Hamiltonian variational reconstruction of the 3D magnetic geometry of relativistic jets: accuracy across GRMHD models and the fundamental sign degeneracy

Abstract

Every resolved image of a relativistic jet encodes its magnetic field, yet no image records which way the field points along the axis. Synchrotron intensity and linear polarization are blind to this: both probe the field only through even combinations of its components. We introduce H-MOG, a variational method that reconstructs the 3D field on a lattice from two projected observables, the jet width W(z) and the linear polarization p(z), regularized by a Hamiltonian prior and optimized with automatic differentiation. We apply H-MOG to ten GRMHD simulations spanning MAD and SANE states and five black-hole spins (a* = -0.94, -0.5, 0, +0.5, +0.94), and test three routes to break the intrinsic sign degeneracy of the reconstruction: a Faraday rotation-measure term, full 3D sampling, and a Blandford-Znajek spin prior. The unsigned field orientation is recovered at <|cos|> ~ 0.95-0.98, far above the random expectation of 0.5. The sense of the poloidal field, however, is not recovered, and we prove it cannot be: W and p are invariant under B -> -B. All three routes to break this degeneracy fail for distinct physical reasons; the spin-sense relation in these turbulent jets is not monotonic, differing sharply between MAD and SANE. Recovering the sense requires a parity-odd observable: Faraday tomography or circular polarization.