Revisiting Randomization in Greedy Model Search

Abstract

Feature subsampling is a core component of random forests and other ensemble methods. While recent theory suggests that this randomization acts solely as a variance reduction mechanism analogous to ridge regularization, these results largely rely on base learners optimized via ordinary least squares. We investigate the effects of feature subsampling on greedy forward selection, a model that better captures the adaptive nature of decision trees. Assuming an orthogonal design, we prove that ensembling with feature subsampling can reduce both bias and variance, contrasting with the pure variance reduction of convex base learners. More precisely, we show that both the training error and degrees of freedom can be non-monotonic in the subsampling rate, breaking the analogy with standard shrinkage methods like the lasso or ridge regression. Furthermore, we characterize the exact asymptotic behavior of the estimator, showing that it adaptively reweights OLS coefficients based on their rank, with weights that are well-approximated by a logistic function. These results elucidate the distinct role of algorithmic randomization when interleaved with greedy optimization.