The Local Structure of Bounded Degree Graphs

Abstract

Let $G=(V,E)$ be a simple graph with maximum degree $d$. For an integer $k\in\mathbb{N}$, the $k$-disc of a vertex $v\in V$ is defined as the rooted subgraph of $G$ that is induced by all vertices whose distance to $v$ is at most $k$. The $k$-disc frequency distribution vector of $G$, denoted by $\text{freq}_{k}(G)$, is a vector indexed by all isomorphism types of rooted $k$-discs. For each such isomorphism type $\Gamma$, the corresponding entry in $\text{freq}_{k}(G)$ counts the fraction of vertices in $V$ that have a $k$-disc isomorphic to $\Gamma$. In a sense, $\text{freq}_{k}(G)$ is one way to represent the "local structure" of $G$. The graph $G$ can be arbitrarily large, and so a natural question is whether given $\text{freq}_{k}(G)$ it is possible to construct a small graph $H$, whose size is independent of $|V|$, such that $H$ has a similar local structure. N. Alon proved that for any $\epsilon>0$ there always exists a graph $H$ whose size is independent of $|V|$ and whose frequency vector satisfies $||\text{freq}_{k}(G)-\text{freq}_{k}(H)||_{1}\le\epsilon$. However, his proof is only existential and does not imply that there is a deterministic algorithm to construct such a graph $H$. He gave the open problem of finding an explicit deterministic algorithm that finds $H$, or proving that no such algorithm exists. Our main result is that Alon's problem is undecidable if and only if a much more general problem (involving directed edges and edge colors) is undecidable. We also prove that both problems are decidable for the special case when $G$ is a path. We show that the local structure of any directed edge-colored path $G$ can be approximated by a suitable fixed-size directed edge-colored path $H$ and we give explicit bound on the size of $H$.