On the Distribution of Unweighted Minimum Knapsack Instances with Large SOS Rank

Abstract

We analyze the sum-of-squares rank of unweighted instances of the Minimum Knapsack (MK) problem, i.e., minimization of $\sum_{i=1}^n x_i$ for 0/1 variables under the constraint $\sum_{i=1}^n x_i \geq q$, with $q \in \mathbb{R}$. Such instances have long served as a testbed for understanding the limitations of lift-and-project methods in Boolean optimization. For example, both the Lov\'asz-Schrijver and Sherali-Adams hierarchies require (maximal) rank $n$ to solve them, already when $q=1/2$ is constant. The SOS hierarchy requires only \emph{sublinear} rank $O(\sqrt{n})$ to solve unweighted MK when $q=1/2$. On the other hand, when $q$ is allowed to vary with~$n$, the SOS rank of the problem may become linear. Interestingly, this is known to happen both when $q$ is large, and when $q$ is very small ($0<q \leq 2^{-n}$). This raises the question of whether we should think of hard instances of unweighted MK as being typical for the SOS hierarchy, or as a consequence of very specific choices of the threshold parameter $q$. In this paper, we address this question by showing new upper and lower bounds on the SOS rank of unweighted MK in the whole regime of the parameter $q$. For $n-q \leq O(1)$, we show that the SOS rank is constant. In contrast, when $q \leq O(1)$, a linear rank is needed if $q$ is exponentially close to an integer. As our main positive result, we show that linear rank is very rare for $q \leq O(1)$. This can be expressed in the language of smoothed analysis: after perturbing $q$ by a Gaussian with mean $0$ and variance $\sigma^2$, the expected SOS rank of MK is $O(\sqrt{n} \log (n/\sigma))$.