On the Dramatic Spin-up/Spin-down Torque Reversals in Accreting Pulsars

Abstract

Dramatic torque reversals between spin up and spin down have been observed in half of the persistent X-ray pulsars monitored by the BATSE all-sky monitor on CGRO. Theoretical models developed to explain early pulsar timing data can explain spin down torques via a disk-magnetosphere interaction if the star nearly corotates with the inner accretion disk. To produce the observed BATSE torque reversals, however, these equilibrium models require the disk to alternate between two mass accretion rates, with $\dot M_{\pm}$ producing accretion torques of similar magnitude, but always of opposite sign. Moreover, in at least one pulsar (GX 1+4) undergoing secular spin down the neutron star spins down faster during brief ($\sim 20$ day) hard X-ray flares -- this is opposite the correlation expected from standard theory, assuming BATSE pulsed flux increases with mass accretion rate. The $10$ day to 10 yr intervals between torque reversals in these systems are much longer than any characteristic magnetic or viscous time scale near the inner disk boundary and are more suggestive of a global disk phenomenon. We discuss possible explanations of the observed torque behavior. Despite the preferred sense of rotation defined by the binary orbit, the BATSE observations are surprisingly consistent with an earlier suggestion by Makishima \etal (1988) for GX~1+4: the disks in these systems somehow alternate between episodes of prograde and retrograde rotation. We are unaware of any mechanism that could produce a stable retrograde disk in a binary undergoing Roche-lobe overflow, but such flip-flop behavior does occur in numerical simulations of wind-fed systems. One possibility is that the disks in some of these binaries are fed by an X-ray excited wind.