High Precision Black Hole Scattering: Tutti Frutti vs Worldline Effective Field Theory

Abstract

We consider black hole scattering up to the fifth Post Minkowskian ($G^5$) order and compare the predictions of the Tutti Frutti formalism to the results obtained within two different versions of Worldline Effective Field Theory. At the $G^4$ order we highlight the complete agreement between Tutti Frutti results and the results of [C. Dlapa et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. \textbf{130}, no.10, 101401 (2023)], and show how the Tutti Frutti approach allows one to extract the $O(G^3)$ angular momentum loss from the $O(G^4)$ impulse. We compare the sixth Post-Newtonian (6PN) accurate Tutti Frutti predictions to the recent results of [M. Driesse et al., arXiv:2411.11846 [hep-th]], which are at the $G^5$ order, and at the leading order in the two mass ratios, finding complete agreement. We highlight that this agreement involves the presence at the 5.5PN level of a nonlocal tail-of-tail contribution to the scattering (first computed in [D. Bini et al., Phys. Rev. D \textbf{102}, no.8, 084047 (2020)]), and involves, at the 6PN level, the presence of a $O(G^4)$ contribution to the angular momentum loss [C. Heissenberg, arXiv:2501.02904 [hep-th]]. At the second order in the mass ratios of the $O(G^5)$ order we predict two independent gauge-invariant observables to high-PN accuracy.