Bradley G. Hammill | Searcharxiv

arXiv2026

A Review of Methods and Practices for Missing Data in Sequential Multiple Assignment Randomized Trials (SMARTs): An Ancillary Study of a Scoping Review

Background: Missing data poses an acute threat to sequential multiple assignment randomized trial (SMART) analyses because of the sequential treatment structure and response-dependent re-randomization. Objectives: This study aimed to (1) review the current statistical methods for handling missing data in SMARTs, and (2) characterize how missing data is reported and handled in published SMARTs. Methods: We conducted a narrative review of statistical methods developed for missing data in SMARTs. Additionally, we conducted a pre-specified secondary extraction of a previously published scoping review of SMARTs focused on missing data. Extraction captured attrition rates, methods for handling missingness, and planned versus performed missing data analyses. Results: Seven methodological papers were identified; nearly all assume missing at random (MAR), and only one addresses the full set of SMART-specific missingness types. Across 30 published SMARTs, median overall attrition was 18.1% (range 0.6%-56.5%). Methods used to address missing data were described in 80% of the manuscripts; mixed-model methods were most common (30%). Among 14 studies with paired protocols, sensitivity analyses were pre-specified in 2 (14%). Conclusions: SMART-specific methodology for missing data is limited, and a substantial gap exists between available methodology and current SMART practice.

stat.ME↗

arXiv2024

High-dimensional multiple imputation (HDMI) for partially observed confounders including natural language processing-derived auxiliary covariates

Multiple imputation (MI) models can be improved by including auxiliary covariates (AC), but their performance in high-dimensional data is not well understood. We aimed to develop and compare high-dimensional MI (HDMI) approaches using structured and natural language processing (NLP)-derived AC in studies with partially observed confounders. We conducted a plasmode simulation study using data from opioid vs. non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID) initiators (X) with observed serum creatinine labs (Z2) and time-to-acute kidney injury as outcome. We simulated 100 cohorts with a null treatment effect, including X, Z2, atrial fibrillation (U), and 13 other investigator-derived confounders (Z1) in the outcome generation. We then imposed missingness (MZ2) on 50% of Z2 measurements as a function of Z2 and U and created different HDMI candidate AC using structured and NLP-derived features. We mimicked scenarios where U was unobserved by omitting it from all AC candidate sets. Using LASSO, we data-adaptively selected HDMI covariates associated with Z2 and MZ2 for MI, and with U to include in propensity score models. The treatment effect was estimated following propensity score matching in MI datasets and we benchmarked HDMI approaches against a baseline imputation and complete case analysis with Z1 only. HDMI using claims data showed the lowest bias (0.072). Combining claims and sentence embeddings led to an improvement in the efficiency displaying the lowest root-mean-squared-error (0.173) and coverage (94%). NLP-derived AC alone did not perform better than baseline MI. HDMI approaches may decrease bias in studies with partially observed confounders where missingness depends on unobserved factors.

stat.ME↗