Targeted computation of nonlocal closure operators via an adjoint-based macroscopic forcing method

Abstract

Reynolds-averaged Navier--Stokes (RANS) closure must be sensitive to the flow physics, including nonlocality and anisotropy of the effective eddy viscosity. Recent approaches used forced direct numerical simulations to probe these effects, including the macroscopic forcing method (MFM) of Mani and Park ($\textit{Phys. Rev. Fluids}$ $\textbf{6}$, 054607 (2021)) and the Green's function approach of Hamba ($\textit{Phys. Fluids}$ $\textbf{17}$, 115102 (2005)). The resulting nonlocal and anisotropic eddy viscosities are exact and relate Reynolds stresses to mean velocity gradients at all locations. They can be used to inform RANS models of the sensitivity to the mean velocity gradient and the suitability of local and isotropic approximations. However, these brute-force approaches are expensive. They force the mean velocity gradient at each point in the averaged space and measure the Reynolds stress response, requiring a separate simulation for each mean velocity gradient location. Thus, computing the eddy viscosity requires as many simulations as degrees of freedom in the averaged space, which can be cost-prohibitive for problems with many degrees of freedom. In this work, we develop an adjoint-based MFM to obtain the eddy viscosity at a given Reynolds stress location using a single simulation. This approach recovers the Reynolds stress dependence at a location of interest, such as a separation point or near a wall, on the mean velocity gradient at all locations. We demonstrate using adjoint MFM to compute the eddy viscosity for a specified wall-normal location in an incompressible turbulent channel flow using one simulation. In contrast, a brute-force approach for the same problem requires $N=144$ simulations (the number of grid points in the non-averaged coordinate direction). We show that a local approximation for the eddy viscosity would have been inappropriate.