Star formation at very low metallicity. II: On the insignificance of metal-line cooling during the early stages of gravitational collapse

Abstract

We study the influence of low levels of metal enrichment on the cooling and collapse of ionized gas in small protogalactic halos using three-dimensional, smoothed particle hydrodynamics simulations. Our initial conditions represent protogalaxies forming within a fossil HII region -- a previously ionized HII region which has not yet had time to cool and recombine. Prior to cosmological reionization, such regions should be relatively common, since the characteristic lifetimes of the likely ionizing sources are significantly shorter than a Hubble time. We show that in these regions, H_2 is the dominant and most effective coolant, and that it is the amount of H_2 formed that determines whether or not the gas can collapse and form stars. At the low metallicities (Z < 10^{-3} Z_sun) thought to be associated with the transition from population III to early population II star formation, metal line cooling has an almost negligible effect on the evolution of low density gas, altering the density and temperature evolution of the gas by less than 1% compared to the metal-free case at densities below 1 cm^{-3} and temperatures above 2000 K. Although there is evidence that metal line cooling becomes more effective at higher density, we find no significant differences in behaviour from the metal-free case at any density below our sink particle creation threshold at n = 500 cm^{-3}. Increasing the metallicity also increases the importance of metal line cooling, but it does not significantly affect the dynamical evolution of the low density gas until Z = 0.1 Z_sun. This result holds regardless of whether or not an ultraviolet background is present.