-classical features of quantum mechanics, but they are also useful for determining the possible advantage of using quantum resources for information processing tasks. A common feature of these models is the presence of inaccessible information, as captured by the concept of preparation contextuality: There are ensembles of quantum states described by the same density operator, and hence operationally indistinguishable, and yet in any probabilistic (ontological) model, they should be described by distinct probability distributions. In this work, we quantify the inaccessible information of a model in terms of the maximum distinguishability of probability distributions associated to any pair of ensembles with identical density operators, as quantified by the total variation distance of the distributions. We obtain a family of lower bounds on this maximum distinguishability in terms of experimentally measurable quantities. In the case of an ideal qubit this leads to a lower bound of, approximately, 0.07. These bounds can also be interpreted as a new class of robust preparation non-contextuality inequalities. Our non-contextuality inequalities are phrased in terms of generalizations of max-relative entropy and trace distance for general operational theories, which could be of independent interest. Under sufficiently strong noise any quantum system becomes preparation non-contextual, i.e., can be described by models with zero inaccessible information. Using our non-contextuality inequalities, we show that this can happen only if the noise channel has the average gate fidelity less than or equal to 1/D(1+1/2+...+1/D), where D is the dimension of the Hilbert space.