Searcharxiv⌕ Search

arXiv subjects

Boris Botvinnik

Publications and source records attributed to Boris Botvinnik.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

Canonical metrics on punctured spheres, I: the mass matrix and the polygon model

A canonical metric $g_{\mathfrak{p}_{\ell}}$ on $S^n \setminus \mathfrak{p}_{\ell}$, where $\mathfrak{p}_{\ell}=(p_1,\ldots,p_{\ell})$ and $n \ge 3$, is a metric conformal to the round metric that is complete, scalar-flat, and asymptotically flat at each puncture $p_i$. For $n=3$ these metrics are the Brill--Lindquist time-symmetric initial data for $\ell$ black holes, and their ends carry ADM masses. In this paper we study the masses, through the mass matrix, as functions on the conformal moduli space $M_{\ell}(S^n)$. The mass matrix $η=(η_{ij})$ is a symmetric matrix with zero diagonal and vanishing row sums (these matrices form the space $H_{\ell}$), and it determines the \emph{normalized ADM mass} at the $i$-th end via $\hat{\mathfrak{m}}_i=\sum_{j\ne i}e^{η_{ij}}$. We prove that the mass map $Ξ\colon M_\ell(S^n)\to H_{\ell}$ is a homeomorphism onto its image. On the other hand, the moduli space $\mathcal{M}_\ell(S^n)$ is homeomorphic to the moduli space of those equilateral $\ell$-gons in the hyperbolic space $\mathbb{H}^{n+1}$ whose sides, extended to infinity, end at distinct points (the Gauss map). By a theorem of Kapovich--Leeb--Millson and Balser, every polystable configuration is the Gauss image of such a polygon, and the Gauss map identifies the space of all equilateral $\ell$-gons with a natural compactification of $M_\ell(S^n)$. In particular, the mass matrix has an explicit description in terms of the pairwise vertex distances of the polygon. The mass matrix diverges as punctures collide. The degeneration, its renormalization, and the resulting compactification of the moduli space are the subject of a sequel to this paper.

math.DG↗

Canonical metrics on punctured spheres, II: compactified moduli spaces of black holes

Let $g_{\mathfrak{p}_{\ell}}$ denote the canonical scalar-flat metric on $S^n\setminus \mathfrak{p}_{\ell}$ introduced in Part~I, which for $n=3$ corresponds to the Brill--Lindquist initial data for $\ell$ black holes, and let $η\in H_{\ell}$ be its associated mass matrix. In this paper, we investigate the asymptotic behavior of the metrics and the mass matrix $η$ as subsets of punctures collide. Such collisions cause every mass to diverge; if a cluster $A$ of black holes collapses at a relative scale $t$, the mass matrix satisfies $η=E(A)\ln(1/t)+O(1)$, diverging along an explicit ray $E(A)\in H_{\ell}$. For nested families of clusters, this degeneracy structure naturally organizes into a space of rooted trees. Subtracting the divergence gives a renormalized mass matrix which extends smoothly to every stratum of the Axelrod--Singer compactified moduli space $\overline{M}{}^{\,\mathrm{AS}}_\ell= \overline C_{\ell-1}(\mathbb{R}^n)/\mathrm O(n)$ and splits naturally into one mass matrix per vertex of the bubble tree. Geometrically, at each vertex carrying punctures the suitably rescaled metrics converge to a complete scalar-flat metric with the nodes filled in, adjacent such pieces being joined by Schwarzschild necks, and the renormalized matrix acting as its mass data. For $n=3$, the necks contain minimal spheres, which are common apparent horizons of the merging holes. At vertices bearing two holes, we determine on which side of the limiting horizon each node lies, and we formulate as a conjecture the resulting criterion for a neck to be a component of the outermost horizon. We also compare the mass lower bound of Part~I with the Riemannian Penrose inequality. Because the mass matrix is invariant under rotations of the bubbles, it lives on a Deligne--Mumford-type quotient of the compactification.

gr-qc↗

Positive scalar curvature on manifolds with fibered singularities

A (compact) manifold with fibered $P$-singularities is a (possibly) singular pseudomanifold $M_Σ$ with two strata: an open nonsingular stratum $\mathring M$ (a smooth open manifold) and a closed stratum $βM$ (a closed manifold of positive codimension), such that a tubular neighborhood of $βM$ is a fiber bundle with fibers each looking like the cone on a fixed closed manifold $P$. We discuss what it means for such an $M_Σ$ with fibered $P$-singularities to admit an appropriate Riemannian metric of positive scalar curvature, and we give necessary and sufficient conditions (the necessary conditions based on suitable versions of index theory, the sufficient conditions based on surgery methods and homotopy theory) for this to happen when the singularity type $P$ is either $\mathbb Z/k$ or $S^1$, and $M$ and the boundary of the tubular neighborhood of the singular stratum are simply connected and carry spin structures. Along the way, we prove some results of perhaps independent interest, concerning metrics on spin$^c$ manifolds with positive "twisted scalar curvature," where the twisting comes from the curvature of the spin$^c$ line bundle.

math.DG↗

Brunnian links and Kontsevich graph complex I

We construct a natural chain map from the Kontsevich graph complex to the rational singular chain complex of $B\mathrm{Diff}_\partial(D^{2k})$ when the dimension $2k$ is sufficiently large, generalizing Goussarov and Habiro's theories of surgery on 3-valent graphs in 3-manifolds. Our construction can be considered as a topological realization of the Kontsevich graph complex. We also give new constructions of elements in the rational homotopy groups of $B\mathrm{Diff}_\partial(D^{2k})$ which are determined by well-known cycles in the graph complex.

math.GT↗

Classification of spin$^c$ manifolds with generalized positive scalar curvature

Suppose $M$ is a closed $n$-dimensional spin$^c$ manifold with spin$^c$ structure $σ$ and associated spin$^c$ line bundle $L$. If one fixes a Riemannian metric $g$ on $M$ and a connection $\nabla_L$ on $L$, the generalized scalar curvature $R^{\text{gen}}$ of $(M,L)$ is $R_g - 2|Ω_L|_{\text{op}}$, where $|Ω_L|_{\text{op}}$ is the pointwise operator norm of the curvature $2$-form $Ω_L$ of $\nabla_L$, acting on spinors. In a previous paper, we showed that positivity of $R^{\text{gen}}$ is obstructed by the non-vanishing of the index of the spin$^c$ Dirac operator on $(M,g,L,\nabla_L)$, and that in some cases, the vanishing of this index guarantees the existence of a pair $(g,\nabla_L)$ with positive generalized scalar curvature. Building on this and on surgery techniques inspired by those that have been developed in the theory of positive scalar curvature on spin manifolds, we show that if $\dim M = n \ge 5$, if the fundamental group $π$ of $M$ is in a large class including surface groups and finite groups with periodic cohomology, and if $M$ is totally non-spin (meaning that the universal cover is not spin), then $(M,L)$ admits positive generalized scalar curvature if and only if the generalized $α$-invariant of $(M,L)$ vanishes in the $K$-homology group $K_n(Bπ)$. We also develop an analogue of Stolz's sequence for computing the group of concordance classes of positive generalized scalar curvature metrics, and connect this to the analytic surgery sequence of Roe and Higson. Finally, we give a number of applications to moduli spaces of positive generalized scalar curvature metrics.

math.DG↗

Symmetries of exotic spheres via complex and quaternionic Mahowald invariants

We use new homotopy-theoretic tools to prove the existence of smooth $U(1)$- and $Sp(1)$-actions on infinite families of exotic spheres. Such families of spheres are propagated by the complex and quaternionic analogues of the Mahowald invariant (also known as the root invariant). In particular, we prove that the complex (respectively, quaternionic) Mahowald invariant takes an element of the $k$-th stable stem $π_k^s$ represented by a homotopy sphere $Σ^k$ to an element of a higher stable stem $π_{k+\ell}^s$ represented by another homotopy sphere $Σ^{k+\ell}$ equipped with a smooth $U(1)$- (respectively, $Sp(1)$-) action with fixed points the original homotopy sphere $Σ^k\subset Σ^{k+\ell}$.

math.AT↗

On the topology of the moduli space of positive scalar curvature concordances

Let $M$ be a manifold which admits a metric with positive scalar curvature (or a positive intermediate curvature in a suitable sense). We study the moduli space ${\mathscr{M}}^{\mathsf{pos}_*}_{\sqcup}(M\times I)_g$ of concordances of such metrics (with appropriate boundary conditions) which restrict to a given metric $g$ on $M \times \{0\} \cup\partial M \times I$. We show that $π_{4*}{\mathscr{M}}^{\mathsf{pos}_*}_{\sqcup}(M \times I)_g \otimes {\mathbb Q} \neq 0$ in a stable range provided $\dim M$ is even. We obtain analogous results when positive scalar curvature is replaced by $k$-positive Ricci curvature for $k \ge 2$.

math.DG↗

Generalized positive scalar curvature on spin$^c$ manifolds

Let $(M,L)$ be a (compact) non-spin spin$^c$ manifold. Fix a Riemannian metric $g$ on $M$ and a connection $A$ on $L$, and let $D_L$ be the associated spin$^c$ Dirac operator. Let $R^{tw}_{(g,A)}:=R_g + 2ic(Ω)$ be the twisted scalar curvature (which takes values in the endomorphisms of the spinor bundle), where $R_g$ is the scalar curvature of $g$ and $2ic(Ω)$ comes from the curvature $2$-form $Ω$ of the connection $A$. Then the Lichnerowicz-Schrödinger formula for the square of the Dirac operator takes the form $D_L^2 =\nabla^*\nabla+\frac{1}{4}R^{tw}_{(g,A)}$. In a previous work we proved that a closed non-spin simply-connected spin$^c$-manifold $(M,L)$ of dimension $n\geq 5$ admits a pair $(g,A)$ such that $R^{tw}_{(g,A)}>0$ if and only if the index $α^c(M,L):=\text{ind}\, D_L$ vanishes in $K_n$. In this paper we introduce a scalar-valued generalized scalar curvature $R^{gen}_{(g,A)}:=R_g - 2|Ω|_{op}$, where $|Ω|_{op}$ is the pointwise operator norm of Clifford multiplication $c(Ω)$, acting on spinors. We show that the positivity condition on the operator $R^{tw}_{(g,A)}$ is equivalent to the positivity of the scalar function $R^{gen}_{g,A}$. We prove a corresponding trichotomy theorem concerning the curvature $R^{gen}_{(g,A)}$, and study its implications. We also show that the space $\mathcal{R}^{gen+}(M,L)$ of pairs $(g,A)$ with $R^{gen}_{(g,A)}>0$ has non-trivial topology, and address a conjecture about non-triviality of the ``index difference'' map.

math.DG↗

Families of diffeomorphisms and concordances detected by trivalent graphs

We study families of diffeomorphisms detected by trivalent graphs via the Kontsevich classes. We specify some recent results and constructions of the second named author to show that those non-trivial elements in homotopy groups $π_*(B\mathrm{Diff}_{\partial}(D^d))\otimes \mathbb{Q}$ are lifted to homotopy groups of the moduli space of $h$-cobordisms $π_*(B\mathrm{Diff}_{\sqcup}(D^d\times I))\otimes \mathbb{Q}$. As a geometrical application, we show that those elements in $π_*(B\mathrm{Diff}_{\partial}(D^d))\otimes \mathbb{Q}$ for $d\geq 4$ are also lifted to the rational homotopy groups $π_*(\mathcal{M}^{\mathrm{psc}}_{\partial}(D^d)_{h_0})\otimes \mathbb{Q}$ of the moduli space of positive scalar curvature metrics. Moreover, we show that the same elements come from the homotopy groups $π_*(\mathcal{M}^{\mathrm{psc}}_{\sqcup} (D^d\times I; g_0)_{h_0})\otimes \mathbb{Q}$ of moduli space of concordances of positive scalar curvature metrics on $D^d$ with fixed round metric $h_0$ on the boundary $S^{d-1}$.

math.GT↗

Positive Scalar Curvature on Spin Pseudomanifolds: the Fundamental Group and Secondary Invariants

In this paper we continue the study of positive scalar curvature (psc) metrics on a depth-1 Thom-Mather stratified space $M_Σ$ with singular stratum $βM$ (a closed manifold of positive codimension) and associated link equal to $L$, a smooth compact manifold. We briefly call such spaces manifolds with $L$-fibered singularities. Under suitable spin assumptions we give necessary index-theoretic conditions for the existence of wedge metrics of positive scalar curvature. Assuming in addition that $L$ is a simply connected homogeneous space of positive scalar curvature, $L=G/H$, with the semisimple compact Lie group $G$ acting transitively on $L$ by isometries, we investigate when these necessary conditions are also sufficient. Our main result is that our conditions are indeed sufficient for large classes of examples, even when $M_Σ$ and $βM$ are not simply connected. We also investigate the space of such psc metrics and show that it often splits into many cobordism classes.

math.DG↗

Positive scalar curvature on $\mathbf{Pin}^\pm$- and $\mathbf{Spin}^c$-manifolds

It is well-known that spin structures and Dirac operators play a crucial role in the study of positive scalar curvature metrics (psc-metrics) on compact manifolds. Here we consider a class of non-spin manifolds with "almost spin" structure, namely those with spin$^c$ or pin$^\pm$-structures. It turns out that in those cases (under natural assumptions on such a manifold $M$), the index of a relevant Dirac operator completely controls existence of a psc-metric which is $S^1$- or $C_2$-invariant near a "special submanifold" $B$ of $M$. This submanifold $B\subset M$ is dual to the complex (respectively, real) line bundle $L$ which determines the spin$^c$ or pin$^\pm$ structure on $M$. We also show that these manifold pairs $(M,B)$ can be interpreted as "manifolds with fibered singularities" equipped with "well-adapted psc-metrics". This survey is based on our recent work as well as on our joint work with Paolo Piazza.

math.DG↗

Positive scalar curvature on simply connected spin pseudomanifolds

Let $M_Σ$ be an $n$-dimensional Thom-Mather stratified space of depth $1$. We denote by $βM$ the singular locus and by $L$ the associated link. In this paper we study the problem of when such a space can be endowed with a wedge metric of positive scalar curvature. We relate this problem to recent work on index theory on stratified spaces, giving first an obstruction to the existence of such a metric in terms of a wedge $α$-class $α_w (M_Σ)\in KO_n$. In order to establish a sufficient condition we need to assume additional structure: we assume that the link of $M_Σ$ is a homogeneous space of positive scalar curvature, $L=G/K$, where the semisimple compact Lie group $G$ acts transitively on $L$ by isometries. Examples of such manifolds include compact semisimple Lie groups and Riemannian symmetric spaces of compact type. Under these assumptions, when $M_Σ$ and $βM$ are spin, we reinterpret our obstruction in terms of two $α$-classes associated to the resolution of $M_Σ$, $M$, and to the singular locus $βM$. Finally, when $M_Σ$, $βM$, $L$, and $G$ are simply connected and $\dim M$ is big enough, and when some other conditions on $L$ (satisfied in a large number of cases) hold, we establish the main result of this article, showing that the vanishing of these two $α$-classes is also sufficient for the existence of a well-adapted wedge metric of positive scalar curvature.

math.DG↗

On the topology of the space of Ricci-positive metrics

We show that the space $\mathcal{R}^{\mathrm{pRc}}(W_g^{2n})$ of metrics with positive Ricci curvature on the manifold $W^{2n}_g := \sharp^g (S^n \times S^n)$ has nontrivial rational homology if $n \not \equiv 3 \pmod 4$ and $g$ are both sufficiently large. The same argument applies to $\mathcal{R}^{\mathrm{pRc}}(W_g^{2n} \sharp N)$ provided that $N$ is spin and $W_g^{2n} \sharp N$ admits a Ricci positive metric.

math.AT↗

Evolution of relative Yamabe constant under Ricci Flow

Let $W$ be a manifold with boundary $M$ given together with a conformal class $\bar C$ which restricts to a conformal class $C$ on $M$. Then the relative Yamabe constant $Y_{\bar C}(W,M;C)$ is well-defined. We study the short-time behavior of the relative Yamabe constant $Y_{[\bar g_t]}(W,M;C)$ under the Ricci flow $\bar g_t$ on $W$ with boundary conditions that mean curvature $H_{\bar g_t}\equiv 0$ and $\bar{g}_t|_M\in C = [\bar{g}_0]$. In particular, we show that if the initial metric $\bar{g}_0$ is a Yamabe metric, then, under some natural assumptions, $\left.\frac{d}{dt}\right|_{t=0}Y_{[\bar g_t]}(W,M;C)\geq 0$ and is equal to zero if and only the metric $\bar{g}_0$ is Einstein.

math.DG↗

Concordance and isotopy of metrics with positive scalar curvature, II

In this article, the author provides full details of the proof of the concordance/isotopy problem. The first published proof, [5], accomplished this task only partially since there was an error, see the erratum [6], which damaged the main argument of [5, Theorem 2.9], and, consequently, the proof of [5, Theorem A].

math.DG↗

Cheeger-Gromov convergence in a conformal setting

For a sequence $\{(M_i, g_i, x_i)\}$ of pointed Riemannian manifolds with boundary, the sequence $\{(M_i,\tilde g_i,x_i)\}$ is its conformal satellite if the metric $\tilde g_i$ is conformal to $g_i$, that is, $\tilde g_i=u^{\frac{4}{n-2}}_ig_i$. Assuming the manifolds $(M_i,g_i,x_i)$ have uniformly bounded geometry, we show that both sequences have smoothly Cheeger-Gromov convergent subsequences provided the conformal factors $u_i$ are principal eigenfunctions of an appropriate elliptic operator. Part of our result is a Cheeger-Gromov compactness for manifolds with boundary. We use stable versions of classical elliptic estimates and inequalities found in the recently established 'flatzoomer' method.

math.DG↗

Homotopy groups of the observer moduli space of Ricci positive metrics

The observer moduli space of Riemannian metrics is the quotient of the space $\mathcal{R}(M)$ of all Riemannian metrics on a manifold $M$ by the group of diffeomorphisms $\mathrm{Diff}_{x_0}(M)$ which fix both a basepoint $x_0$ and the tangent space at $x_0$. The group $\mathrm{Diff}_{x_0}(M)$ acts freely on $\mathcal{R}(M)$ providing $M$ is connected. This offers certain advantages over the classic moduli space, which is the quotient by the full diffeomorphism group. Results due to Botvinnik, Hanke, Schick and Walsh, and to Hanke, Schick and Steimle have demonstrated that the higher homotopy groups of the observer moduli space $\mathcal{M}_{x_0}^{s>0}(M)$ of positive scalar curvature metrics are, in many cases, non-trivial. The aim in the current paper is to establish similar results for the moduli space $\mathcal{M}_{x_0}^{\mathrm{Ric}>0}(M)$ of metrics with positive Ricci curvature. In particular we show that for a given $k$, there are infinite order elements in the homotopy group $π_{4k}\mathcal{M}_{x_0}^{\mathrm{Ric}>0}(S^n)$ provided the dimension $n$ is odd and sufficiently large. In establishing this we make use of a gluing result of Perelman. We provide full details of the proof of this gluing theorem, which we believe have not appeared before in the literature. We also extend this to a family gluing theorem for Ricci positive manifolds.

math.DG↗