Constraints on Nonlinearity of the Mass-Concentration Relation

Abstract

We develop a Bayesian generalization of the previous method to constrain a wide variety of mass-concentration (M-C) relations motivated by both theoretical and observational studies. The framework incorporates the intrinsic scatter in concentration, nonlinear weak-lensing (WL) calibration relations, the WL measurement-error covariance, and the underlying parent mass distribution. We employ Hamiltonian Monte Carlo for computational efficiency. Our sample consists of 213 X-ray-selected clusters with WL measurements for the eRASS1, XXL, LoCuSS, and MCXC catalogs at 0<z< 0.9. For each subsample, we account for its specific WL calibration relation and underlying population distribution. We consider a conventional single power-law model, an empirical double power-law model, and four theoretical models calibrated against numerical simulations. The four theoretical M-C models comprise two in which concentration decreases with mass, distinguished by the sign of d^2ln c/d(ln M)^2, and two in which the concentration decreases with increasing mass before turning upward at high masses. Because the mass and redshift ranges of our cluster sample do not extend into the upturn regime predicted by numerical simulations, we distinguish among the models primarily through the curvature of their M-C relations. Regardless of which model is adopted, the inferred M-C relation is in good agreement with the results of recent numerical simulations. We find no statistically significant differences among the models above the $4σ$ level. However, the result shows a tendency toward a gradual flattening of the mass dependence toward higher masses. Specifically, a monotonically decreasing model with positive curvature is preferred over the single power-law relation and a monotonically decreasing model with negative curvature at the $2σ$ level and over three double power-law models at the $0.5-1σ$ level.