Linking Photometry and spectroscopy: profiling multiple populations in globular clusters

Abstract

Our understanding of multiple populations in globular clusters (GCs) largely comes from photometry and spectroscopy: appropriate photometric diagrams can disentangle first and second populations (1P and 2P)-1P having chemical signatures similar to field stars, and 2P stars showing unique light-element variations-while spectroscopy enables detailed chemical abundances analyses of these populations. We combine multi-band photometry with extensive spectroscopic data to investigate the chemical composition of multiple populations across 38 GCs, yielding a chemical abundance dataset for stars with precise population tagging. This dataset provides the most extensive analysis of C, N, O, Na, Mg, and Al variations, revealing the largest sample yet of light-element spreads across GCs. GC mass correlates with light-element variations, supporting earlier photometric studies. We investigated iron differences among 1P stars, confirming their presence in 19 GCs, and finding a spread consistent with prediction based on photometry. Notably, in eight of them we detected a correlation between [Fe/H] and the position in iron-sensitive photometric diagrams. More massive GCs display larger lithium depletion among 2P stars, which is consistent with zero at smaller masses. Notably, some 2P stars with the most extreme chemical differences compared to 1P stars still show Li comparable to 1P, suggesting that the 1P polluters have produced some amount of this element. We analyzed the anomalous stars, a population characterized by enrichment in iron, s-process elements, and C+N+O, in ten GCs. NGC1851, NGC5139, NGC6656, and NGC 6715 display light-element inhomogeneities similar to 1P and 2P stars. Iron and barium enrichment varies widely-negligible in some clusters and much larger than errors in others. Generally, these elemental spreads correlate with GC mass.