Quantifying risk of a noise-induced AMOC collapse from northern and tropical Atlantic Ocean variability

Abstract

The Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC) exerts a major influence on global climate. There is much debate about whether the current strong AMOC may collapse as a result of anthropogenic forcing and/or internal variability. Increasing the noise in simple salt-advection models can change the apparent AMOC tipping threshold. However, it's not clear if 'present-day' variability is strong enough to induce a collapse. Here, we investigate how internal variability affects the likelihood of AMOC collapse. We examine internal variability of basin-scale salinities and temperatures in four CMIP6 pre-industrial simulations. We fit this to an empirical, process-based AMOC box model, and find that noise-induced AMOC collapse (defined as a decade in which the mean AMOC strength falls below 5 Sv) is unlikely for pre-industrial CMIP6 variability unless external forcing shifts the AMOC closer to a threshold. However, CMIP6 models seem to underestimate present-day Atlantic Ocean variability, and stronger variability substantially increases the likelihood of noise-induced collapse, especially if forcing brings the AMOC close to a stability threshold. Surprisingly, we find a case where forcing temporarily overshoots a stability threshold but noise decreases the probability of collapse. Accurately modelling internal decadal variability is essential for understanding the increased uncertainty in AMOC projections.