Mutual information and mutual correlation: their spin-free formulations and comparison

Abstract

Orbital entropies, pair entropies, and mutual information have become popular tools for analysis of strongly correlated wave functions. They can quantitatively measure how strongly an orbital participates in the electron correlation and reveal the correlation pattern between different orbitals. However, this pattern can become rather complicated and sometimes difficult to interpret for large active spaces and is not invariant with respect to the spin projection ($M_s$) component of the spin multiplet state. We introduce a modified spin-free orbital entropy, pair entropy, and mutual information, which simplify the correlation analysis and are invariant with respect to $M_s$. By comparison of these quantities with their "original" spin-including counterparts one can distinguish static correlation due to spin couplings from the "genuine" strong correlation due to a multiconfigurational character of the wave function. Recently, Evangelista introduced mutual correlation computed from the two-body cumulant as an alternative correlation measure, which is easier to compute for some methods. We present here a spin-free analogue of this quantity, which is $M_s$ invariant, and perform a comparison of the entropy-based and cumulant-based correlation measures in both spin-free and original variants. We illustrate the approaches on iron-sulfur bound complexes with one and two iron atoms.