Energy-dependent slow collective flavor conversion of supernova neutrinos

Abstract

We study collective slow flavor conversion (SFC) of supernova neutrinos with multi-energy, multi-angle simulations for three representative neutrino spectra in the early accretion, late accretion, and cooling phases, in which multiple crossings between the initial electron- and heavy-lepton-flavor spectra are present. By numerically solving the neutrino quantum kinetic equations in a local periodic box, we find that SFC triggered predominantly by the spatially inhomogeneous instabilities drives the system toward a spatially coarse-grained, quasi-stationary state, whose flavor conversion probability depends strongly on energy, angle, and the neutrino mass ordering. While we find that not all of the initial spectral crossings are completely erased in the final state, a simple, box-like analytical prescription inspired by studies of fast flavor conversions, which eliminates the spectral crossings, can reasonably approximate the post-SFC spectra. Using the initial and post-SFC spectra, we also evaluate the changes of the corresponding $\nu_e$ and $\bar\nu_e$ heating rates as well as the absorption equilibrium electron fraction ($Y_e$). Within the considered scenarios, we find that the heating rates are generally enhanced by up to $\sim 80\%$ due to the net conversion of $\nu_x$ to $\nu_e$ (and $\bar\nu_x$ to $\bar\nu_e$) above their crossing energy, provided that the energy spectra above the crossing energy differ substantially. For the absorption equilibrium $Y_e$, spectra changes due to SFC increase it by $\sim 0.03$ due to the relatively more enhanced $\nu_e$ absorption rate than $\bar\nu_e$, which potentially drives supernova materials to be more proton-rich. These results highlight the importance of energy-dependent treatments of SFC for supernova neutrinos.