Resolving the 47 Tucanae Distance Problem

Abstract

We present new B, V and I-band photometry for a sample of 43 local subdwarfs with HIPPARCOS parallax errors < 13%, in the metallicity range -1.0 < [Fe/H] < -0.3, which we use to perform main sequence (MS) fitting to the Galactic globular cluster 47 Tuc. This sample is many times larger than those used in previous MS-fitting studies and also enables us to fit in two colour planes, V/(B-V) and V/(V-I). With this enlarged subdwarf sample we investigate whether the current discrepancy in empirical distance estimates for 47 Tuc, arising from recent MS-fitting and white dwarf fitting results, is due to inaccuracies in the MS-fitting method. Comparison of published photometries for 47 Tuc has revealed systematic offsets which mean that the $(B-V)$ main-line used in previous studies may be too blue by ~ 0.02 mag. We have derived main-lines in V/(B-V) and V/(V-I) from the data of Kaluzny et al. (1998), which we have recalibrated from the `secondary' standards in 47 Tuc of Stetson (2000). Using an assumed cluster reddening of E(B-V)=0.04, our best-fit apparent distance modulus is (m-M)V=13.37 (+0.10)(-0.11) in both colour planes, which implies a cluster age of 11.0 +/-1.4 Gyr and leads to a dereddened distance modulus of (m-M)0=13.25 (+0.06)(-0.07). Comparison with previous work shows that our apparent distance modulus is ~0.2 mag smaller than those derived in previous MS-fitting studies. The difference is accounted for by our preferred cluster reddening and the recalibration of the cluster photometry, which has made the main-line redder by an average of 0.02 mag in (B-V). Independent support for our MS-fitting distance comes from consideration of the Red Clump in the cluster, from which we derive a dereddened distance modulus of (m-M)0=13.31 +/-0.05, which is in agreement with the MS-fitting result. (Abridged)