SearcharxivSearch

arXiv subjects

Abhas Mitra

Publications and source records attributed to Abhas Mitra.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

Thermal Radiation from Compact Objects in Curved Space-Time

We highlight here the fact that the distantly observed luminosity of a spherically symmetric compact star radiating thermal radiation isotropically is higher by a factor of $(1+z_{\rm b})^2$ compared to the corresponding flat space-time case, where $z_{\rm b}$ is the surface gravitational redshift of the compact star. In particular, we emphasize that if the thermal radiation is indeed emitted isotropically along the respective normal directions at each point, this factor of increment $(1+z_{\rm b})^2$ remains unchanged even if the compact object would lie within its {\em photon sphere}. Since a canonical neutron star has $z_{\rm b} \approx 0.1$, the actual X-ray luminosity from the neutron star surface could be $\sim 20 \%$ higher than what would be interpreted by ignoring the general relativistic effects described here. For a static compact object, supported by only isotropic pressure, compactness is limited by the Buchdahl limit $z_{\rm b} < 2.0$. However, for compact objects supported by anisotropic pressure, $z_{\rm b}$ could be even higher ($z_{\rm b} < 5.211$). In addition, in principle, there could be ultra-compact objects having $z_{\rm b} \gg 1$. Accordingly, the general relativistic effects described here might be quite important for studies of thermal radiation from some ultra-compact objects.

physics.gen-ph

Mass of Schwarzschild Black Holes Is Indeed Zero And Black Hole Candidates Are Quasi Black Holes

A Schwarzschild Black Hole (BH) is the gravitational field due to a neutral point mass, and it turns out that the gravitational mass of a neutral point mass: $M=0$ (Arnowitt, Deser, Misner, PRL 4, 375, 1960). The same result is also suggested by Janis, Newman, and Winicour (PRL 20, 878, 1968). In 1969, Bel gave an explicit proof that for a Schwarzschild BH, $M=0$ (Bel, JMP 10, 1051, 1969). The same result follows from the fact the timelike geodesic of a test particle would turn null if it would ever arrive at an event horizon (Mitra, FPL, 2000, 2002). Non-occurrrence of trapped surfaces in continued gravitational collapse too demands $M=0$ for black hole (Mitra, Pramana, 73, 615, 2009). Physically, for a point mass at $R=0$, one expects ${\it Ric} \sim M δ(R=0)$ (Narlikar \& Padmanabhan, Found. Phys., 18, 659, 1988). But the black hole solution is obtained from ${\it Ric} =0$. Again this is the most direct proof that $M=0$ for a Schwarzschild black hole. Implication of this result is that the observed massive black hole candidates are non-singular quasi black holes or black hole mimickers which can possess strong magnetic fields as has been observed. The echoes from LIGO signals, if true, may be the direct evidence that the pertinent compact objects are BH mimickers and not true vacuum BHs.

physics.gen-ph

Sensitivity estimate of the MACE gamma ray telescope

The MACE (Major Atmospheric Cherenkov Experiment) is a 21 m diameter gamma-ray telescope which is presently being installed at Hanle in Ladakh, India (32^0 46^' 46^" N, 78^0 58^' 35^" E) at an altitude of 4270 m a.s.l. Once operational, it will become the highest altitude very high energy (VHE) gamma-ray telescope in the world based on Imaging Atmospheric Cherenkov Technique (IACT). In the present work, we discuss the sensitivity estimate of the MACE telescope by using a substantially large Monte Carlo simulation database at 5^0 zenith angle. The sensitivity of MACE telescope is estimated by carrying out the gamma-hadron segregation using the Random Forest method. It is estimated that the MACE telescope will have an analysis energy threshold of 38 GeV for image intensities above 50 photoelectrons. The integral sensitivity for point like sources with Crab Nebula-like spectrum above 38 GeV is ~2.7% of Crab Nebula flux at 5 sigma statistical significance level in 50 hrs of observation.

astro-ph.IM

Gamma/hadron segregation for a ground based imaging atmospheric Cherenkov telescope using machine learning methods: Random Forest leads

A detailed case study of $γ$-hadron segregation for a ground based atmospheric Cherenkov telescope is presented. We have evaluated and compared various supervised machine learning methods such as the Random Forest method, Artificial Neural Network, Linear Discriminant method, Naive Bayes Classifiers,Support Vector Machines as well as the conventional dynamic supercut method by simulating triggering events with the Monte Carlo method and applied the results to a Cherenkov telescope. It is demonstrated that the Random Forest method is the most sensitive machine learning method for $γ$-hadron segregation.

astro-ph.IM

Validation of a new background discrimination method for the TACTIC TeV $γ$-ray telescope with Markarian 421 data

This paper describes the validation of a new background discrimination method based on Random Forest technique by re-analysing the Markarian 421 (Mrk 421) observations performed by the TACTIC (TeV Atmospheric Cherenkov Telescope with Imaging Camera) gamma-ray telescope. The Random Forest technique is a flexible multivariate method which combines Bagging and Random Split Selection to construct a large collection of decision trees and then combines them to construct a common classifier. Markarian 421 in a high state was observed by TACTIC during December 07, 2005 - April 30, 2006 for 202 h. Previous analysis of this data led to a detection of flaring activity from the source at Energy $ >$ 1 TeV. Within this data set, a spell of 97 h revealed strong detection of a gamma-ray signal with daily flux of > 1 Crab unit on several days. Here we re-analyze this spell as well as the data from the entire observation period with the Random Forest method. Application of this method led to an improvement in the signal detection strength by $\sim 26\%$ along with a $\sim 18\%$ increase in detected $γ$ rays compared to the conventional Dynamic Supercuts method. The resultant differential spectrum obtained is represented by a power law with an exponential cut off $Γ= -2.51 \pm 0.10$ and $E_{0} = 4.71 \pm 2.20$ TeV. Such a spectrum is consistent with previously reported results and justifies the use of Random Forest method for analyzing data from atmospheric Cherenkov telescopes.

astro-ph.HE

Low frequency radio spectrum of LS 5039 during periastron and apastron passages

We have recently studied LS 5039, a gamma-ray binary, with Giant Meterwave Radio Telescope (GMRT) during its periastron and apastron passage. The results presented here show that the spectra are inverted at the low frequency and the flux densities do not differ significantly for two different orbital phases. Assuming that the free-free absorption of radio in stellar wind environment is responsible for the optically thick radio emission we calculated the free-free absorption optical depth and constrained the height of the radio emitting region from the orbital plane. The height is found to be around 1.6 AU for a spherical stellar wind geometry. This estimate may change if the stellar wind is focussed or the radio absorption is due to synchrotron self-absorption.

astro-ph.HE

Macroscopic form of the first law of thermodynamics for an adiabatically evolving non-singular self-gravitating fluid

We emphasize that the pressure related work appearing in a general relativistic first law of thermodynamics should involve {\em proper volume element} rather than coordinate volume element. This point is highlighted by considering both local energy momentum conservation equation as well as particle number conservation equation. It is also emphasized that we are considering here a {\em non-singular} fluid governed by purely classical general relativity. Therefore, we are not considering here any semi-classical or quantum gravity which apparently suggests thermodynamical properties even for a (singular) black hole. Having made such a clarification, we formulate a global first law of thermodynamics for an adiabatically evolving spherical perfect fluid. It may be verified that such a global first law of thermodynamics, {\em for a non-singular fluid}, has not been formulated earlier.

physics.gen-ph

The fallacy of Oppenheimer Snyder Collapse: no general relativistic Collapse at all, no black hole, no physical singularity

By applying Birkhoff's theorem to the problem of the general relativistic collapse of a uniform density dust, we directly show that the density of the dust $ρ=0$ even when its proper number density $n$ would be assumed to be finite! The physical reason behind this exact result can be traced back to the observation of Arnowitt et al. that the gravitational mass of a neutral point particle is zero: $m=0$ (PRL, 4, 375, 1960). And since, a dust is a mere collection of {\em neutral point particles, unlike a continuous hydrodynamic fluid}, its density $ρ= m n=0$. It is nonetheless found that for $k=-1$, a homogeneous dust can collapse and expand special relativistically in the fashion of a Milne universe. Thus, in reality, general relativistic homogeneous dust collapse does not lead to the formation of any black hole in conformity of many previous studies (Logunov, Mestverishvili, Kiselev, Phys.Part.Nucl. 37, 317, 2006; Kisevev, Logunov & Mestvirishvili, Theor. Math. Phys., 164, 972, 2010; Mitra, J. Math. Phys. 50, 042502, 2009; Suggett, J. Phys. A, 12, 375 1979). Interestingly, this result is in agreement with the intuition of Oppenheimer & Snyder (Phys. Rev. 56, p.456, 1939) too: "Physically such a singularity would mean that the expressions used for the energy-momentum tensor does not take into account some essential physical fact which would really smooth the singularity out. Further, a star in its early stages of development would not possess a singular density or pressure, it is impossible for a singularity to develop in a finite time."

physics.gen-ph

No uniform density star in general relativity

As per general relativity (GR), there cannot be any superluminal propagation of energy. And thus, the sound speed in a continuous medium, $c_s=\sqrt{dp/dρ}$, must be subluminal. However, if one would conceive of a {\em homogeneous} fluid, one would have $c_s=\infty$ unless pressure too would be homogeneous. Thus it is universally accepted that the maiden GR interior solution obtained by Schwarzschild, involving a homogeneous fluid having a boundary, is unphysical. However no one has ever shown how this exact solution is in reality devoid of physical reality. Also, this solution is universally used for approximate modelling of general relativistic stars and compact objects. But here first we show that in order that the Kretschmann scalar is continuous, one should have $ρ=0$ for strictly homogeneous static stars. Further, by invoking the fact that in GR, given one time label $t$ one can choose another time label $t_*=f(t)$ {\em without any loss of generality}, we obtain the same result that for a static homogeneous sphere $ρ=0$. Consequently, it is eventually found that the static homogeneous sphere having a boundary is just part of the vacuum where $c_s=0$ rather than $\infty$. Therefore all general relativistic stars must be inhomogeneous.

physics.gen-ph

Likely formation of general relativistic radiation pressure supported stars or "eternally collapsing objects"

Hoyle and Folwler showed that there could be Radiation Pressure Supported Stars (RPSS) even in Newtonian gravity. Much later, Mitra found that one could also conceive of their General Relativistic (GR) version, "Relativistic Radiation Pressure Supported Stars" (RRPSSs). While RPSSs have $z\ll 1$, RRPSSs have $z \gg 1$, where $z$ is the surface gravitational redshift. Here we elaborate on the formation of RRPSSs during continued gravitational collapse by recalling that a contracting massive star must start trapping radiation as it would enter its {\em photon sphere}. It is found that, irrespective of the details of the contraction process, the trapped radiation flux should attain the corresponding Eddington value at sufficiently large $z\gg 1$. This means that continued GR collapse may generate an intermediate RRPSS with $z\gg 1$ before a true BH state with $z=\infty$ is formed asymptotically. An exciting consequence of this is that the stellar mass black hole candidates, at present epoch, should be hot balls of quark gluon plasma, as has been discussed by Royzen in a recent article entitled "{\it QCD against black holes?}".

astro-ph.HE

Quantum Information Paradox: Real or Fictitious?

One of the outstanding puzzles of theoretical physics is whether quantum information indeed gets lost in the case of Black Hole (BH) evaporation or accretion. Let us recall that Quantum Mechanics (QM) demands an upper limit on the acceleration of a test particle. On the other hand, it is pointed out here that, if a Schwarzschild BH would exist, the acceleration of the test particle would blow up at the event horizon in violation of QM. Thus the concept of an exact BH is in contradiction of QM and quantum gravity (QG). It is also reminded that the mass of a BH actually appears as an INTEGRATION CONSTANT of Einstein equations. And it has been shown that the value of this integration constant is actually zero. Thus even classically, there cannot be finite mass BHs though zero mass BH is allowed. It has been further shown that during continued gravitational collapse, radiation emanating from the contracting object gets trapped within it by the runaway gravitational field. As a consequence, the contracting body attains a quasi-static state where outward trapped radiation pressure gets balanced by inward gravitational pull and the ideal classical BH state is never formed in a finite proper time. In other words, continued gravitational collapse results in an "Eternally Collapsing Object" which is a ball of hot plasma and which is asymptotically approaching the true BH state with M=0 after radiating away its entire mass energy. And if we include QM, this contraction must halt at a radius suggested by highest QM acceleration. In any case no EH is ever formed and in reality, there is no quantum information paradox.

physics.gen-ph

Einstein energy associated with the Friedmann -Robertson -Walker metric

Following Einstein's definition of Lagrangian density and gravitational field energy density (Einstein, A., Ann. Phys. Lpz., 49, 806 (1916); Einstein, A., Phys. Z., 19, 115 (1918); Pauli, W., {\it Theory of Relativity}, B.I. Publications, Mumbai, 1963, Trans. by G. Field), Tolman derived a general formula for the total matter plus gravitational field energy ($P_0$) of an arbitrary system (Tolman, R.C., Phys. Rev., 35(8), 875 (1930); Tolman, R.C., {\it Relativity, Thermodynamics & Cosmology}, Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1962)); Xulu, S.S., arXiv:hep-th/0308070 (2003)). For a static isolated system, in quasi-Cartesian coordinates, this formula leads to the well known result $P_0 = \int \sqrt{-g} (T_0^0 - T_1^1 -T_2^2 -T_3^3) ~d^3 x$, where $g$ is the determinant of the metric tensor and $T^a_b$ is the energy momentum tensor of the {\em matter}. Though in the literature, this is known as "Tolman Mass", it must be realized that this is essentially "Einstein Mass" because the underlying pseudo-tensor here is due to Einstein. In fact, Landau -Lifshitz obtained the same expression for the "inertial mass" of a static isolated system without using any pseudo-tensor at all and which points to physical significance and correctness of Einstein Mass (Landau, L.D., and Lifshitz, E.M., {\it The Classical Theory of Fields}, Pergamon Press, Oxford, 2th ed., 1962)! For the first time we apply this general formula to find an expression for $P_0$ for the Friedmann- Robertson -Walker (FRW) metric by using the same quasi-Cartesian basis. As we analyze this new result, physically, a spatially flat model having no cosmological constant is suggested. Eventually, it is seen that conservation of $P_0$ is honoured only in the a static limit.

gr-qc

Cosmological properties of eternally collapsing objects (ECOs)

We show that the integration constant in the vacuum Schwarzschild solution has the unique value, alpha_0=0, accordingly Black Holes too have the same unique value of mass M0=0. Therefore the so-called Black Holes Candidates (BHC) cannot be true BHs. It is also shown that continued collapse of sufficiently massive bodies would generate radiation pressure and energy dominated quasistatic objects having surface gravitational redshifts z>>1. Under the assumption of baryon number conservation, such objects would take infinite time to collapse to the idealized BH state with M=0 and z=infty. The local temperature of such a stellar mass Eternally Collapsing Object (ECO) would be above Quark Gluon Phase transition. ECOs would undergo intermittent violent radiative eruptions and pollute the interstellar medium with freshly made hydrogen out of their QGP and also the light elements cooked in their envelope. It is shown that the extremely redshifted observed temperature of an ECO could be 2.75 K and superposition of ECO background radiation might generate the microwave back ground radiation. The predicted 2.75 K luminosity for the galactic centre ECO, i.e., Sgr A*, L~3x1036 erg/s, nicely matches with the corresponding estimate by Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP).

physics.gen-ph

A New Case For an Eternally Old Universe

We start with a new version of Newtonian cosmology by incorporating the fact that the galaxies are losing mass due to emission of radiation. This yields accelerated recession for the galaxies. We point out that in the presence of accelerated expansion, the universe can be infinitely old and suggest that the observable universe is only a speckle of the true universe. We argue that the mean density of the universe must be zero and the cosmic fluid comprises infinite number of such speckles separated by infinite distances. The Microwave Background radiation is shown to be just the sum of redshifted thermal radiation of Eternally Collapsing Objects (ECO), the so-called Black Hole Candidates.The hot photosphere of the ECOs cooks light elements the same way they are supposed to be produced in hot early universe. This universe with nested infinities has zero baryon number as it contains equal number of matter and antimatter atoms. The predicted microwave luminosity of the galactic centre ECO (Sgr A) nicely matches with the corresponding WMAP estimate (abridged).

physics.gen-ph

Comments on "The Euclidean gravitational action as black hole entropy, singularities, and spacetime voids" by C. Castro, J. Math. Phys., 49, 042501, 2008

We point out that the {\em spacetime void} inferred by Castro[J. Math. Phys. 49, 042501, (2008)] results from his choice of a discontinuous radial gauge. Further since the integration constant $α_0 = 2M_0$ ($G=c=1$) occurring in the vacuum Hilbert/Schwarzschild solution of a neutral "point mass" is zero [Arnowitt et al., in Gravitation: An Introduction to Current Research, ed. L. Witten, Wiley, Chap. 7, p.227; also Phys. Rev. Lett., 4, 375, (1960)]; A. Mitra, Adv. Sp. Res., 38, 2917 (2006)] Castro's gauge reduces to the well behaved and physical Hilbert gauge. Physically this means that true Hilbert/Schwarzschild black holes have unique gravitational mass M=0. Accordingly, the unphysical {\em spacetime viod} inferred by Castro is actually non-existent.

physics.gen-ph

An astrophysical peek into Einstein's static universe

We derive here the metric for Einstein's static universe (ESU) directly from Einstein equation, i.e., by considering both $G_{ik}$ and $T_{ik}$. We find that in order that the fluid pressure and acceleration are {\em uniform} and finite despite the presence of a coordinate singularity, the effective density $ρ_e = ρ+ Λ/8 π=0$, where $Λ$ is the cosmological constant. Under weak energy condition, this would imply $ρ= Λ=0$ for ESU. This means that if one would need to invoke a source of ``repulsive gravity'' in some model, (i) the model must be non-static, (ii) the repulsive gravity must be due to a ``quintessence'' or a ``dark energy'' fluid with negative pressure and appear on the right hand side (RHS) of the Einstein equation through $T_{ij}$ rather than through a fundamental constant residing on the LHS of the same equation, and (iii) energy density of both normal matter and the ``dark energy fluid'' should be time dependent. In fact, the repulsive gravity would be due to a time independent $Λ$, it would be extremely difficult to understand why the associated energy density should be approximately $10^{120}$ times lower than the value predicted by quantum gravity. On the other hand, for a dark energy fluid whose energy density is time dependent, it would be much easier to understand such an extremely low present energy density: the original initial value of the energy density of the fluid could be equal to the quantum gravity value while the present low value is due to decay with time.

physics.gen-ph

Masses of radiation pressure supported stars in extreme relativistic realm

We discuss that in the extreme relativistic limit, i.e., when z >>1, where z is the surface gravitational redshift, there could be radiation pressure supported and dominated stars with arbitrary gravitational mass, high or low. Such Objects are called Eternally Collapsing Objects (ECOs). ECOs are practically as compact as Schwarzschil Black Holes (BH) and, observationally, are likely to be mistaken as BHs. Further since any object undergoing continued collapse must first become an ECO before becoming a true BH state charcterized by M=0, the observed BH Candidates are ECOs.

physics.gen-ph

Does Pressure Increase or Decrease Active Gravitational Mass Density?

It is known that, for a static fluid sphere, the GeneralRelativistic (GR) Effective Mass Energy Density (EMD) appears to be (rho + 3 p), where rho is the bare mass density, p is the isotropic pressure, from a purely localized view point. But since there is no truly local definition of ``gravitational field'', such a notion could actually be misleading. On the other hand, by using the Tolman mass formula, we point out that, from a global perspective, the Active Gravitational Mass Energy Density (AGMD) is sqrt{g_{00}} (rho + 3 p) and which is obviously smaller than (rho + 3p) because g_{00} < 1. Then we show that the AGMD eventually is (rho - 3p), i.e., exactly opposite to what is generally believed. We further identify the AGMD to be proportional to the Ricci Scalar. By using this fundamental and intersting property, we obtain the GR virial theorem in terms of appropriate ``proper energies''.

gr-qc