Beyond level-1: Identifiability of a class of galled tree-child networks

Abstract

Inference of phylogenetic networks is of increasing interest in the genomic era. However, the extent to which phylogenetic networks are identifiable from various types of data remains poorly understood, despite its crucial role in justifying methods. This work obtains strong identifiability results for large sub-classes of galled tree-child semidirected networks. Some of the conditions our proofs require, such as the identifiability of a network's tree of blobs or the circular order of 4 taxa around a cycle in a level-1 network, are already known to hold for many data types. We show that all these conditions hold for quartet concordance factor data under various gene tree models, yielding the strongest results from 2 or more samples per taxon. Although the network classes we consider have topological restrictions, they include non-planar networks of any level and are substantially more general than level-1 networks -- the only class previously known to enjoy identifiability from many data types. Our work establishes a route for proving future identifiability results for tree-child galled networks from data types other than quartet concordance factors, by checking that explicit conditions are met.