Noisy Pairwise-Comparison Random Search for Smooth Nonconvex Optimization

Abstract

We study smooth nonconvex optimization using only noisy pairwise comparisons, without access to gradients or function values. We propose Noisy-Comparison Random Search (NCRS), a simple direct-search method that samples random directions and performs accept/reject updates from comparison feedback. Under a low-dimensional active-subspace structure, NCRS adapts to the intrinsic dimension $k\le d$ rather than the ambient dimension $d$. For a uniform-margin comparison oracle with advantage $p$, NCRS achieves $\epsilon$-first-order stationarity with comparison complexity $\mathcal{O}(k/(p^2\epsilon^2))$. We also introduce a gap-dependent confidence model, where comparison reliability decreases as the objective-value gap between the two candidates becomes small, and analyze a confidence-weighted voting variant of NCRS. For this oracle, the method achieves $\epsilon$-first-order stationarity with total comparison complexity $\mathcal{O}(k^2/\epsilon^4)$. These results provide intrinsic-dimension convergence guarantees for noisy comparison-based random search in smooth nonconvex optimization.