Hyperelliptic and trigonal modular curves in characteristic $p$

Abstract

Let $X_\Delta(N)$ be an intermediate modular curve of level $N$, meaning that there exist (possibly trivial) morphisms $X_1(N)\rightarrow X_\Delta(N) \rightarrow X_0(N)$. For all such intermediate modular curves, we give an explicit description of all primes $p$ such that $X_\Delta(N)_{\overline{\mathbb F}_p}$ is either hyperelliptic or trigonal. Furthermore we also determine all primes $p$ such that $X_\Delta(N)_{\mathbb F_p}$ is trigonal. This is done by first using the Castelnuovo-Severi inequality to establish a bound $N_0$ such that if $X_0(N)_{{\overline{\mathbb F}_p}}$ is hyperelliptic or trigonal, then $N \leq N_0$. To deal with the remaining small values of $N$, we develop a method based on the careful study of the canonical ideal to determine, for a fixed curve $X_\Delta(N)$, all the primes $p$ such that the $X_\Delta(N)_{ {\overline{\mathbb F}_p}}$ is trigonal or hyperelliptic. Furthermore, using similar methods, we show that $X_\Delta(N)_{{\overline{\mathbb F}_p}}$ is not a smooth plane quintic, for any $N$ and any $p$.