How Do Z and Atoll X-ray Binaries Differ?

Abstract

Low-mass X-ray binaries containing weakly magnetized neutron stars may be divided into two classes, Z and atoll sources, based in large part upon the patterns which they trace in plots of two X-ray colors. In this paper, we examine color-color diagrams of nine atoll sources and five Z sources using data from the Rossi X-ray Timing Explorer. The five-year span of data we have examined is significantly longer than those of previous studies. We find that the previous clear distinction between atoll and Z sources may be an artifact of incomplete sampling, as those atoll sources which are sampled over a wide dynamic range in intensity (greater than a factor of 80) trace three-branched color-color patterns similar to the tracks for which Z sources are named. This suggests that the two classes are more intimately related than previously realized, which also has been suggested based upon recent timing studies. However, detailed differences in the spectral behavior of the two classes argue against any simple unification.