First principles vs second principles: Role of charge self-consistency in strongly correlated systems

Abstract

First principles approaches have been successful in solving many-body Hamiltonians for real materials to an extent when correlations are weak or moderate. As the electronic correlations become stronger often embedding methods based on first principles approaches are used to better treat the correlations by solving a suitably chosen many-body Hamiltonian with a higher level theory. Such combined methods are often referred to as second principles approaches. At such level of the theory the self energy, i.e. the functional that embodies the stronger electronic correlations, is either a function of energy or momentum or both. The success of such theories is commonly measured by the quality of the self energy functional. However, self-consistency in the self-energy should, in principle, also change the real space charge distribution in a correlated material and be able to modify the electronic eigenfunctions, which is often undermined in second principles approaches. Here we study the impact of charge self-consistency within two example cases: TiSe$_{2}$, a three-dimensional charge-density-wave candidate material, and CrBr$_{3}$, a two-dimensional ferromagnet, and show how real space charge re-distribution due to correlation effects taken into account within a first principles Green's function based many-body perturbative approach is key in driving qualitative changes to the final electronic structure of these materials.