Parity Tests under Ties: A One-Test Lifting Theorem

Abstract

In the unrestricted polynomial decision-tree model, only the number of polynomial sign tests is charged. A parity test asks for the sign of a product of pairwise differences. Such tests underlie low-depth randomized algorithms for maximum finding and top-$k$ selection, but their usual analysis assumes distinct inputs because a tie makes the product vanish. We give a black-box lifting theorem that removes this assumption. After $O(\log n)$ polynomial tests determine the number of nonzero pairwise differences, every subsequent parity test is simulated by one polynomial test, consistently with a fixed lexicographic tie-breaking order. The simulator is an elementary symmetric polynomial in masked first and second powers of all pairwise differences. Thus a depth-$D$ parity-test tree on distinct inputs becomes a polynomial decision tree of depth $D+O(\log n)$ on arbitrary inputs, with no increase in randomized pointwise error for order-selection problems. We obtain maximum finding in depth $O(\log n[\log n+\log(1/δ)])$ with error $δ$, and top-$k$ selection in depth $O(\log^2 n+k\log n)$ with inverse-polynomial error, both without any promise on ties.