Coupling dynamical accretion and chemical differentiation: A unified framework for the diversity of Earth and Mars

Abstract

The physical and geochemical differences between Earth and Mars provide fundamental constraints on terrestrial planet formation, yet a self-consistent framework linking dynamical and chemical aspects remains elusive. Here we present an integrated modeling framework that couples high-resolution N-body simulations with impact-driven metal-silicate equilibration to track the dynamical accretion history and chemical differentiation for Earth and Mars. Using a narrow ring planetesimal accretion scenario, we show that Earth and Mars analogs naturally sample systematically different solid reservoirs within the protoplanetary disk. Earth analogs preferentially accrete reduced material around the planetesimal ring center, whereas Mars analogs acquire a larger fraction of oxidized material exterior to the ring. This leads to diverse bulk redox states, with composition further modified by impact-dependent pressure-temperature equilibration conditions during core formation. As a result, Earth analogs experience deeper equilibration and more efficient transfer of iron into the core, producing mantles with low iron oxide contents and larger core mass fractions. In contrast, Mars analogs equilibrate at shallower conditions, retain more iron in their mantles, and develop smaller cores. Our results demonstrate that the dynamical and geochemical differences between Earth and Mars emerge from the coupled effects of accretion pathways, the disk's radial redox structure, and impact-controlled differentiation rather than from any single process. Our unified framework physically explains the geochemical diversity of terrestrial planets and offers a potential pathway to interpret compositions of rocky planets in exoplanetary systems.