Four negations and the spectral presheaf

Abstract

Using Vakarelov's theory of lattice logics with negation, we introduce the (co)quasiintuitionistic logic, and prove its soundness and completeness with respect to the class of (co)quasiintuitionistic algebras. Combining these algebras together, we obtain biquasiintuitionistic algebras and the biquasiintuitionistic logic. Their further extension with the Skolem algebra structure defines Akchurin algebras and the respective logic, which is a product of biquasiintuitionistic and biintuitionistic logics, featuring four distinct negations. Next we generalise the framework of spectral presheaves (which is a main object in the Butterfield--Isham--D\"{o}ring topos theoretic approach to quantum mechanics) to arbitrary complete orthocomplemented lattices, and show that the orthocomplementation determines two negation operators on the spectral presheaf (one paraconsistent, another paracomplete), equipping the set of all closed-and-open subpresheaves of a spectral presheaf with the structure of a biquasiintuitionistic algebra. Combined with the generic Skolem (i.e. Heyting and Brouwer) algebra structure of this set, this gives a particular instance of an Akchurin algebra. We also show that the underlying orthocomplemented lattice can be reconstructed as an internal object of the spectral presheaf, resulting as the image of a double coquasiintuitionistic (resp., quasiintuitionistic) negation monad (resp., comonad). Finally, we prove a no-go theorem for the claim that the spectral presheaf is a model of a dialectical (or any other) relevance logic.