Is SGR 1900+14 a Magnetar?

Abstract

We present RXTE observations of the soft gamma--ray repeater SGR 1900+14 taken September 4-18, 1996, nearly 2 years before the 1998 active period of the source. The pulsar period (P) of 5.1558199 +/- 0.0000029 s and period derivative (Pdot) of (6.0 +/- 1.0) X 10^-11 s/s measured during the 2-week observation are consistent with the mean Pdot of (6.126 +/- 0.006) X 10^-11 s/s over the time up to the commencement of the active period. This Pdot is less than half that of (12.77 +/- 0.01) X 10^-11 s/s observed during and after the active period. If magnetic dipole radiation were the primary cause of the pulsar spindown, the implied pulsar magnetic field would exceed the critical field of 4.4 X 10^13 G by more than an order of magnitude, and such field estimates for this and other SGRs have been offered as evidence that the SGRs are magnetars, in which the neutron star magnetic energy exceeds the rotational energy. The observed doubling of Pdot, however, would suggest that the pulsar magnetic field energy increased by more than 100% as the source entered an active phase, which seems very hard to reconcile with models in which the SGR bursts are powered by the release of magnetic energy. Because of this, we suggest that the spindown of SGR pulsars is not driven by magnetic dipole radiation, but by some other process, most likely a relativistic wind. The Pdot, therefore, does not provide a measure of the pulsar magnetic field strength, nor evidence for a magnetar.