Galaxy Clusters: Oblate or Prolate?

Abstract

It is now well known that a combined analysis of the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) effect and the X-ray emission observations can be used to determine the angular diameter distance to galaxy clusters, from which the Hubble constant is derived. Given that the SZ/X-ray Hubble constant is determined through a geometrical description of clusters, the accuracy to which such distance measurements can be made depends on how well one can describe intrinsic cluster shapes. Using the observed X-ray isophotal axial ratio distribution for a sample of galaxy clusters, we discuss intrinsic cluster shapes and, in particular, if clusters can be described by axisymmetric models, such as oblate and prolate ellipsoids. These models are currently favored when determining the SZ/X-ray Hubble constant. We show that the current observational data on the asphericity of galaxy clusters suggest that clusters are more consistent with a prolate rather than an oblate distribution. We address the possibility that clusters are intrinsically triaxial by viewing triaxial ellipsoids at random angles with the intrinsic axial ratios following an isotropic Gaussian distribution. We discuss implications of our results on current attempts at measuring the Hubble constant using galaxy clusters and suggest that an unbiased estimate of the Hubble constant, not fundamentally limited by projection effects, would eventually be possible with the SZ/X-ray method.