Searcharxiv⌕ Search

arXiv subjects

Benedikt Schuler

Publications and source records attributed to Benedikt Schuler.

2 recordsLinked to original sources

Exploring Low-Regret Energy System Transition Pathways with Modeling to Generate Alternatives

Long-term planning of energy system transitions is complex due to interdependent investment decisions and uncertain market and policy conditions. Stochastic optimization models account for this uncertainty by identifying a single optimal hedging strategy. However, the flexibility in technology choice and investment timing, i.e., the transition flexibility, usually remains unexplored. Modeling to generate alternatives (MGA) explores near-optimal solution spaces but has not been coupled with stochastic optimization to quantify the transition flexibility. We explore the low-regret pathway space, i.e., all transition pathways that stay within a chosen regret tolerance in every scenario. We introduce a termination criterion for MGA that bounds the exploration error in high-dimensional solution spaces and measure how far each pathway decision, once taken, narrows the capacity ranges of the others. We apply the method to an industrial energy system in Germany. The pathway that minimizes the worst-case regret keeps it at 2.2%, compared with up to 30.9% for perfect-foresight pathways. The transition flexibility increases most at low regret tolerances. At 3.5%, the capacity ranges are on average about 60% as wide as at the highest regret tolerance of 10%. A large share of these capacity ranges is surplus capacity, i.e., capacity installed in addition to, not instead of, other capacity. Surplus capacity is largely not operated but, once installed, narrows the other capacity ranges more strongly than operated capacity. Exploring the low-regret pathway space, rather than reporting a single optimal pathway, therefore is the more informative basis for planning energy system transitions under uncertainty.

math.OC↗

Gotta catch 'em all: Modeling All Discrete Alternatives for Industrial Energy System Transitions

Industrial decision-makers often base decisions on mathematical optimization models to achieve cost-efficient design solutions in energy transitions. However, since a model can only approximate reality, the optimal solution is not necessarily the best real-world energy system. Exploring near-optimal design spaces, e.g., by the Modeling All Alternatives (MAA) method, provides a more holistic view of decision alternatives beyond the cost-optimal solution. However, the MAA method misses out on discrete in-vestment decisions. Incorporating such discrete investment decisions is crucial when modeling industrial energy systems. Our work extends the MAA method by integrating discrete design decisions. We optimize the design and operation of an industrial energy system transformation using a mixed-integer linear program. First, we explore the continuous, near-optimal design space by applying the MAA method. Thereafter, we sample all discrete design alternatives from the continuous, near-optimal design space. In a case study, we apply our method to identify all near-optimal design alternatives of an industrial energy system. We find 128 near-optimal design alternatives where costs are allowed to increase to a maximum of one percent offering decision-makers more flexibility in their investment decisions. Our work enables the analysis of discrete design alternatives for industrial energy transitions and supports the decision-making process for investments in energy infrastructure.

math.OC↗