Egg Drop Problems: They Are All They Are Cracked Up To Be!

Abstract

We illustrate how to invite and excite students about research by exploring higher-dimensional generalizations of the classical egg drop problem, in which the goal is to locate a critical breaking point using the fewest number of trials. Beginning with the one-dimensional case, we prove that with $k$ eggs and $N$ floors, the minimal number of drops in the worst case satisfies $P_1(k) \leq \lceil k N^{1/k} \rceil$. We then extend the recursive algorithm to two and three dimensions, proving similar formulas: $P_2(k) \leq \lceil (k-1)(M+N)^{1/(k-1)} \rceil $ in 2D and $P_3(k) \leq \lceil (k-2)(L+M+N)^{1/(k-2)} \rceil$ in 3D, and conjecture a general formula for the $d$-dimensional case. Beyond the critical point problems, we then study the critical line problems, where the breaking condition occurs along $x+y=V$ (with slope $-1$) or, more generally, $\alpha x+\beta y=V$ (with the slope of the line unknown). We discuss how one frequently has to pivot from the original problem, which is intractable, to something that can be solved; in our case, using induction and recursion, two standard proof techniques.