SearcharxivSearch

arXiv subjects

Aaron S. G. Robotham

Publications and source records attributed to Aaron S. G. Robotham.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

The constrainability of galaxy positions in the $M_*$ -- SFR plane from SED fitting

Using a sample of 6,029 $z<0.06$ galaxies from the GAMA survey, we characterise the spread of galaxy property inferences on the M$_*$ -- SFR plane via Spectral Energy Distribution (SED) fitting. We analyse 24 different model configurations using the stellar population library code \textsc{ProGeny}, and the SED-fitting code \textsc{ProSpect}, and quantify how modelling assumptions affect inferred stellar masses, star formation rates, and the resulting classification of galaxies. We find that the reproducibility of inferred galaxy positions depends strongly on location within the $M_*$ -- SFR plane, with uncertainties increasing dramatically below $\log_{10}(\rm{sSFR}/\rm{yr}^{-1}) \sim -11$. This boundary closely tracks the transition between robustly and poorly constrained SFR estimates, regardless of whether SFRs are derived from SED fitting or H$_α$ measurements. We find that star-bursting galaxies cannot be robustly isolated from SED fitting alone, while the separation of star-forming and passive galaxies is most consistently conducted by a cut in sSFR, rather than a dex cut relative to either a curved or linear SFS (Star Forming Sequence). We further show that transitioning (or Green Valley) selections using SED fitting are highly unstable, with only $\sim$25\% of the sample being repeatedly selected, on average.

astro-ph.GA

Bright star-forming galaxies naturally forming at z>10 in the Shark semi-analytic model

The James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) has unveiled the existence of numerous z>10 bright ultraviolet (UV) galaxies, potentially challenging galaxy formation models in a Lambda Cold Dark Matter (LCDM) universe. Modifications to star formation and stellar feedback models have been suggested to alleviate the tension. However, the fundamental challenge is to design a galaxy formation model that simultaneously reproduces observations from z=0 to those at the highest redshifts. Here, we present predictions from the Shark semi-analytic model of galaxy formation, which is tuned to reproduce the z=0 universe. We show that the same model is capable of reproducing the current UV luminosity function constraints even up to z=17 without the need to invoke variations in the baryon physics model. This model is also capable of reproducing reasonably well the stellar mass function evolution from z=0 to z=10 and the cosmic star formation rate (SFR) density at 0 10. We demonstrate that without this mechanism, galaxies are not bursty enough in the model to reproduce the observations at z>10.

astro-ph.GA

The Structural Abundance Crisis of Massive Galaxies in Current Cosmological Simulations

The internal structure of galaxies encodes the complex baryon cycle driven by gas accretion, star formation, and feedback, together with secular evolution and environmentally driven processes such as mergers and tidal interactions. We present a population-level census of massive nearby galaxies ($\log(M_\star/M_\odot) > 10$) by comparing Hyper Suprime-Cam Subaru Strategic Program observations with matched mock images from IllustrisTNG, EAGLE, and SIMBA. Using a consistent, like-for-like imaging pipeline, we construct structural abundance functions (SAFs) for key morphological parameters, revealing a structural abundance crisis. Across Sérsic index, concentration, size, and ellipticity, all simulations exhibit large, systematic discrepancies ($>5σ$; RMSE $\sim 0.2$--$1.8$\,dex), typically corresponding to abundance differences of factors of several. While individual simulations display diverse failures---underproducing or overproducing compact spheroids, extended or round galaxies ---all underproduce highly flattened disks. Although TNG shows the closest agreement and SIMBA the largest offsets, this shared failure indicates that current models---despite matching global demographics such as the stellar mass function---do not uniquely constrain internal galaxy structure. Our results demonstrate that agreement in integrated observables can mask fundamental shortcomings in the modelling of mass and angular momentum redistribution. We therefore establish SAFs as a stringent, multidimensional, and observationally accessible benchmark for testing and calibrating next-generation galaxy formation models in the era of upcoming deep, wide-field surveys.

astro-ph.GA

The contribution of stars, dust, neutral gas and supermassive black holes in galaxies to the cosmic baryon inventory

We compute the cosmic stellar, dust and neutral gas mass history at $0<z\lesssim3$ using ProSpect spectral energy distribution modelling of $\approx 800 \, 000$ galaxies in the Galaxy and Mass Assembly (GAMA) survey and the Deep Extragalactic VIsible Legacy Survey (DEVILS). The cosmic dust mass history broadly follows the shape of the cosmic star formation history; though, the decline is slower, suggestive of a slowing rate of dust growth and destruction as the star formation declines past its peak at $z\approx 2$. Neutral gas masses were estimated by scaling the dust masses by the metallicity-dependent dust-to-gas ratio. The neutral gas mass density as traced by the dust is an average of $\approx 0.7$ dex lower than that measured from $21$cm experiments, most likely due to differences in the spatial scales inhabited by dust and HI. Folding in measurements of the supermassive black hole mass density obtained previously with similar data and methods, we present a self-consistent census of the baryons confined to galaxies. Stars, neutral gas, SMBHs and dust contained within the optical radii of galaxies account for $\approx 5$ per cent of the baryons. Most of the remaining $\approx 95$ per cent of baryons must be ionised and dispersed throughout the interstellar, circumgalactic and intergalactic media within, around and between galaxies.

astro-ph.GA

Deep Extragalactic VIsible Legacy Survey (DEVILS): Morphologically-selected galaxy merger fractions and their direct comparison to close-pair samples

Galaxy mergers are a central driver of galaxy evolution across cosmic time, and thus, quantifying their frequency is critical for constraining hierarchical models of galaxy formation. Motivated by the need to robustly quantify these fractions and their evolution, we build on our previous close-pair analysis by exploring morphological identification techniques within the Deep Extragalactic VIsible Legacy Survey (DEVILS), using the D10 (COSMOS) field, which covers an area of $1.47$ deg$^2$. While close-pairs trace the early stages of galaxy interactions, morphological methods probe more advanced phases of the merging process, including systems with disturbed structures and post-merger remnants. We present galaxy merger fractions over the redshift range $0.2 < z < 0.9$ using visual classification and automated identification based on non-parametric statistics: concentration ($C$), asymmetry ($A$), smoothness ($S$), Gini ($G$), and $M_{20}$, applied to HST/ACS imaging. To enhance the detection of subtle structural perturbations, we measure asymmetry on unsharp-masked images. We find relatively little overlap between visually and automatically identified samples, which highlights their distinct sensitivities and limitations. Moreover, galaxy merger fractions derived from morphological disturbances are consistently higher than those from close-pair counts at all redshifts. This potentially reflects how each method probes different stages of the merger process, with distinct observability timescales, as well as the fact that morphologically disturbed galaxies, at a given redshift, are typically the later-stage descendants of close-pairs from earlier epochs. This comparison allows us to examine systematic differences between identification techniques and assess how they impact the observed evolution of the galaxy merger fraction.

astro-ph.GA

SM-Net: Learning a Continuous Spectral Manifold from Multiple Stellar Libraries

We present SM-Net, a machine-learning model that learns a continuous spectral manifold from multiple high-resolution stellar libraries. SM-Net generates stellar spectra directly from the fundamental stellar parameters effective temperature (Teff), surface gravity (log g), and metallicity (log Z). It is trained on a combined grid derived from the PHOENIX-Husser, C3K-Conroy, OB-PoWR, and TMAP-Werner libraries. By combining their parameter spaces, we construct a composite dataset that spans a broader and more continuous region of stellar parameter space than any individual library. The unified grid covers Teff = 2,000-190,000 K, log g = -1 to 9, and log Z = -4 to 1, with spectra spanning 3,000-100,000 Angstrom. Within this domain, SM-Net provides smooth interpolation across heterogeneous library boundaries. Outside the sampled region, it can produce numerically smooth exploratory predictions, although these extrapolations are not directly validated against reference models. Zero or masked flux values are treated as unknowns rather than physical zeros, allowing the network to infer missing regions using correlations learned from neighbouring grid points. Across 3,538 training and 11,530 test spectra, SM-Net achieves mean squared errors of 1.47 x 10^-5 on the training set and 2.34 x 10^-5 on the test set in the transformed log1p-scaled flux representation. Inference throughput exceeds 14,000 spectra per second on a single GPU. We also release the model together with an interactive web dashboard for real-time spectral generation and visualisation. SM-Net provides a fast, robust, and flexible data-driven complement to traditional stellar population synthesis libraries.

astro-ph.IM

Hidden in Plain Sight: Searching for Globular Clusters Within JWST Observations of the PLCK G165.7+67.0 Galaxy Cluster

Although the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) has received much attention for its ability to search deeper into the cosmos than ever before, it also enhances our capability to study objects closer to us in the Universe. We apply a methodology of subtracting intracluster light to the PLCK G165.7+67.0 (G165; $z$ = 0.35) cluster, revealing a population of unresolved point-like sources including globular clusters (GCs). By applying a fitting algorithm in color space used to select galaxy cluster members, we uncover over 900 globular cluster candidates from our point source sample. We also identify candidates by estimating the contribution of interlopers to the point source sample, yielding an estimate of 793$\pm$ 83 globular cluster candidates. We find the color-selected sources to be approximately correlated spatially with the intracluster light and lensing mass of the cluster. The observed luminosity function of the sources shows a turnover point fainter than the completeness limit, so we use fixed-parameter curve fitting models to predict a K-corrected turnover point between $-9.4 \leq M_{\rm F200W} \leq -10.7$ mag, although we predict the expected K-corrected turnover point should be closer to $-7.7 \leq M_{\rm F200W} \leq -8.4$ mag. We discuss the dynamical state of this disturbed galaxy cluster with a bimodal mass distribution using the spatial distribution of GC candidates and find that the radial profiles of our color-selected GC candidates are very consistent with the lensing-derived surface mass density at $>$50 kpc.

astro-ph.GA

SKYSURF. X. A Novel Method for Measuring Integrated Galaxy Light

We describe the drizzling pipeline and contents of the drizzled database for Hubble Space Telescope Cycle 27-29 Archival Legacy project "SKYSURF," the largest archival project ever approved for Hubble. SKYSURF aims to investigate the extragalactic background light using all 143,914 ACSWFC, WFC3UVIS, and WFC3IR images that have been taken by Hubble since its launch in 2002. SKYSURF has produced 38,027 single-visit mosaics and 7,893 multi-visit mosaics across 28 ACSWFC, WFC3UVIS, and WFC3IR filters using nonstandard drizzling methods, which include preserving the lowest sky-level of each visit/group in the drizzled products, applying wider apertures for cosmic-ray rejection, correcting effects caused by charge transfer efficiency degradation, and removing potential light gradients from input images via sky-map subtraction. We generate source catalogs for all drizzled products with SExtractor and provide updated star-galaxy separation parameters and integrated galaxy light (IGL) estimates for 25 of the 28 SKYSURF filters (wavelength range 0.2-1.7 um) using a novel IGL fitting method made possible by the vast SKYSURF dataset. We discuss the data processing and data analysis challenges encountered, detail our solutions, and offer suggestions that may facilitate future large-scale IGL investigations with Webb, SPHEREx, and Roman.

astro-ph.IM

SKYSURF IX -- The Cosmic Optical and Infrared Background from Integrated Galaxy Light Measurements

As part of the SKYSURF Hubble Space Telescope (HST) Legacy Archival program we present galaxy number counts which yield measurements of the extragalactic background light (EBL) at 15 different wavelengths. We have processed 82,752 HST images across 23 filters into 16,686 mosaics using the same software and processing pipeline throughout. Using 17/23 filters that give reliable galaxy counts, we constrain the integrated galaxy light (IGL) with a 1.5-9\% error between 0.3 and 1.6 $μ$m in combination with 8 bands from WAVES (Wide Area VISTA Extragalactic Survey) and DEVILS (Deep Extragalactic Visible Legacy Survey). While HST was never intended to undertake large area surveys, through extensive quality control and filtering, we were able to extract a reliable and representative sample of fields distributed across the sky. Our final catalogs cover a combined $\approx 19.6 °^2$, with individual filters covering areas ranging from $\approx 0.16-7.0 °^2$. The combination of numerous independent sight-lines and area coverage allows us to reduce cosmic variance uncertainties in deep number counts to 0.06\%-1.8\%. For the first time we are able to establish a measurement of the IGL, $\mathrm{9.07 \pm 0.35 nW m^{-2} sr^{-1}}$, at 0.59 $μ$m using HST data. We obtain a cosmic optical background value of $ 24.45 \pm 0.50 \mathrm{nW m^{-2} sr^{-1}}$. Different techniques used to measure the COB, both directly and indirectly, have recently converged indicating that the COB arises almost exclusively from processes within galaxies. This in combination with the recent values reported from New Horizons and very high energy (VHE) constraints leaves very little room for any diffuse emission coming from outside the Milky Way.

astro-ph.CO

Decomposing the growth mechanisms of galaxies over the last 10 billion years

Determining how galaxies accumulate stellar mass is paramount to understanding the Universe. Two primary mechanisms drive this process: star-formation (SF) & mergers. Our understanding of star formation, and to some degree the processes that influence the baryon cycle (environment, gas supply, feedback, etc), are either relatively well constrained or will develop significantly over the coming decades via upcoming facilities (i.e. through their imprint on galaxy properties measured with deep multi-wavelength and spectroscopic data). However, the same can not be said for mergers. It is telling that we indirectly know hierarchical assembly through mergers is one of the most crucial processes that shape our Universe, but the robust observational measurement of mergers is almost non-existent outside of the local Universe - let alone how these mergers impact galaxy properties. This is not likely to significantly change in the coming decades as existing or approved facilities/surveys are inadequate in charactering mergers in the distant Universe. Motivated by this, we discuss an ambitious study to first explore mergers, and then the co-dependent astrophysical process that govern the accumulation of stellar mass over the last ~10billion years, and highlight the essential need for a 10m+ class multi-object spectroscopic facility.

astro-ph.GA

Dissecting Reionisation with the Cosmic Star Formation and Active Galactic Nuclei Luminosity History

The combination of the $z=0-13.5$ cosmic star formation history and active galactic nuclei (AGN) luminosity history as inferred by the James Webb Space Telescope is connected to the cosmic spectral energy distribution (CSED) to explore the sources of reionisation. We compute the redshift evolution of the corresponding cosmic ionising photon emissivity, the neutral fraction and the cosmic microwave background optical depth. We use the generative SED modelling code ProSpect to bracket the ionising emissivity between escape fractions of $f_{\mathrm{esc}} = 1 - 100\%$ for both the stars and AGN. Stars alone could have achieved reionisation by $z\approx 6$ with $f_{\mathrm{esc}} \gtrsim 30\%$ for solar metallicity ($Z=0.02$) stars or $f_{\mathrm{esc}} \gtrsim 10\%$ for metal-poor ($Z=10^{-4}$) stars. On the other hand, AGN by themselves would have struggled to produce sufficiently many ionising photons even with $f_{\mathrm{esc}} = 100\%$. A hybrid model containing both stars and AGN is explored where we find best fit (median$\pm 1σ$) $f_{\mathrm{esc}}=$ $12\%$ ($14^{+9}_{-7}\%$) for the stars and $f_{\mathrm{esc}}=$ $63\%$ ($60^{+28}_{-32}\%$) for the AGN, maintained at all redshifts. In essence, the joint growth of stellar mass and supermassive black holes produces neither more nor fewer ionising photons than needed to reionise $\gtrsim 99\%$ of the intergalactic medium by $z\approx 6$.

astro-ph.GA

GalSBI-SPS: a stellar population synthesis-based galaxy population model for cosmology and galaxy evolution applications

Next generation photometric and spectroscopic surveys will enable unprecedented tests of the concordance cosmological model and of galaxy formation and evolution. Fully exploiting their potential requires a precise understanding of the selection effects on galaxies and biases on measurements of their properties, required, above all, for accurate estimates of redshift distributions n(z). Forward-modelling offers a powerful framework to simultaneously recover galaxy $n(z)$s and characterise the observed galaxy population. We present GalSBI-SPS, a new SPS-based galaxy population model that generates realistic galaxy catalogues, which we use to forward-model HSC data in the COSMOS field. GalSBI-SPS samples galaxy physical properties, computes magnitudes with ProSpect, and simulates HSC images in the COSMOS field with UFig. We measure photometric properties consistently in real data and simulations. We compare $n(z)$s, photometric and physical properties to observations and to GalSBI. GalSBI-SPS reproduces the observed grizy magnitude, colour, and size distributions down to i<23. Median differences in magnitudes and colours remain below 0.14 mag, with the model covering the full colour space spanned by HSC. Galaxy sizes are overestimated by 0.2 arcsec on average and some tension exists in the g-r colour, but the latter is comparable to that seen in GalSBI. $n(z)$s show a mild positive offset (0.01-0.08) in the mean. GalSBI-SPS qualitatively reproduces the stellar mass-SFR and size-stellar mass relations seen in COSMOS2020. GalSBI-SPS provides a realistic, survey-independent galaxy population description at a Stage-III depth using only literature-based parameters. Its predictive power will improve significantly when constrained against observed data using SBI, thereby providing accurate $n(z)$s satisfying the stringent requirements set by Stage IV surveys.

astro-ph.GA

Deep Extragalactic VIsible Legacy Survey (DEVILS): Galaxy group catalogue for the D10-COSMOS field with 90% spectroscopic redshift completeness

Large-scale galaxy redshift surveys conducted over the last couple of decades have proven crucial in deepening our understanding of structure growth in the Universe and galaxy evolution. While there have been several such surveys, until now those that achieve the high completeness and precision necessary to probe the low-mass end of galaxy groups have been limited to relatively low redshifts ($z\lesssim0.3$), with surveys exploring the more distant Universe being constrained by small sample sizes and/or low redshift completeness. The recent Deep Extragalactic VIsible Legacy Survey (DEVILS) aims to explore galaxy environment over the last $\sim6$ Gyr with a completeness level comparable to the most complete local Universe surveys ($>85\%$). In this work, we present the galaxy group catalogue for the D10-COSMOS field from DEVILS, which achieves a redshift completeness of $90\%$ for galaxies with $Y<21.2$ mag. We showcase the science potential by exploring the impact of environment on the fraction and power of active galactic nuclei (AGN), finding that satellites in galaxy groups show no evidence of altered AGN properties, while satellites in clusters exhibit increased AGN fractions but decreased AGN luminosities.

astro-ph.GA

ProMage: fast galaxy magnitudes emulation combining SED forward-modelling and machine learning

We present ProMage, a feed-forward neural network that emulates the computation of observer- and rest-frame magnitudes from the generative galaxy SED package ProSpect. The network predicts magnitudes conditioned on input galaxy physical properties, including redshift, star formation history, gas and dust parameters. ProMage accelerates magnitude computation by a factor of $10^4$ compared to ProSpect, while achieving per-mille relative accuracy for $99\%$ of sources in the test set across the $g,r,i,z,y$ Hyper Suprime-Cam bands. This acceleration is key to enabling fast inference of galaxy physical properties in next-generation Stage IV surveys and to generating large catalogue realisations in forward-modelling frameworks such as GalSBI-SPS.

astro-ph.GA

The weak connection between the stellar haloes and merger histories of Milky Way-mass galaxies

Stellar haloes form through the disruption of satellite galaxies over time, making them a promising observable for constraining galaxy merger histories. We use a dynamical decomposition technique to isolate the stellar haloes of Milky Way-mass galaxies in the $100\,{\rm Mpc}$ EAGLE simulation and study their relationship to the merger histories of their hosts. We define the stellar halo as the stellar mass that is bound to the central subhalo but not associated with the disc or bulge components of a galaxy, and we quantify their merger histories using the most significant merger since $z=1$. Surprisingly, we find that the fraction of a galaxy's total stellar mass in the stellar halo, $f_{\rm SH}$, is not a reliable indicator of its merger activity. Contrary to common assumptions, disc galaxies with low $f_{\rm SH}$ do not necessarily have quiescent merger histories. In fact, roughly one quarter experienced a merger at $z \leq 1$ with a satellite whose stellar mass was at least 10 per cent of the host galaxy's stellar mass. These galaxies undergo mergers with satellites on circular orbits that are roughly co-planar with the pre-existing disc and thereby avoid contributing mass to the stellar halo. Instead, such mergers build thick, extended discs and supply fresh gas that often triggers a significant episode of star formation in the disc. Our results suggest that disc galaxies with low-mass stellar haloes, such as the Milky Way, can have varied and active merger histories, and that stellar haloes may not be a reliable tool for inferring galaxy merger histories.

astro-ph.GA

Self-Consistent JWST Census of Star Formation and AGN activity at z=5.5-13.5

The cosmic star formation history (CSFH) and cosmic active galactic nuclei (AGN) luminosity history (CAGNH) are self consistently measured at $z = 5.5-13.5$. This is achieved by analyzing galaxies detected by the James Webb Space Telescope from $\approx 400 \, \mathrm{arcmin^{2}}$ fields from the PEARLS, CEERS, NGDEEP, JADES and PRIMER surveys. In particular, the combination of spectral energy distribution fitting codes, EAZY and \textsc{ProSpect}, are employed to estimate the photometric redshifts and astrophysical quantities of $3751$ distant galaxies, from which we compute the stellar mass, star formation rate and AGN luminosity distribution functions in four redshift bins. Integrating the distribution functions, we find that the CSFH rises by $\approx 1$~dex over $z = 13.5 - 5.5$ and the CAGNH rises by $\approx 1$~dex over $z = 10.5 - 5.5$. We connect our results of the CSFH and CAGNH at $z=13.5-5.5$ to that from $z= 5-0$ to determine the summary of $\gtrsim 13$ Gyr of star formation and AGN activity, from the very onset of galaxy formation to the present day.

astro-ph.GA

ProGeny II: the impact of libraries and model configurations on inferred galaxy properties in SED fitting

We use a volume-complete sample of ~8,000 galaxies from the GAMA survey to characterise the impact of stellar population libraries (SPLs) and model configurations on the resulting inferred galaxy properties from Spectral Energy Distribution (SED) fitting. We compare a fiducial SPL from ProGeny (a new tool that can generate SPLs quickly and flexibly) against five other commonly used SPLs using the SED-fitting code ProSpect. The impact of selecting each SPL is compared to the consequence of changing the model implementation in the SED fitting process, including the implementation of metallicity evolution versus a fixed or constant metallicity, and a functional parametric star formation history (SFH) versus a stepwise parametric (or "non-parametric") SFH. Furthermore, we use ProGeny to assess the impact of sub-SPL choices, including isochrone selection, stellar spectra selection, and IMF selection. Through a comparison of derived stellar masses, star formation rates, metallicities, ages, and the inferred cosmic star formation history (CSFH), we rank the impact of varying choices. Overall the assumption of a solar metallicity creates the greatest biases, with a substantial impact also caused by the choice of a specific SPL. To recover a CSFH most consistent with observations, we advocate for the use of the fiducial implementation with a skewed Normal functional form for the SFH, and an evolving metallicity, although we note that all studied SPLs underestimate the peak in the CSFH.

astro-ph.GA

Deep Extragalactic VIsible Legacy Survey (DEVILS): New robust merger rates at intermediate redshifts

Mergers are fundamental to our understanding of the processes driving the evolution of the structure and morphology of galaxies, star formation, AGN activity, and the redistribution of stellar mass in the Universe. Determining the fraction and properties of mergers across cosmic time is critical to understanding the formation of the Universe we observe today. This fraction and its evolution also provide inputs and constraints for cosmological simulations, crucial for theoretical models of galaxy evolution. We present robust estimates of major close-pair fractions and merger rates at $0.2 < z < 0.9$ in the Deep Extragalactic VIsible Legacy Survey (DEVILS). We identify major mergers by selecting close-pairs with a projected spatial separation $r_{\mathrm{sep}} < 20$ h$^{-1}$ kpc and a radial velocity separation $v_{\mathrm{sep}} < 500$ km s$^{-1}$. For galaxies with stellar masses of log$_{10}$($M_\star$/$M_\odot$) = 10.66 $\pm$ 0.25 dex, we find a major close-pair fraction of $\approx 0.021$ at $0.2 < z < 0.34$ using a highly complete, unbiased spectroscopic sample. We extend these estimates to $0.2 < z < 0.9$ by combining the full probability distribution of redshifts for galaxies with high-quality spectroscopic, photometric, or grism measurements. Fitting a power-law $γ_{m} = A(1 + z)^m$, we find $A = 0.024 \pm 0.001$ and $m = 0.55 \pm 0.22$. Consistent with previous results, the shallow slope suggests weak redshift evolution in the merger fraction. When comparing with large hydrodynamical simulations, we also find consistent results. We convert close-pair fractions to merger rates using several literature prescriptions for merger timescales and provide all measurements for future studies.

astro-ph.GA