SearcharxivSearch

arXiv subjects

Aseel Farhat

Publications and source records attributed to Aseel Farhat.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

A critical note on back-and-forth Data Assimilation Nudging Algorithm

This work investigates the effectiveness of the Back-and-Forth Nudging (BFN) data assimilation algorithm, specifically its performance when employing the Azouani-Olson-Titi (AOT) continuous data assimilation downscaling nudging algorithm, for recovering initial conditions of dissipative dynamical systems. Contrary to previous reports in the literature, we show that, for several systems of interest, one can construct initial conditions that BFN cannot reliably recover. Our key finding is the construction of infinitely many distinct solutions for certain dissipative systems that share identical spatially sparse observational data. Since these observations are indistinguishable, no data assimilation method relying only on them can differentiate between these solutions or recover the correct initial condition. We illustrate these pathological initial conditions for the Lorenz 1963 model and several 1D partial differential equations: the heat equation, viscous linear transport, and viscous and inviscid Burgers equations. Our analytical results are supported by numerical simulations. To address the numerical ill-posedness of backward-in-time iterations, an essential step of BFN for dissipative models, we introduce a regularized backward step, the Voigt-regularized BFN (VBFN). We investigate its performance for the 2D Navier-Stokes equations and the viscous 1D KdV equation, comparing it with standard BFN and Diffusive BFN (dBFN). While VBFN improves numerical stability and reduces model bias relative to dBFN, it still cannot reconstruct the unobserved fine spatial scales of the reference solution. This reinforces our main conclusion: even with regularization, BFN-type algorithms are limited in recovering the full state, and in particular the initial data, from sparse spatial observations.

math.AP

On the nudging approach to continuous data assimilation in the limit of infinite error feedback gain

This article studies the intimate relationship between two filtering algorithms for continuous data assimilation, the synchronization filter and the nudging filter, in the paradigmatic context of the two-dimensional (2D) Navier-Stokes equations (NSE) for incompressible fluids. In this setting, the nudging filter can formally be viewed as an affine perturbation of the 2D NSE. Thus, in the degenerate limit of zero nudging parameter, the nudging filter converges to the solution of the 2D NSE. However, when the nudging parameter of the nudging filter is large, the perturbation becomes singular. It is shown that in the singular limit of infinite nudging parameter, the nudging filter converges to the synchronization filter. In establishing this result, the article fills a notable gap in the literature surrounding these algorithms. Numerical experiments are then presented that confirm the theoretical results and probes the issue of selecting a nudging strategy in the presence of observational noise. In this direction, an adaptive nudging strategy is proposed that leverages the insight gained from the relationship between the synchronization filter and the nudging filter that produces measurable improvement over the constant nudging strategy.

math.AP

Determining Modes, State Reconstruction, and Intertwinement: A Synchronization Framework

This article studies the interrelation between the determining modes property in the two-dimensional (2D) Navier-Stokes equations (NSE) of incompressible fluids and the reconstruction property of two filtering algorithms for continuous data assimilation applied to the 2D NSE. These two properties are realized as manifestations of a more general phenomenon of "self-synchronous intertwinement." It is shown that this concept is a logically stronger form of asymptotic enslavement, as characterized by the existence of finitely many determining modes in the 2D NSE. In particular, this stronger form is shown to imply convergence of the direct-replacement filter and the nudging filter from continuous data assimilation (CDA), and then subsequently invoked to show that convergence in these filters implies that the 2D NSE possesses finitely many determining modes. The main achievement of this article is to therefore to develop a new conceptual framework, that of self-synchronous intertwinement, through which the precise inter-relationship between the determining modes property and synchronization phenomenon in these CDA filters is rigorously established and made decisively clear. The theoretical results are then complemented by numerical experiments that confirm the conclusions of the theorems.

math.AP

Determining Modes, State Reconstruction, and Intertwinement: Existence of Self-Synchronizing Intertwinements

In the companion paper of the authors, a general synchronization framework was developed in the paradigmatic context of the 2D Navier-Stokes equations that allows one to precisely study the relation between the determining modes property of the corresponding dynamical system and the ability of certain continuous data assimilation algorithms to reconstruct unobserved state variables from sufficiently many observed state variables in this system, i.e., the reconstruction property. In this framework, the determining modes property and the reconstruction property can be viewed in a unified way as the ability of certain couplings of the Navier-Stokes equations to self-synchronize; due to the bi-directionality of coupling, the coupled system is referred to as an "intertwinement." A central achievement of this framework is to deduce a conceptual equivalence between the determining modes property and the reconstruction property of continuous data assimilation algorithms. In this paper, we prove that there are at least two non-trivial classes of intertwinements to which this framework applies. Moreover, these intertwinements encompass the continuous data assimilation algorithms studied in (Olson, Titi 2003) and (Azouani, Olson, Titi 2014) as special cases. Specifically, we show that there exist two types of intertwinements that are globally well-posed and we identify conditions under which these intertwinements self-synchronize. We emphasize that the intertwinements studied here can be induced by nonlinear perturbations of the underlying system, which are subsequently coupled bi-directionally to a copy of itself. Thus, establishing global well-posedness and suitable global-in-time uniform bounds, which are crucial to proving the claimed synchronization phenomenon, requires careful consideration.

math.AP

Upper bounds on the dimension of the global attractor of the 2D Navier-Stokes equations on the $β-$plane

This article establishes estimates on the dimension of the global attractor of the two-dimensional rotating Navier-Stokes equation for viscous, incompressible fluids on the $β$-plane. Previous results in this setting by M.A.H. Al-Jaboori and D. Wirosoetisno (2011) had proved that the global attractor collapses to a single point that depends only the longitudinal coordinate, i.e., zonal flow, when the rotation is sufficiently fast. However, an explicit quantification of the complexity of the global attractor in terms of $β$ had remained open. In this paper, such estimates are established which are valid across a wide regime of rotation rates and are consistent with the dynamically degenerate regime previously identified. Additionally, a decomposition of solutions is established detailing the asymptotic behavior of the solutions in the limit of large rotation.

math.AP

On persistence of spatial analyticity in the hyper-dissipative Navier-Stokes models

The goal of this note is to demonstrate that as soon as the hyper-diffusion exponent is greater than one, a class of finite time blow-up scenarios consistent with the analytic structure of the flow (prior to the possible blow-up time) can be ruled out. The argument is self-contained, in spirit of the regularity theory of the hyper-dissipative Navier-Stokes system in turbulent regime developed by Grujic and Xu.

math.AP

Identifying the body force from partial observations of a 2D incompressible velocity field

Using limited observations of the velocity field of the two-dimensional Navier-Stokes equations, we successfully reconstruct the steady body force that drives the flow. The number of observed data points is less than 10\% of the number of modes that describes the full flow field, indicating that the method introduced here is capable of identifying complicated forcing mechanisms from a relatively small collection of observations. In addition to demonstrating the efficacy of this method on turbulent flow data generated by simulations of the two-dimensional Navier-Stokes equations, we also rigorously justify convergence of the derived algorithm. Beyond the practical applicability of such an algorithm, the reliance of this method on the dynamical evolution of the system yields physical insight into the turbulent cascade.

physics.flu-dyn

Time-Dependent Duhamel Renormalization method with Multiple Conservation and Dissipation Laws

The time dependent spectral renormalization (TDSR) method was introduced by Cole and Musslimani as a novel way to numerically solve initial boundary value problems. An important and novel aspect of the TDSR scheme is its ability to incorporate physics in the form of conservation laws or dissipation rate equations. However, the method was limited to include a single conserved or dissipative quantity. The present work significantly extends the computational features of the method with the (i) incorporation of multiple conservation laws and/or dissipation rate equations, (ii) ability to enforce versatile boundary conditions, and (iii) higher order time integration strategy. The TDSR method is applied on several prototypical evolution equations of physical significance. Examples include the Korteweg-de Vries (KdV), multi-dimensional nonlinear Schrödinger (NLS) and the Allen-Cahn equations.

math.NA

Local near-Beltrami structure and depletion of the nonlinearity in the 3D Navier-Stokes flows

Computational simulations of turbulent flows indicate that the regions of low dissipation/enstrophy production feature high degree of local alignment between the velocity and the vorticty, i.e., the flow is locally near-Beltrami. Hence one could envision a geometric scenario in which the persistence of the local near-Beltramy property might be consistent with a (possible) finite-time singularity formation. The goal of this note is to show that this scenario is in fact prohibited if the sine of the angle between the velocity and the vorticty is small enough with respect to the local enstrophy.

math.AP

An algebraic reduction of the `scaling gap' in the Navier-Stokes regularity problem

It is shown--within a mathematical framework based on the suitably defined scale of sparseness of the super-level sets of the positive and negative parts of the vorticity components, and in the context of a blow-up-type argument--that the ever-resisting `scaling gap', i.e., the scaling distance between a regularity criterion and a corresponding a priori bound (shortly, a measure of the super-criticality of the 3D Navier-Stokes regularity problem), can be reduced by an algebraic factor; since (independent) fundamental works of Ladyzhenskaya, Prodi and Serrin as well as Kato and Fujita in 1960s, all the reductions have been logarithmic in nature, regardless of the functional set up utilized. More precisely, it is shown that it is possible to obtain an a priori bound that is algebraically better than the energy-level bound, while keeping the corresponding regularity criterion at the same level as all the classical regularity criteria. The mathematics presented was inspired by morphology of the regions of intense vorticity/velocity gradients observed in computational simulations of turbulent flows, as well as by the physics of turbulent cascades and turbulent dissipation.

math.AP

Assimilation of nearly turbulent Rayleigh-B\'enard flow through vorticity or local circulation measurements: a computational study

We introduce a continuous (downscaling) data assimilation algorithm for the 2D B\'enard convection problem using vorticity or local circulation measurements only. In this algorithm, a nudging term is added to the vorticity equation to constrain the model. Our numerical results indicate that the approximate solution of the algorithm is converging to the unknown reference solution (vorticity and temperature) corresponding to the measurements of the 2D B\'enard convection problem when only spatial coarse-grain measurements of vorticity are assimilated. Moreover, this convergence is realized using data which is much more coarse than the resolution needed to satisfy rigorous analytical estimates.

math.AP

A data assimilation algorithm: the paradigm of the 3D Leray-alpha model of turbulence

In this paper we survey the various implementations of a new data assimilation (downscaling) algorithm based on spatial coarse mesh measurements. As a paradigm, we demonstrate the application of this algorithm to the 3D Leray-$α$ subgrid scale turbulence model. Most importantly, we use this paradigm to show that it is not always necessary that one has to collect coarse mesh measurements of all the state variables, that are involved in the underlying evolutionary system, in order to recover the corresponding exact reference solution. Specifically, we show that in the case of the 3D Leray$-α$ model of turbulence the solutions of the algorithm, constructed using only coarse mesh observations of any two components of the three-dimensional velocity field, and without any information of the third component, converge, at an exponential rate in time, to the corresponding exact reference solution of the 3D Leray$-α$ model. This study serves as an addendum to our recent work on abridged continuous data assimilation for the 2D Navier-Stokes equations. Notably, similar results have also been recently established for the 3D viscous Planetary Geostrophic circulation model in which we show that coarse mesh measurements of the temperature alone are sufficient for recovering, through our data assimilation algorithm, the full solution; viz. the three components of velocity vector field and the temperature. Consequently, this proves the Charney conjecture for the 3D Planetary Geostrophic model; namely, that the history of the large spatial scales of temperature is sufficient for determining all the other quantities (state variables) of the model.

math.AP

On the Charney Conjecture of Data Assimilation Employing Temperature Measurements Alone: The Paradigm of 3D Planetary Geostrophic Model

Analyzing the validity and success of a data assimilation algorithm when some state variable observations are not available is an important problem in meteorology and engineering. We present an improved data assimilation algorithm for recovering the exact full reference solution (i.e. the velocity and temperature) of the 3D Planetary Geostrophic model, at an exponential rate in time, by employing coarse spatial mesh observations of the temperature alone. This provides, in the case of this paradigm, a rigorous justification to an earlier conjecture of Charney which states that temperature history of the atmosphere, for certain simple atmospheric models, determines all other state variables.

math.AP

Continuous Data Assimilation for a 2D Bénard Convection System through Horizontal Velocity Measurements Alone

In this paper we propose a continuous data assimilation (downscaling) algorithm for a two-dimensional Bénard convection problem. Specifically we consider the two-dimensional Boussinesq system of a layer of incompressible fluid between two solid horizontal walls, with no-normal flow and stress free boundary condition on the walls, and fluid is heated from the bottom and cooled from the top. In this algorithm, we incorporate the observables as a feedback (nudging) term in the evolution equation of the horizontal velocity. We show that under an appropriate choice of the nudging parameter and the size of the spatial coarse mesh observables, and under the assumption that the observed data is error free, the solution of the proposed algorithm converges at an exponential rate, asymptotically in time, to the unique exact unknown reference solution of the original system, associated with the observed data on the horizontal component of the velocity. Moreover, we note that in the case where the observational measurements are not error free, one can estimate the error between the solution of the algorithm and the exact reference solution of the system in terms of the error in the measurements.

math.AP

Data Assimilation algorithm for 3D Bénard convection in porous media employing only temperature measurements

In this paper we propose a continuous data assimilation (downscaling) algorithm for the Bénard convection in porous media using only coarse mesh measurements of the temperature. In this algorithm, we incorporate the observables as a feedback (nudging) term in the evolution equation of the temperature. We show that under an appropriate choice of the nudging parameter and the size of the mesh, and under the assumption that the observed data is error free, the solution of the proposed algorithm converges at an exponential rate, asymptotically in time, to the unique exact unknown reference solution of the original system, associated with the observed (finite dimensional projection of) temperature data. Moreover, we note that in the case where the observational measurements are not error free, one can estimate the error between the solution of the algorithm and the exact reference solution of the system in terms of the error in the measurements.

math.AP

Abridged continuous data assimilation for the 2D Navier-Stokes equations utilizing measurements of only one component of the velocity field

We introduce a continuous data assimilation (downscaling) algorithm for the two-dimensional Navier-Stokes equations employing coarse mesh measurements of only one component of the velocity field. This algorithm can be implemented with a variety of finitely many observables: low Fourier modes, nodal values, finite volume averages, or finite elements. We provide conditions on the spatial resolution of the observed data, under the assumption that the observed data is free of noise, which are sufficient to show that the solution of the algorithm approaches, at an exponential rate asymptotically in time, to the unique exact unknown reference solution, of the 2D Navier-Stokes equations, associated with the observed (finite dimensional projection of) velocity.

math.AP

Continuous Data Assimilation for the 2D Bénard Convection through Velocity Measurements Alone

An algorithm for continuous data assimilation for the two- dimensional Bénard convection problem is introduced and analyzed. It is inspired by the data assimilation algorithm developed for the Navier-Stokes equations, which allows for the implementation of variety of observables: low Fourier modes, nodal values, finite volume averages, and finite elements. The novelty here is that the observed data is obtained for the velocity field alone; i.e. no temperature measurements are needed for this algorithm. We provide conditions on the spatial resolution of the observed data, under the assumption that the observed data is free of noise, which are sufficient to show that the solution of the algorithm approaches, at an exponential rate, the unique exact unknown solution of the Bénard convection problem associated with the observed (finite dimensional projection of) velocity.

math.AP