Searcharxiv⌕ Search
Home/Archive/arXiv

arXiv · 2301.10952

Unlimited Category Theories for Mathematics are Inconsistent: A Discussion of Michael Ernst's "The Prospects for Unlimited Category Theory: Doing What Remains to be Done"

William H. Wheeler
View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

Proponents of category theory long hoped to escape the limits of set theory by founding mathematics on an unlimited category theory in which large categories, such as the category Grp of all groups, the category Top of all topological spaces, and the category Cat of all categories, would be (first-class) entities rather than just classes. Several proposals were put forward by Lawvere, MacLane, and Feferman, but none were successful. Feferman, in 1969 and 2013, proposed three requirements which an axiomatic theory of categories should fulfull in order to be an "unlimited category theory for mathematics". But in 2015 Michael Ernst proved that if an axiomatic theory of categories satisfied Fefermann's three requirements, then it is inconsistent. This paper, a presentation to the Indiana University, Bloomington, Logic Seminar, exposits Ernst's paper.

Explore related subjects

math.CTmath.LO

Keep this discovery

BibTeXRIS

William H. Wheeler. 2023-01-26. Unlimited Category Theories for Mathematics are Inconsistent: A Discussion of Michael Ernst's "The Prospects for Unlimited Category Theory: Doing What Remains to be Done". https://arxiv.org/abs/2301.10952

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

A model structure for cartesian 2-fibrations

Cartesian 2-fibrations provide a way to understand indexed categories, but their classical ``straightening'' construction requires several layers of weak coherence data. This paper develops a homotopical framework that replaces much of this bookkeeping with a fully strict model. By using marked 2-categories to record the cartesian morphisms and 2-cells, we construct a model structure whose fibrant objects are precisely the cartesian 2-fibrations over a fixed 2-category $\mathcal{C}$. We then show that the marked Grothendieck construction identifies these 2-fibrations, up to weak equivalence, with strict 2-functors from $\mathcal{C}$ into $2\mathrm{Cat}$. As an additional contribution, we construct localizations of 2-categories that simultaneously invert selected morphisms and 2-cells.

math.CT↗
arXiv2026

A Natural Fuzzy Order on Fuzzy Numbers

This paper introduces a natural fuzzy order on fuzzy numbers that extends the natural orders on real numbers and interval numbers. We investigate its completeness properties and show that the space of uniformly bounded fuzzy numbers is conically complete and conically cocomplete, and that it is complete if and only if the underlying continuous t-norm is the G\"odel t-norm. Moreover, it is proved that this space constitutes a \([0,1]\)-enriched domain if and only if the underlying continuous t-norm satisfies the (S) condition. These results provide a foundation for ordering fuzzy numbers.

math.CT↗
arXiv2026

Noetherian forms of free non-symmetric operads

In this paper, we study certain categories of labeled finite rooted ordered trees over a fixed set of labels where each label is equipped with an arity: a fixed number of children that the vertex with the given label must have. Equivalently, these are expression trees for operations in a free non-symmetric operad. A morphism between these trees matches a pruning of one tree (a prefix) with an entire subtree of another (a suffix). We characterize such categories, up to isomorphism, in terms of suitable exactness properties. It turns out that these categories exhibit strong algebraic behavior, in the sense that every such category, when appended with a strict initial object, has a particularly nice noetherian form.

math.CT↗