Searcharxiv⌕ Search

arXiv · 2611.20789

Detecting False Self-Consistency in Density-Functional Calculations

Abstract

Density-functional calculations feed materials databases and machine-learning models, and are declared converged when energy changes and residuals fall below thresholds. We show that these criteria, and even the agreement of independent optimizers, can accept a state from which the energy still descends or whose Hamiltonian is inconsistent with the energy. A variational formulation of self-consistency in the space of Kohn-Sham Hamiltonians yields a descent probe that exposes lower states accessible from a returned solution, and a frozen-orbital Janak test detects such an inconsistency. Both apply to any code without modification. In VASP, a UO$_2$ PBE+$U$ calculation converges 1.46 eV above a lower state, and CoO and FeO converge as metals 0.8-0.9 eV above insulating states. In a census of 339 converged calculations on tungsten-free Materials Project structures, recomputed with a modified static protocol, 57 (16.8%) show energy decreases above the threshold, 49 without an initial energy rise exceeding the tolerance.

Explore related subjects

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Mohsen Sotoudeh. 2026-11-16. Detecting False Self-Consistency in Density-Functional Calculations. https://searcharxiv.com/abs/2611.20789

Citations retain the original authors and DOI and include this site’s record URL. If this discovery service contributed to your research, you can also cite Searcharxiv by Indiciae: BibTeX · RIS.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

Evidence for crystal-field-selected octupolar order in wolframite oxides

Magnetic order can involve higher-rank moments such as octupoles, which are difficult to identify in strongly distorted crystals. Here we present evidence for predominantly octupolar order in the monoclinic wolframites MgReO$_4$ and ZnReO$_4$. Muon spin spectroscopy detects magnetic transitions near 83 and 126 K, respectively, with similar precession frequencies in both compounds. An ab initio effective Hamiltonian shows that strong crystal fields split the spin--orbit quartet, isolating low-energy doublets with weak dipolar character. Exchange selects octupole-dominated order in distinct collinear antiferromagnetic structures, with moments along $b$ in MgReO$_4$ and tilted within the $ac$ plane in ZnReO$_4$. The estimated dipole moments of 0.06 and 0.12 $μ_{\mathrm{B}}$ per Re, respectively, are consistent with the absence of a resolved magnetic contribution in neutron powder diffraction. A single-ion model illustrates how octupolar states generate local fields with a vanishing net dipole moment. These findings support a crystal-field route to hidden magnetism beyond double perovskites.

cond-mat.mtrl-sci↗

Substrate Role in Polaron Formation on Single-layer Transition Metal Dihalides

Single-layer transition metal dihalides grown on conducting substrates were shown to host stable polarons. Here, we investigate small polarons in a single layer of the insulator MnBr$_2$, which was grown by molecular beam epitaxy on three different substrates: graphene on Ir(110), graphene on Ir(111), and Au(111). Polarons on these substrates can be created, converted, and moved by the STM tip when a tunneling current flows at a proper bias voltage. Four polaron species are observed in MnBr$_2$ grown on graphene Ir(110), three of which resemble the species previously observed for CoCl$_2$ on graphite, whereas MnBr$_2$ grown on the other substrates exhibits only two of these four species. Changing the substrate from graphene on Ir to Au(111) increases polaron number density by an order of magnitude. These large differences demonstrate that the choice of conducting substrate plays a decisive role in determining polaron phenomenology in substrate-supported single-layer insulators. Two unique observations are reported for polarons in MnBr$_2$ on graphene supported by Ir(110): First, mobile polarons are guided by the periodic potential originating from the super-moiré of MnBr$_2$ with graphene and Ir(110); second, polarons remain stable up to 300\,K.

cond-mat.mtrl-sci↗

Systematic comparison of approximations and functionals in first-principle calculations of aluminum-based III-V ferroelectric nitrides

We revisit first-principles predictions of structural, ferroelectric, and electronic properties in aluminum-based III-V nitride alloys, focusing on Al1-xScxN and Al1-xBxN. Using density functional theory within a unified 48-atom supercell framework, we systematically assess the role of chemical disorder and exchange-correlation approximations by comparing the virtual crystal approximation (VCA) and special quasirandom structures (SQS), as well as PBE, PBESol, SCAN, and SCAN+rVV10 functionals. We demonstrate that, even amongst the similar PBE and PBESol functionals, large quantitative and qualitative differences emerge. In particular, VCA or SQS PBESol modeling (a popular functional) underestimates the stability domain of the ferroelectric wurtzite phase in Al1-xScxN compared to SQS PBE or SQS SCAN. We demonstrate that the 5-fold coordinated hexagonal phase predicted in 2002 by Farrer and Bellaiche [Phys. Rev. B 66, 201203] is a metastable state whose energy lies between that of the four-fold coordinated ferroelectric wurtzite phase and the energy of the six-fold coordinated rocksalt phase below the transition point. In contrast, Al1-xBxN shows a much faster destabilization of the wurtzite ferroelectric phase, with bond breaking which strongly distorts the wurtzite structure (with enhanced polarization) and eventually favors a zincblende phase and a threefold coordinated hexagonal layer phase. Our analysis highlights the critical importance of both local disorder and exchange-correlation treatment in the quantitative prediction of the functional properties of III-V nitride ferroelectrics.

cond-mat.mtrl-sci↗