arXiv subjects

Andrew Humphrey

Publications and source records attributed to Andrew Humphrey.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

arXiv2025

JWST observes the assembly of a massive galaxy at z~4

We present JWST observations of the radio galaxy TGSSJ1530+1049, spectroscopically confirmed at $z=4.0$. NIRCam images and NIRSpec/IFU spectroscopy (R=2700) show that TGSSJ1530+1049 is part of one of the densest-known structures of continuum and line-emitting objects found at these redshifts. NIRCam images show a number of distinct continuum objects and evidence of interactions traced by diffuse emission, and the NIRSpec IFU cube reveals further strong line emitting regions. We identify six continuum and four additional strong H$\alpha$ emitting sources with weaker or no underlying continuum within the 3x3 arcsec IFU field. From spatial alignment with high-resolution radio data and emission line profiles, the radio AGN host galaxy is clearly identified. The bright H$\alpha$ emission (but not the optical components) is distributed remarkably linearly along the radio axis, suggestive of a biconical illumination zone by a central obscured AGN. The emission line kinematics indicate jet-gas interactions on scales of a few kpc. However, due to large relative velocities and presence of underlying continuum, the alignment with the radio structure appears to be, at least partly, caused by a particular configuration of interacting galaxies. At least four objects within a 10x10 (projected) kpc$^2$ area which includes the radio source have high stellar masses ($\log(M_\star/M_\odot)>10.3$) and star formation rates in the range $70-163\,M_\odot$ yr$^{-1}$. Using a stellar mass-based analysis, we predict a total dark matter halo mass of $\approx10^{13} M_\odot$. Based on the physical separations and velocity differences between the galaxies, it is expected that these galaxies will merge to form a massive galaxy within a few Gyr. The system qualitatively resembles the forming brightest cluster galaxies in cosmological simulations that form early through a rapid succession of mergers.

astro-ph.GA↗

arXiv2024

Galaxy Spectra neural Network (GaSNet). II. Using Deep Learning for Spectral Classification and Redshift Predictions

Large sky spectroscopic surveys have reached the scale of photometric surveys in terms of sample sizes and data complexity. These huge datasets require efficient, accurate, and flexible automated tools for data analysis and science exploitation. We present the Galaxy Spectra Network/GaSNet-II, a supervised multi-network deep learning tool for spectra classification and redshift prediction. GaSNet-II can be trained to identify a customized number of classes and optimize the redshift predictions for classified objects in each of them. It also provides redshift errors, using a network-of-networks that reproduces a Monte Carlo test on each spectrum, by randomizing their weight initialization. As a demonstration of the capability of the deep learning pipeline, we use 260k Sloan Digital Sky Survey spectra from Data Release 16, separated into 13 classes including 140k galactic, and 120k extragalactic objects. GaSNet-II achieves 92.4% average classification accuracy over the 13 classes (larger than 90% for the majority of them), and an average redshift error of approximately 0.23% for galaxies and 2.1% for quasars. We further train/test the same pipeline to classify spectra and predict redshifts for a sample of 200k 4MOST mock spectra and 21k publicly released DESI spectra. On 4MOST mock data, we reach 93.4% accuracy in 10-class classification and an average redshift error of 0.55% for galaxies and 0.3% for active galactic nuclei. On DESI data, we reach 96% accuracy in (star/galaxy/quasar only) classification and an average redshift error of 2.8% for galaxies and 4.8% for quasars, despite the small sample size available. GaSNet-II can process ~40k spectra in less than one minute, on a normal Desktop GPU. This makes the pipeline particularly suitable for real-time analyses of Stage-IV survey observations and an ideal tool for feedback loops aimed at night-by-night survey strategy optimization.

astro-ph.IM↗

arXiv2024

Widespread AGN feedback in a forming brightest cluster galaxy at $z=4.1$ unveiled by JWST

We present rest-frame optical spectroscopy using JWST/NIRSpec IFU for the radio galaxy TN J1338-1942 at z=4.1, one of the most luminous galaxies in the early Universe with powerful extended radio jets. Previous observations showed evidence for strong, large-scale outflows on the basis of its large (~150 kpc) halo detected in Ly-alpha, and high velocity [O II] emission features detected in ground-based IFU data. Our NIRSpec/IFU observations spatially resolve the emission line properties across the host galaxy in great detail. We find at least five concentrations of line emission, coinciding with discrete continuum features previously detected in imaging from HST and JWST, over an extent of ~2'' (~15 kpc). The spectral diagnostics enabled by NIRSpec unambiguously trace the activity of the obscured AGN plus interaction between the interstellar medium and the radio jet as the dominant mechanisms for the ionization state and kinematics of the gas in the system. A secondary region of very high ionization lies at roughly 5 kpc distance from the nucleus, and within the context of an expanding cocoon enveloping the radio lobe, this may be explained by strong shock-ionization of the entrained gas. However, it could also signal the presence of a second obscured AGN, which may also offer an explanation for an intriguing outflow feature seen perpendicular to the radio axis. The presence of a dual SMBH system in this galaxy would support that large galaxies in the early Universe quickly accumulated their mass through the merging of smaller units (each with their own SMBH), at the centers of large overdensities. The inferred black hole mass to stellar mass ratio of 0.01-0.1 for TNJ1338 points to a more rapid assembly of black holes compared to the stellar mass of galaxies at high redshifts, consistent with other recent observations.

astro-ph.GA↗

arXiv2023

3D tomography of the giant Ly$α$ nebulae of $z$$\approx$3--5 radio-loud AGN

Ly$α$ emission nebulae are ubiquitous around high-z galaxies and are tracers of the gaseous environment on scales out to >100 kpc. High-z radio galaxies (HzRGs, type-2 radio-loud quasars) host large scale nebulae observed in the ionised gas differ from those seen in other types of high-z quasars. In this work, we exploit MUSE observations of Lya nebulae around eight HzRGs ($2.9<z<4.5$). All the HzRGs have large scale Lya emission nebulae with seven of them extended over 100 kpc at the observed surface brightness (SB) limit. Because the emission line profiles are significantly affected by neutral hydrogen absorbers across the entire nebulae, we perform an absorption correction to infer maps of the intrinsic Lya SB, central velocity and velocity width, all at the last scattering surface of the observed Lya photons. We find: (i) The intrinsic SB radial profiles can be described by an inner exponential and an outter power law; (ii) our HzRGs have higher SB and more asymmetric nebulae than both RL and RQ type-1s; (iii) intrinsic nebula kinematics of four HzRGs show evidence of jet-driven outflows but no general trends for the whole sample; (iv) a relation between the nebula maximum extent and the offset between the AGN and the nebula centroids; (v) an alignment between radio jet position angles and the nebula morphology. All support a scenario where the orientation of the AGN has an impact on the observed nebular morphologies and resonant scattering may affect the shape of the SB profiles, nebular kinematics and relations between the observed Lya morphologies. Furthermore, we find evidence showing that the outskirts of the ionised gas nebulae may be 'contaminated' by Lya photons from nearby emission halos. Overall, this work provides results which allow us to compare Lya nebulae around various classes of quasars at and beyond Cosmic Noon. [Abridged]

astro-ph.GA↗

arXiv2022

Optimized Spectral Energy Distribution for Seyfert Galaxies

The temperature predicted by photoionization models for the Narrow Line Region of Seyfert 2 galaxies is lower than the value inferred from the observed [O III] λ4363A/λ5007A line ratio. We explore the possibility of considering a harder ionizing continuum than typically assumed. The spectral ionizing energy distribution, which can generate the observed λ4363A/λ5007A ratio, is characterized by a secondary continuum peak at 200 eV.

astro-ph.GA↗

arXiv2021

BlueMUSE: Project Overview and Science Cases

We present the concept of BlueMUSE, a blue-optimised, medium spectral resolution, panoramic integral field spectrograph based on the MUSE concept and proposed for the Very Large Telescope. With an optimised transmission down to 350 nm, a larger FoV (1.4 x 1.4 arcmin$^2$) and a higher spectral resolution compared to MUSE, BlueMUSE will open up a new range of galactic and extragalactic science cases allowed by its specific capabilities, beyond those possible with MUSE. For example a survey of massive stars in our galaxy and the Local Group will increase the known population of massive stars by a factor $>$100, to answer key questions about their evolution. Deep field observations with BlueMUSE will also significantly increase samples of Lyman-alpha emitters, spanning the era of Cosmic Noon. This will revolutionise the study of the distant Universe: allowing the intergalactic medium to be detected unambiguously in emission, enabling the study of the exchange of baryons between galaxies and their surroundings. By 2030, at a time when the focus of most of the new large facilities (ELT, JWST) will be on the infra-red, BlueMUSE will be a unique facility, outperforming any ELT instrument in the Blue/UV. It will have a strong synergy with ELT, JWST as well as ALMA, SKA, Euclid and Athena.

astro-ph.IM↗

arXiv2021

Inside-out star formation quenching and the need for a revision of bulge-disk decomposition concepts for spiral galaxies

Our knowledge about the photometric properties of bulges in late-type galaxies (LTGs) is founded upon image decomposition into a Sérsic model for the central luminosity excess of the bulge and an exponential model for the underlying disk. We argue that the standard practice of adopting an exponential model for the disk all the way to its center is inadequate because it implicitly neglects the fact of star formation (SF) quenching (SFQ) in the centers of LTGs. Extrapolating the fit for the observable star-forming zone of the disk (outside the bulge) inwardly overestimates the true surface brightness of the disk in its SF-quenched central zone. We refer to this effect as Dio. The primary consequence of the neglect of Dio in bulge-disk decomposition studies is the oversubtraction of the disk underneath the bulge, leading to a systematic underestimation of the luminosity of the latter. Framed in the picture of galaxy downsizing and inside-out SFQ, Dio is expected to differentially impact galaxies across redshift and stellar mass M*, thus leading to systematic and complex biases in the scatter and slope of various galaxy scaling relations. We conjecture that correction for Dio will lead to a downbending of the bulge vs. super-massive black hole (SMBH) relation for galaxies below log(M*/Msolar)~10.7. A decreasing M(SMBH)/M* ratio with decreasing M* would help consistently explain the scarcity and weakness of accretion-powered nuclear activity in low-mass spiral galaxies. A well detectable Dio (~2 r mag) can emerge early on through inward migration of SF clumps from the disk in combination with a strong contrast of emission-line equivalent widths between the quenched proto-bulge and its SF periphery. Spatially resolved studies with the JWST, ELT, and Euclid could therefore offer key insights into the chronology and physical drivers of SFQ in the early phase of galaxy assembly. (abridged)

astro-ph.GA↗

arXiv2021

Exploring New Redshift Indicators for Radio-Powerful AGN

Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN) are relevant sources of radiation that might have helped reionising the Universe during its early epochs. The super-massive black holes (SMBHs) they host helped accreting material and emitting large amounts of energy into the medium. Recent studies have shown that, for epochs earlier than $z~{\sim}~5$, the number density of SMBHs is on the order of few hundreds per square degree. Latest observations place this value below $300$ SMBHs at $z~{\gtrsim}~6$ for the full sky. To overcome this gap, it is necessary to detect large numbers of sources at the earliest epochs. Given the large areas needed to detect such quantities, using traditional redshift determination techniques -- spectroscopic and photometric redshift -- is no longer an efficient task. Machine Learning (ML) might help obtaining precise redshift for large samples in a fraction of the time used by other methods. We have developed and implemented an ML model which can predict redshift values for WISE-detected AGN in the HETDEX Spring Field. We obtained a median prediction error of $σ_{z}^{N} = 1.48 \times (z_{\mathrm{Predicted}} - z_{\mathrm{True}}) / (1 + z_{\mathrm{True}}) = 0.1162$ and an outlier fraction of $η= 11.58 \%$ at $(z_{\mathrm{Predicted}} - z_{\mathrm{True}}) / (1 + z_{\mathrm{True}}) > 0.15$, in line with previous applications of ML to AGN. We also applied the model to data from the Stripe 82 area obtaining a prediction error of $σ_{z}^{N} = 0.2501$.

astro-ph.GA↗

arXiv2021

Self-consistent population spectral synthesis with FADO: II. Star formation history of galaxies in spectral synthesis methods

The field of galaxy evolution will make a great leap forward in the next decade as a consequence of the huge effort by the scientific community in multi-object spectroscopic facilities. To maximise the impact of such incoming data, the analysis methods must also step up, extracting reliable information from the available spectra. In this paper, we aim to investigate the limits and the reliability of different spectral synthesis methods in the estimation of the mean stellar age and metallicity. The main question this work aims to address is which signal-to-noise ratios (S/N) are needed to reliably determine the mean stellar age and metallicity from a galaxy spectrum and how this depends on the tool used to model the spectra. To address this question we built a set of realistic simulated spectra containing stellar and nebular emission, reproducing the evolution of a galaxy in two limiting cases: a constant star formation rate and an exponentially declining star formation. We degraded the synthetic spectra built from these two star formation histories (SFHs) to different S/N and analysed them with three widely used spectral synthesis codes, namely FADO, STECKMAP, and STARLIGHT. For S/N < 5 all three tools show a large diversity in the results. The FADO and STARLIGHT tools find median differences in the light-weighted mean stellar age of ~0.1 dex, while STECKMAP shows a higher value of ~0.2 dex. Detailed investigations of the best-fit spectrum for galaxies with overestimated mass-weighted quantities point towards the inability of purely stellar models to fit the observed spectra around the Balmer jump. Our results imply that when a galaxy enters a phase of high specific star formation rate the neglect of the nebular continuum emission in the fitting process has a strong impact on the estimation of its SFH when purely stellar fitting codes are used, even in presence of high S/N spectra.

astro-ph.GA↗

arXiv2021

Mapping the "invisible" circumgalactic medium around a z $\sim$ 4.5 radio galaxy with MUSE

In this paper we present Multi Unit Spectroscopic Explorer (MUSE) integral field unit spectroscopic observations of the $\sim70\times30$ kpc$^2$ Ly$α$ halo around the radio galaxy 4C04.11 at $z = 4.5077$. High-redshift radio galaxies (HzRGs) are hosted by some of the most massive galaxies known at any redshift and are unique markers of concomitant powerful active galactic nucleus (AGN) activity and star formation episodes. We map the emission and kinematics of the Ly$α$ across the halo as well as the kinematics and column densities of eight HI absorbing systems at $-3500 < Δv < 0$ km s$^{-1}$. We find that the strong absorber at $Δv \sim 0\,\rm km\,s^{-1}$ has a high areal coverage ($30\times30$ kpc$^2$), being detected across a large extent of the Ly$α$ halo, a significant column density gradient along the southwest to northeast direction, and a velocity gradient along the radio jet axis. We propose that the absorbing structure, which is also seen in CIV and NV absorption, represents an outflowing metal-enriched shell driven by a previous AGN or star formation episode within the galaxy and is now caught up by the radio jet, leading to jet-gas interactions. These observations provide evidence that feedback from AGN in some of the most massive galaxies in the early Universe may play an important role in redistributing material and metals in their environments.

astro-ph.GA↗

arXiv2021

Interactions between the large-scale radio structures and the gas in a sample of optically selected type 2 quasars

The role of radio mode feedback in non radio-loud quasars needs to be explored in depth to determine its true importance. Its effects can be identified based on the evidence of interactions between the radio structures and the ambient ionised gas. We investigate this in a sample of 13 optically selected type-2 quasars (QSO2) at z<0.2 with FIRST radio detections. None are radio loud. All show complex optical morphologies, with signs of distortion across tens of kpc due to mergers/interactions. The radio luminosity has an AGN component in 11/13 QSO2. It is spatially extended in 9 of them (jets/lobes/bubbles/other). The maximum sizes are in the range few kpc to ~500 kpc. Evidence for radio-gas interactions exist in 10/13 QSO2; that is, all but one with confirmed AGN radio components. The interactions are identified across different spatial scales, from the nuclear narrow line region up to tens of kpc from the AGN. Large scale low/modest power radio sources can exist in radio-quiet QSO2, which can provide a source of feedback on scales of the spheroidal component of galaxies and well into the circumgalactic medium in systems where radiative mode feedback is expected to dominate.

astro-ph.GA↗

arXiv2020

HIRES, the high-resolution spectrograph for the ELT

HIRES will be the high-resolution spectrograph of the European Extremely Large Telescope at optical and near-infrared wavelengths. It consists of three fibre-fed spectrographs providing a wavelength coverage of 0.4-1.8 mic (goal 0.35-1.8 mic) at a spectral resolution of ~100,000. The fibre-feeding allows HIRES to have several, interchangeable observing modes including a SCAO module and a small diffraction-limited IFU in the NIR. Therefore, it will be able to operate both in seeing and diffraction-limited modes. ELT-HIRES has a wide range of science cases spanning nearly all areas of research in astrophysics and even fundamental physics. Some of the top science cases will be the detection of bio signatures from exoplanet atmospheres, finding the fingerprints of the first generation of stars (PopIII), tests on the stability of Nature's fundamental couplings, and the direct detection of the cosmic acceleration. The HIRES consortium is composed of more than 30 institutes from 14 countries, forming a team of more than 200 scientists and engineers.

astro-ph.IM↗

arXiv2020

The peculiar emission line spectra of core-Extremely Red BOSS Quasars at $z\sim$2-3: orientation and/or evolution?

Core-extremely red quasars (core-ERQ) have been proposed to represent an intermediate evolutionary phase in which a heavily obscured quasar is blowing out the circumnuclear interstellar medium with very energetic outflows prior to becoming an optical quasar. We revise the general UV and optical emission line properties of core-ERQ in the context of the AGN orientation-based unification scenario. We use diagnostic diagrams based on ultraviolet (UV) emission line ratios and UV-optical line kinematic information to compare the physical and kinematic gas properties of core-ERQ with those of other luminous narrow and broad line AGN. In particular, we provide a revised comparison of the [OIII] kinematics in 21 core-ERQ with other samples of quasars matched in luminosity with the aim of evaluating whether core-ERQ host the most extreme [OIII] outflows. The UV line ratios suggest that the physical properties (for instance, density, metallicity) of the ionised gas in core-ERQ are similar to those observed in the BLR of blue Nitrogen-loud QSOs. The [OIII] outflow velocities of core-ERQ are, on average, consistent with those of very luminous blue QSO1, although extreme outflows are much more frequent in core-ERQ. These similarities can be explained in the context of the AGN unification model, assuming that core-ERQ are viewed with an intermediate orientation between type 2 (edge-on) and type 1 (face-on) QSOs. We propose that core-ERQ are very luminous but otherwise normal quasars viewed at an intermediate orientation. Such orientation allows a direct view of the outer part of the large BLR, from which core-ERQ UV emission originates; the extreme [OIII] outflow velocities are instead a consequence of the very high luminosity of core-ERQ.

astro-ph.GA↗

arXiv2019

Structural analysis of massive galaxies using HST deep imaging at z < 0.5

Taking advantage of HST CANDELS data, we analyze the lowest redshift (z<0.5) massive galaxies in order to disentangle their structural constituents and study possible faint non-axis-symmetric features. Due to the excellent HST spatial resolution for intermediate-z objects, they are hard to model by purely automatic parametric fitting algorithms. We performed careful single and double Sérsic fits to their galaxy surface brightness profiles. We also compare the model color profiles with the observed ones and also derive multi-component global effective radii attempting to obtain a better interpretation of the mass-size relation. Additionally, we test the robustness of our measured structural parameters via simulations. We find that the Sérsic index does not offer a good proxy for the visual morphological type for our sample of massive galaxies. Our derived multi-component effective radii give a better description of the size of our sample galaxies than those inferred from single Sérsic models with GALFIT. Our galaxy population lays on the scatter of the local mass-size relation, indicating that these massive galaxies do not experience a significant growth in size since z~0.5. Interestingly the few outliers are late-type galaxies, indicating that spheroids must reach the local mass-size relation earlier. For most of our sample galaxies, both single and multi-component Sérsic models with GALFIT show substantial systematic deviations from the observed SBPs in the outskirts. These residuals may be partly due to several factors, namely a non-optimal data reduction for low surface brightness features, the existence of prominent stellar haloes for massive galaxies and could also arise from conceptual shortcomings of parametric 2D image decomposition tools. They consequently propagate into galaxy color profiles.

astro-ph.GA↗

arXiv2017

A 100 kpc nebula associated with the "Teacup" fading quasar

We report the discovery of a ~100 kpc ionized nebula associated with the radio quiet type 2 quasar (QSO2) nicknamed the "Teacup" (z=0.085). The giant nebula is among the largest known around active galaxies at any z. We propose that it is part of the circumgalactic medium (CGM) of the QSO2 host, which has been populated with tidal debris by galactic interactions. This rich gaseous medium has been rendered visible due to the illumination by the powerful active nucleus (AGN). Subsolar abundances (~0.5Z(sun)) are tentatively favored by AGN photoionization models. We also report the detection of coronal emission (Fe+6) from the NE bubble, at ~9 kpc from the AGN. The detection of coronal lines at such large distances from the AGN and the [NII]/Halpha, [SII]/Halpha, [OI]/Halpha optical emission line ratios of the giant nebula are consistent with the fading quasar scenario proposed by Gagne et al. (2014). The fading rate appears to have been faster in the last ~46,000 yr. Deep wide field integral field spectroscopy of giant nebulae around powerful AGN such as the "Teacup's" with instruments such as MUSE on VLT opens up a way to detect and study the elusive material from the CGM around massive active galaxies thanks to the illumination by the luminous AGN.

astro-ph.GA↗

arXiv2017

Galaxy wide radio induced feedback in a radio quiet quasar

We report the discovery of a radio quiet type 2 quasar (SDSS J165315.06+234943.0 nicknamed the "Beetle" at z=0.103) with unambiguous evidence for active galactic nucleus (AGN) radio induced feedback acting across a total extension of ~46 kpc and up to ~26 kpc from the AGN. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first radio quiet system where radio induced feedback has been securely identified at >>several kpc from the AGN. Turbulent gas is also found far from the radio axis, ~25 kpc in the perpendicular direction. We propose a scenario in which the radio structures have perforated the interstellar medium of the galaxy and escaped into the circumgalactic medium. While advancing, they have interacted with in-situ gas modifying its properties. Our results show that jets of modest power can be the dominant feedback mechanism acting across huge volumes in radio quiet systems, including highly accreting luminous AGN, where radiative mode feedback may be expected.

astro-ph.GA↗

arXiv2016

MUSE 3D Spectroscopy and Kinematics of the gigahertz peaked spectrum Radio Galaxy PKS 1934-63: Interaction, Recently Triggered AGN and Star Formation

We observe the radio galaxy PKS 1934-63 (at $z=0.1825$) using MUSE (Multi Unit Spectroscopic Explorer) on the Very Large Telescope (VLT). The radio source is GigaHertz Peaked Spectrum and compact (0.13 kpc), implying an early stage of evolution ($\leq 10^4$ yr). Our data show an interacting pair of galaxies, projected separation 9.1 kpc, velocity difference $Δ(v)=216$ km $\rm s^{-1}$. The larger galaxy is a $\rm M_{*}\simeq 10^{11}M_{\odot}$ spheroidal with the emission-line spectrum of a high-excitation young radio AGN, e.g. strong [OI]6300 and [OIII]5007. Emission-line ratios indicate a large contribution to the line luminosity from high-velocity shocks ($\simeq 550$ km $\rm s^{-1}$) . The companion is a non-AGN disk galaxy, with extended $\rm Hα$ emission from which its star-formation rate is estimated as $\rm 0.61~M_{\odot}yr^{-1}$. Both galaxies show rotational velocity gradients in $\rm Hα$ and other lines, with the interaction being prograde-prograde. The SE-NW velocity gradient of the AGN host is misaligned from the E-W radio axis, but aligned with a previously discovered central ultraviolet source, and a factor 2 greater in amplitude in $\rm Hα$ than in other (forbidden) lines (e.g. [OIII]5007). This could be produced by a fast rotating (100-150 km $\rm s^{-1}$) disk with circumnuclear star-formation. We also identify a broad component of [OIII]5007 emission, blueshifted with a velocity gradient aligned with the radio jets, and associated with outflow. However, the broad component of [OI]6300 is redshifted. In spectral fits, both galaxies have old stellar populations plus $\sim 0.1\%$ of very young stars, consistent with the galaxies undergoing first perigalacticon, triggering infall and star-formation from $\sim 40$ Myr ago followed by the radio outburst.

astro-ph.GA↗

arXiv2016

Ionized outflows in luminous type 2 AGNs at z<0.6: no evidence for significant impact on the host galaxies

We investigate the presence of extended ionized outflows in 18 luminous type 2 AGNs (11 quasars and 7 high luminosity Seyfert 2s) at 0.3 =severalx100 pc and upper limits R<1-2 kpc. Our results are inconsistent with related studies which suggest that large scale R~several-15 kpc are ubiquitous in QSO2. We study the possible causes of discrepancy and propose that seeing smearing is the cause of the large inferred sizes. The implications in our understanding of the feedback phenomenon are important since the mass M (through the density), mass injection M(dot) and energy injection rates E(dot) of the outflows become highly uncertain. One conclusion seems unavoidable: M, M(dot), E(dot) are modest or low compared with previous estimations. No evidence is found supporting that typical outflows can affect the interstellar medium of the host galaxies accross spatial scales >~1-2 kpc.

astro-ph.GA↗