Half-checking propagators

Abstract

Propagators are central to the success of constraint programming, that is contracting functions removing values proven not to be in any solution of a given constraint. The literature contains numerous propagation algorithms, for many different constraints, and common to all these propagation algorithms is the notion of correctness: only values that appear in no solution to the respective constraint may be removed. In this paper half-checking propagators are introduced, for which the only requirements are that identified solutions (by the propagators) are actual solutions (to the corresponding constraints), and that the propagators are contracting. In particular, a half-checking propagator may remove solutions resulting in an incomplete solving process, but with the upside that (good) solutions may be found faster. Overall completeness can be obtained by running half-checking propagators as one component in a portfolio solving process. Half-checking propagators opens up a wider variety of techniques to be used when designing propagation algorithms, compared to what is currently available. A formal model for half-checking propagators is introduced, together with a detailed description of how to support such propagators in a constraint programming system. Three general directions for creating half-checking propagation algorithms are introduced, and used for designing new half-checking propagators for the cost-circuit constraint as examples. The new propagators are implemented in the Gecode system.