From Nonmetricity Operators to the Physical Spectrum: A Branch-Complete Analysis of Local Four-Derivative Symmetric Teleparallel Gravity

Abstract

We develop a branch-complete classical free-spectrum analysis of local parity-even symmetric teleparallel gravity containing all pure-gravity nonmetricity operators through four derivatives. After canonicalisation and integration by parts, the nonlinear action contains 116 independent operators distributed as $5+13+29+69$ among $Q^2$, $(\nabla Q)^2$, $Q^2\nabla Q$ and $Q^4$. Around Minkowski spacetime in the coincident gauge only the first two sectors contribute to the quadratic action, which reduces to four two-derivative and five four-derivative bilinears. We map the original coefficients to this nine-dimensional basis, construct the Hessian and momentum kernel, and classify local linear gauge symmetries. Unrestricted linearised diffeomorphism invariance imposes six independent relations and leaves a three-parameter family $(A,B,C)$. We also recover TDiff, Weyl, WTDiff and additional accidental symmetry branches. Barnes--Rivers decomposition, gauge fixing, exact inversion and conserved-source saturation reduce the physical exchange to spin-two and scalar factors $A+2Cq$ and $2A+(3B-2C)q$. The generic regular spectrum contains a massless graviton, a massive spin-two state and a massive scalar, with eight degrees of freedom. The massive spin-two residue is necessarily opposite to that of the healthy massless graviton. The regular classification leaves only GR/STEGR, $A>0$ with $B=C=0$, and the scalar extension, $A>0$, $B>0$, $C=0$, as fully healthy Minkowski loci. The latter has three degrees of freedom and mixed ultraviolet behaviour, with tensor exchange scaling as $k^{-2}$ and scalar exchange as $k^{-4}$. Thus, within this finite local metric theory, full four-derivative tensor suppression requires the finite massive spin-two pole with opposite residue.