Are Ideal Measurements of Real Scalar Fields Causal?

Abstract

Half a century ago a local and (seemingly) causally consistent implementation of the projection postulate was formulated for local projectors in Quantum Field Theory (QFT) by utilising the basic property that spacelike local observables commute. This was not the end of the story for whether projective, or ideal measurements in QFT respect causality. In particular, the causal consistency of ideal measurements was brought into question by Sorkin 20 years later using a scenario previously overlooked. Sorkin's example, however, involved a non-local operator, and thus the question remained whether ideal measurements of local operators are causally consistent, and hence whether they are physically realisable. Considering both continuum and discrete spacetimes such as causal sets, we focus on the basic local observables of real scalar field theory -- smeared field operators -- and show that the corresponding ideal measurements violate causality, and are thus impossible to realise in practice. We show this using a causality condition derived for a general class of update maps for smeared fields that includes unitary kicks, ideal measurements, and approximations to them such as weak measurements. We discuss the various assumptions that go into our result. Of note is an assumption that Sorkin's scenario can actually be constructed in the given spacetime setup. This assumption can be evaded in certain special cases in the continuum, and in a particularly natural way in Causal Set Theory. In such cases one can then freely use the projection postulate in a causally consistent manner. In light of the generic acausality of ideal measurements, we also present examples of local update maps that offer causality-respecting alternatives to the projection postulate as an operationalist description of measurement in QFT.