Searcharxiv⌕ Search

arXiv · 2609.31497

HOMO-LUMO Intervals from Modern Density Functionals as Fundamental Gap Estimators

Abstract

Use of the Kohn-Sham eigenvalue gap (highest occupied molecular orbital to lowest unoccupied, HOMO-LUMO) as a fundamental gap (I-A, I= ionization potential, A= electron affinity) estimator is a long-standing challenge for relatively simple exchange-correlation functionals, e.g. meta-GGAs. The LAK meta-GGA [T. Lebeda et al. Phys. Rev. Lett. 133, 136402 (2024)] was developed to emphasize certain constraints in ways intended to make the LAK KS gaps close to the HSE06 hybrid functional [A.V. Krudau et al. J.Chem. Phys. 125, 224106 (2006)] gaps. The LAK functional was tested against a small atomization data set and a very small bond length set, with no molecular HOMO-LUMO gap testing. Here we test LAK against widely used, large reference data sets for molecular heats of formation, bond lengths, harmonic frequencies, I, and A and compare with r2SCAN [J.W. Furness et al., J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 11, 8208 (2020)] as well as HSE06 and PBE0, a quite different hybrid. On these tests LAK does not give meaningfully better geometries, heats of formation, HOMO-LUMO gaps, or DFT IP theorem satisfaction than r2SCAN. Compared against experimental I and A values the same holds; LAK results resemble r2SCAN results, not HSE06. Moreover, the HOMO and LUMO shifts generated by the NCAPR GGA [J. Carmona-Espindola et al., J. Chem. Phys. 157, 114109 (2022)] as derivative discontinuity estimates, correct the bare NCAPR HOMO and LUMO eigenvalues to substantially better agreement with experiment for both fundamental gap and IP theorem than do the meta-GGAs (LAK, r2SCAN) or hybrids (HSE, PBE0). We discuss possible reasons why LAK behaves differently for molecules and solids.

Explore related subjects

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

H. Francisco, Javier Carmona-Espíndola, A. C. Cancio, José Luis Gázquez, S. B. Trickey. 2026-09-25. HOMO-LUMO Intervals from Modern Density Functionals as Fundamental Gap Estimators. https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.31497

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

A phase space electronic structure theory beyond Born-Oppenheimer: Geometric forces and Moody-Shapere-Wilczek revisited

We revisit the three-body problem in quantum mechanics in two and three dimensions, generating both exact eigenvalues and eigenvectors of the Hamiltonian and a series of approximate solutions as calculated with a variety of different schemes to separate heavy ("nuclear") and light ("electronic") particles. We show that, with minimal extra cost, one can go beyond the Born-Oppenheimer approximation by performing electronic structure calculations parameterized by both the nuclear position (${\mathbf X})$ and the nuclear momentum ($\mathbf{P}$), a so-called phase space theory of electronic structure. In particular, we demonstrate that such phase space electronic structure calculations correctly incorporate the non-inertial Coriolis and centrifugal forces felt by electrons in a moving nuclear frame, thus leading to far more accurate eigenenergies and electronic angular momenta than has been possible before. We also demonstrate that our approach naturally incorporates and generalizes the Moody-Shapere-Wilczek magnetic monopole for the non-abelian Berry curvature (now allowing for vibrational motion rather than a diatomic of fixed length). We argue that the resulting approach should be extremely useful for propagating dynamics where angular momentum flows between nuclei and electrons; in particular, if extended to include spin degrees of freedom, the present approach will offer a practical means to study chiral induced spin selectivity through the lens of chiral phonons and coupled nuclear-electronic motion.

physics.chem-ph↗

The NewMag crystal-field code for f-element systems: Implementation for extended active spaces, second-order correlated energies, and generalisation to fn configurations

We report a massive update of the NewMag program, which enables to extract Stevens crystal-field parameters (CFPs) after relativistic and multiconfigurational calculations are performed. The code can now post-treat ORCA and OpenMolcas outputs that contain state-average complete active space self-consistend field (SA-CASSCF) calculations with minimal or extended active spaces, second-order NEVPT2 or CASPT2 calculations, and spin-orbit configuration interaction (SOCI) calculations. Stevens parameters are extracted following the original Stevens convention with the so-called "extended" parameters. Rotation invariant indicators are also computed, after applying a correction of the parameter values to ensure normalization, following Rudowicz. At the SOCI level, the spin-orbit coupling (SOC) constant is also extracted within a spherical approximation of the SOC operator. For all the reference calculation levels, the model spectrum is reconstructed, allowing a direct assessment of its quality. The reported implementation is successfully applicable to f-element systems with a non-void, non-half-filled/empty or non-full f shell, that is for f^n configurations with n != 0, != 7 and != 14. Similarities and differences with the SINGLE_ANISO and AILFT codes are discussed. With selected examples, we showcase the interest of determining CFPs in f-element systems to understand their magnetic and optical properties in general, and more specifically the added value of NewMag. Finally, application of this approach to d-element systems is discussed, to reveal when it readily and successfully applies and when it may fail in reproducing satisfactorily the ab initio energies.

physics.chem-ph↗

Fortuitous Cancellation of Competing Effects in the Free Energy of Water Autoionization: Long-Range Electrostatics, System Size, and Nuclear Quantum Effects

Few molecular processes are more fundamental to chemistry than the autoionization of water, whose equilibrium constant, $K_w \approx 10^{-14}$, underlies acid-base equilibria and the chemistry of life. Yet the molecular origins of the free energy cost of forming and separating ions remain incompletely understood. Efforts to explain it have been limited by the difficulty of modeling water reactivity in sufficient detail. Here we combine machine learning interatomic potentials (MLIPs) with spectral adaptive biasing force enhanced sampling to connect proton transfer and water wire configurations to the underlying free energy landscape. We identify competing influences of long-range electrostatics, system size, temperature, and nuclear quantum motion on the predicted ionization thermodynamics. The free energy surface extends from neutral water to ions separated beyond the solvent-separated ion pair (SSIP). It reveals a transition state in which a proton is shared between the second and third molecules of a three-membered water wire. The contact ion pair is unstable and the SSIP only weakly metastable, so determining pK$_w$ requires sampling longer wires. Long-range electrostatics raise the free energy at ion separations beyond $3\,\mathrm{\mathring{A}}$. Models with comparable force errors give substantially different free energy profiles in this region. Increasing system size lowers the calculated pK$_w$, while nuclear quantum effects bring it closer to experiment and reproduce the higher pK$_w$ of D$_2$O relative to H$_2$O. These results establish a baseline for interpreting thermodynamic results from MLIP simulations in which charged and polar groups react and diffuse in finite cells. Our analysis also explains how cancellation among competing effects can yield ionization constants close to experiment even when simulations omit several physical contributions.

physics.chem-ph↗