Association of the IceCube neutrinos with CAZ blazar light curves

Abstract

The IceCube Neutrino Observatory has detected several hundred high-energy neutrinos from cosmic sources. Despite numerous studies searching for their origin, it is still not known which sources emit them. A few likely individual associations exist with active galactic nuclei (AGNs), mostly comprising blazars (AGNs with jets pointed toward Earth). Nonetheless, on a population level, blazar-neutrino correlation strengths are rather weak. This could mean that blazars as a population do not emit high-energy neutrinos or that the detection power of the tests is insufficient due to the strong atmospheric neutrino background. By assuming an increase in high-energy neutrino emission during major blazar flares, in our previous studies, we leveraged the neutrino arrival time to boost the detection power. Here, we utilize the same principle, while substantially increasing the number of blazars in the sample. We searched for the spatiotemporal correlation of 356 IceCube high-energy neutrinos with major optical flares of 3225 radio- and 3814 $\gamma$-ray-selected blazars. We found that despite the increase in data size, the number of likely spatiotemporal associations remained low and the overall correlation strengths weak. Two individual associations were shown to drive our strongest correlation, namely, the only $>$2$\sigma$ post-trial spatiotemporal correlation, occurring with the BL Lac objects of the radio-selected blazar sample. We estimated that $\lesssim$8\% of the detected cosmic neutrinos were emitted by blazars during major optical flares. As a complementary analysis, we compared the synchrotron peak frequency, redshift, Doppler factor, X-ray brightness, and optical variability of spatially neutrino-associated blazars to those of the general blazar population. We found that spatially neutrino-associated blazars have a Doppler factor and X-ray brightness that are higher than average.