Searcharxiv⌕ Search

arXiv subjects

Chun Xia

Publications and source records attributed to Chun Xia.

At least 37 records · Page 2Linked to original sources

Thermodynamic and Magnetic Topology Evolution of the X1.0 Flare on 2021 October 28 Simulated by a Data-driven Radiative Magnetohydrodynamic Model

Solar filament eruptions, flares and coronal mass ejections (CMEs) are manifestations of drastic release of energy in the magnetic field, which are related to many eruptive phenomena from the Earth magnetosphere to black hole accretion disks. With the availability of high-resolution magnetograms on the solar surface, observational data-based modelling is a promising way to quantitatively study the underlying physical mechanisms behind observations. By incorporating thermal conduction and radiation losses in the energy equation, we develop a new data-driven radiative magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) model, which has the capability to capture the thermodynamic evolution compared to our previous zero-\b{eta} model. Our numerical results reproduce major observational characteristics of the X1.0 flare on 2021 October 28 in NOAA active region (AR) 12887, including the morphology of the eruption, kinematic of flare ribbons, extreme-ultraviolet (EUV) radiations, and two components of the EUV waves predicted by the magnetic stretching model, i.e., a fast-mode shock wave and a slower apparent wave due to successive stretching of magnetic field lines. Moreover, some intriguing phenomena are revealed in the simulation. We find that flare ribbons separate initially and ultimately stop at the outer stationary quasi-separatrix layers (QSLs). Such outer QSLs correspond to the border of the filament channel and determine the final positions of flare ribbons, which can be used to predict the size and the lifetime of a flare before it occurs. In addition, the side view of the synthesized EUV and white-light images exhibit typical three-part structures of CMEs, where the bright leading front is roughly cospatial with the non-wave component of the EUV wave, reinforcing the magnetic stretching model for the slow component of EUV waves.

astro-ph.SR↗

MPI-AMRVAC 3.0: updates to an open-source simulation framework

Computational astrophysics routinely combines grid-adaptive capabilities with modern shock-capturing, high resolution spatio-temporal schemes on multi-dimensional hydro- and magnetohydrodynamics. We provide an update on developments within the open-source MPI-AMRVAC code. With online documentation, the MPI-AMRVAC 3.0 release includes several added equation sets, and many options to explore and quantify the influence of implementation details. Showcasing this on a variety of hydro and MHD tests, we document new modules of interest for state-of-the-art solar applications. Test cases address how higher order reconstructions impact long term simulations of shear layers, with and without gas-dust coupling, how runaway radiative losses transit to intricate multi-temperature, multi-phase dynamics, and how different flavors of spatio-temporal schemes and magnetic monopole control produce consistent MHD results in combination with adaptive meshes. We demonstrate Super-Time-Stepping strategies for specific parabolic terms and give details on all implemented Implicit-Explicit integrators. A new magnetofrictional module can be used for computing force-free magnetic fields or for data-driven time-dependent evolutions, while the Regularized-Biot-Savart-Law approach can insert fluxropes in 3D domains. Synthetic observations of 3D MHD simulations can be rendered on-the-fly, or in post-processing, in many spectral wavebands. A particle module and a generic fieldline tracing, compatible with the hierarchical meshes, can be used to sample information at prescribed locations, to follow dynamics of charged particles, or realize two-way coupled simulations between MHD setups and field-aligned non-thermal processes. Highlighting the latest additions and various technical aspects, our open-source strategy welcomes any further code usage, contribution, or spin-off development.

astro-ph.IM↗

Formation of Quiescent Prominence Magnetic Field by Supergranulations

To understand the formation of quiescent solar prominences, the origin of their magnetic field structures, i.e., magnetic flux ropes (MFRs), must be revealed. We use three-dimensional magnetofriction simulations in a spherical subdomain to investigate the role of typical supergranular motions in the long-term formation of a prominence magnetic field. Time-dependant horizontal supergranular motions with and without the effect of Coriolis force are simulated on the solar surface via Voronoi tessellation. The vortical motions by the Coriolis effect at boundaries of supergranules inject magnetic helicity into the corona. The helicity is transferred and accumulated along the polarity inversion line (PIL) as strongly sheared magnetic field via helicity condensation. The diverging motions of supergranules converge opposite magnetic polarities at the PIL and drive the magnetic reconnection between footpoints of the sheared magnetic arcades to form an MFR. The magnetic network, negative-helicity MFR in the northern hemisphere, and fragmented-to-continuous formation process of magnetic dip regions are in agreement with observations. Although diverging supergranulations, differential rotation, and meridional flows are included, the simulation without the Coriolis effect can not produce an MFR or sheared arcades to host a prominence. Therefore Coriolis force is a key factor for helicity injection and the formation of magnetic structures of quiescent solar prominences.

astro-ph.SR↗

A formation mechanism for the large plumes in the prominence

To understand the formation mechanism of large plumes in solar prominences, we investigate the formation process of two such phenomena. We studied the dynamic and thermal properties of two large plumes using observations from New Vacuum Solar Telescope, the Solar Dynamic Observatory, and the Solar Terrestrial Relations Observatory-Ahead. We find that two large plumes observed with high-resolution data are quite different from previously studied small-scale plumes. They are born at the top of a prominence bubble with a large projected area of 10-20 Mm^2 . Before the occurrence of each large plume, the bubble expands and takes on a quasi-semicircular appearance. Meanwhile, the emission intensity of extreme-ultra-violet (EUV) bands increases in the bubble. A small-scale filament is found to erupt in the bubble during the second large plume. At the point at which the height of the bubble is comparable with half the width of the bubble, the bubble becomes unstable and generates the plumes. During the formation of plumes, two side edges of the top of the bubble, which are dominated by opposite Doppler signals, approach each other. The large plume then emerges and keeps rising up with a constant speed of about 13-15 km/s. These two large plumes have temperatures of 1.3 x 10^6 Kelvin and densities of 2.0 x 10^9 cm^-3, two orders hotter and one order less dense than the typical prominence. We also find that the bubble is a hot, low-density volume instead of a void region beneath the cold and dense prominence. Therefore, we conclude that these two large plumes are the result of the breakup of the prominence bubble triggered by an enhancement of thermal pressure; they separate from the bubble, most likely by magnetic reconnection.

astro-ph.SR↗

Optimizing the hybrid parallelization of BHAC

We present our experience with the modernization on the GR-MHD code BHAC, aimed at improving its novel hybrid (MPI+OpenMP) parallelization scheme. In doing so, we showcase the use of performance profiling tools usable on x86 (Intel-based) architectures. Our performance characterization and threading analysis provided guidance in improving the concurrency and thus the efficiency of the OpenMP parallel regions. We assess scaling and communication patterns in order to identify and alleviate MPI bottlenecks, with both runtime switches and precise code interventions. The performance of optimized version of BHAC improved by $\sim28\%$, making it viable for scaling on several hundreds of supercomputer nodes. We finally test whether porting such optimizations to different hardware is likewise beneficial on the new architecture by running on ARM A64FX vector nodes.

cs.DC↗

Data-constrained Magnetohydrodynamic Simulation of a Long Duration Eruptive Flare

We perform a zero-$β$ magnetohydrodynamic simulation for the C7.7 class flare initiated at 01:18 UT on 2011 June 21 using the Message Passing Interface Adaptive Mesh Refinement Versatile Advection Code (MPI-AMRVAC). The initial condition for the simulation involves a flux rope which we realize through the regularized Biot-Savart laws, whose parameters are constrained by observations from the Atmospheric Imaging Assembly (AIA) on the Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO) and the Extreme Ultraviolet Imager (EUVI) on the twin Solar Terrestrial Relations Observatory (STEREO). This data-constrained initial state is then relaxed to a force-free state by the magneto-frictional module in MPI-AMRVAC. The further time-evolving simulation results reproduce the eruption characteristics obtained by SDO/AIA 94 A, 304 A, and STEREO/EUVI 304 A observations fairly well. The simulated flux rope possesses similar eruption direction, height range, and velocities to the observations. Especially, the two phases of slow evolution and fast eruption are reproduced by varying the density distribution in light of the filament material draining process. Our data-constrained simulations also show other advantages, such as a large field of view (about 0.76 solar radii). We study the twist of the magnetic flux rope and the decay index of the overlying field, and find that in this event, both the magnetic strapping force and the magnetic tension force are sufficiently weaker than the magnetic hoop force, thus allowing the successful eruption of the flux rope. We also find that the anomalous resistivity is necessary in keeping the correct morphology of the erupting flux rope.

astro-ph.SR↗

Measuring three-dimensional shapes of stable solar prominences using stereoscopic observations from SDO and STEREO

Although the real shapes and trajectories of erupting solar prominences in three dimensions have been intensively studied, the three-dimensional (3D) shapes of stable prominences before eruptions have not been measured accurately so far. We intend to make such a measurement to constrain 3D prominence models and to extend our knowledge of prominences. Using multiperspective observations from the Atmospheric Imaging Assembly on board SDO and the Extreme Ultraviolet Imager on board STEREO, we reconstructed 3D coordinates of three stable prominences: a quiescent, an intermediate, and a mixed type. Based on the 3D coordinates, we measured the height, length, and inclination angle of the legs of these prominences. To study the spatial relationship between the footpoints of prominences and photospheric magnetic structures, we also used the Global Oscillation Network Group H alpha images and magnetograms from the HMI on board the SDO. In three stable prominences, we find that the axes of the prominence legs are inclined by 68 degrees on average to the solar surface. Legs at different locations along a prominence axis have different heights with a two- to threefold difference. Our investigation suggests that over 96% of prominence footpoints in a sample of 70 footpoints are located at supergranular boundaries. The widths of two legs have similar values measured in two orthogonal lines of sight. We also find that a prominence leg above the solar limb showed horizontal oscillations with larger amplitudes at higher locations. With a limited image resolution and number of cases, our measurement suggests that the legs of prominences may have various orientations and do not always stand vertically on the surface of the sun. Moreover, the locations of prominence legs are closely related to supergranules.

astro-ph.SR↗

Transition region adaptive conduction (TRAC) in multidimensional magnetohydrodynamic simulations

In solar physics, a severe numerical challenge for modern simulations is properly representing a transition region between the million-degree hot corona and a much cooler plasma of about 10000 K (e.g., the upper chromosphere or a prominence). In previous 1D hydrodynamic simulations, the transition region adaptive conduction (TRAC) method has been proven to capture aspects better that are related to mass evaporation and energy exchange. We aim to extend this method to fully multidimensional magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) settings, as required for any realistic application in the solar atmosphere. Because modern MHD simulation tools efficiently exploit parallel supercomputers and can handle automated grid refinement, we design strategies for any-dimensional block grid-adaptive MHD simulations. We propose two different strategies and demonstrate their working with our open-source MPI-AMRVAC code. We benchmark both strategies on 2D prominence formation based on the evaporation--condensation scenario, where chromospheric plasma is evaporated through the transition region and then is collected and ultimately condenses in the corona. A field-line-based TRACL method and a block-based TRACB method are introduced and compared in block grid-adaptive 2D MHD simulations. Both methods yield similar results and are shown to satisfactorily correct the underestimated chromospheric evaporation, which comes from a poor spatial resolution in the transition region. Because fully resolving the transition region in multidimensional MHD settings is virtually impossible, TRACB or TRACL methods will be needed in any 2D or 3D simulations involving transition region physics.

astro-ph.SR↗

A fully self-consistent model for solar flares

The 'standard solar' flare model collects all physical ingredients identified by multi-wavelength observations of our Sun: magnetic reconnection, fast particle acceleration and the resulting emission at various wavelengths, especially in soft to hard X-ray channels. Its cartoon representation is found throughout textbooks on solar and plasma astrophysics, and guides interpretations of unresolved energetic flaring events on other stars, accretion disks and jets. To date, a fully self-consistent model that reproduces the standard scenario in all its facets is lacking, since this requires the combination of a large scale, multi-dimensional magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) plasma description with a realistic fast electron treatment. Here, we demonstrate such a novel combination, where MHD combines with an analytic fast electron model, adjusted to handle time-evolving, reconnecting magnetic fields and particle trapping. This allows to study (1) the role of fast electron deposition in the triggering of chromospheric evaporation flows; (2) the physical mechanisms that generate various hard X-ray sources at chromospheric footpoints or looptops; and (3) the relationship between soft X-ray and hard X-ray fluxes throughout the entire flare loop evolution. For the first time, this self-consistent solar flare model demonstrates the observationally suggested relationship between flux swept out by the hard X-ray footpoint regions, and the actual reconnection rate at the X-point, which is a major unknown in flaring scenarios. We also demonstrate that a looptop hard X-ray source can result from fast electron trapping.

astro-ph.SR↗

MPI-AMRVAC: a parallel, grid-adaptive PDE toolkit

We report on the latest additions to our open-source, block-grid adaptive framework MPI-AMRVAC, which is a general toolkit for especially hyperbolic/parabolic partial differential equations (PDEs). Applications traditionally focused on shock-dominated, magnetized plasma dynamics described by either Newtonian or special relativistic (magneto)hydrodynamics, but its versatile design easily extends to different PDE systems. Here, we demonstrate applications covering any-dimensional scalar to system PDEs, with e.g. Korteweg-de Vries solutions generalizing early findings on soliton behaviour, shallow water applications in round or square pools, hydrodynamic convergence tests as well as challenging computational fluid and plasma dynamics applications. The recent addition of a parallel multigrid solver opens up new avenues where also elliptic constraints or stiff source terms play a central role. This is illustrated here by solving several multi-dimensional reaction-diffusion-type equations. We document the minimal requirements for adding a new physics module governed by any nonlinear PDE system, such that it can directly benefit from the code flexibility in combining various temporal and spatial discretisation schemes. Distributed through GitHub, MPI-AMRVAC can be used to perform 1D, 1.5D, 2D, 2.5D or 3D simulations in Cartesian, cylindrical or spherical coordinate systems, using parallel domain-decomposition, or exploiting fully dynamic block quadtree-octree grids.

astro-ph.IM↗

Thermal instabilities: Fragmentation and field misalignment of filament fine structure

Prominences show a surprising amount of fine structure and it is widely believed that their threads, as seen in H$α$ observations, provide indirect information concerning magnetic field topology. We investigate the spontaneous emergence and evolution of fine structure in high-density condensations formed through the process of thermal instability under typical solar coronal conditions. Our study reveals intricate multidimensional processes that occur through in situ condensations in a representative coronal volume in a low plasma beta regime. We performed 2D and 3D numerical simulations of interacting slow magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) wave modes when all relevant non-adiabatic effects are included. We show that the interaction of multiple slow MHD wave modes in a regime unstable to the thermal mode leads to thermal instability. This initially forms pancake-like structures almost orthogonal to the local magnetic field, while low-pressure induced inflows of matter generate rebound shocks. This is succeeded by the rapid disruption of these pancake sheets through thin-shell instabilities evolving naturally from minute ram pressure imbalances. This eventually creates high-density blobs accompanied by thread-like features from shear flow effects. The further evolution of the blobs follows the magnetic field lines, such that a dynamical realignment with the background magnetic field appears. However, the emerging thread-like features are not at all field-aligned, implying only a very weak link between fine structure orientation and magnetic field topology which has far-reaching implications for field topology interpretations based on H$α$ observations.

astro-ph.SR↗

Ideal MHD instabilities for coronal mass ejections

We review and discuss insights on ideal magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) instabilities that can play a role in destabilizing solar coronal flux rope structures. For single flux ropes, failed or actual eruptions may result from internal or external kink evolutions, or from torus unstable configurations. We highlight recent findings from 3D magnetic field reconstructions and simulations where kink and torus instabilities play a prominent role. For interacting current systems, we critically discuss different routes to coronal dynamics and global eruptions, due to current channel coalescence or to tilt-kink scenarios. These scenarios involve the presence of two nearby current channels and are clearly distinct from the popular kink or torus instability. Since the solar corona is pervaded with myriads of magnetic loops -- creating interacting flux ropes typified by parallel or antiparallel current channels as exemplified in various recent observational studies -- coalescence or tilt-kink evolutions must be very common for destabilizing adjacent flux rope systems. Since they also evolve on ideal MHD timescales, they may well drive many sympathetic eruptions witnessed in the solar corona. Moreover, they necessarily lead to thin current sheets that are liable to reconnection. We review findings from 2D and 3D MHD simulations for tilt and coalescence evolutions, as well as on particle acceleration aspects derived from computed charged particle motions in tilt-kink disruptions and coalescing flux ropes. The latter were recently studied in two-way coupled kinetic-fluid models, where the complete phase-space information of reconnection is incorporated.

astro-ph.SR↗

Forward Modeling of SDO/AIA and X-Ray Emission from a Simulated Flux Rope Ejection

We conduct forward-modeling analysis based on our 2.5 dimensional magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) simulation of magnetic flux rope (MFR) formation and eruption driven by photospheric converging motion. The current sheet (CS) evolution during the MFR formation and eruption process in our MHD simulation can be divided into four stages. The current sheet (CS) evolution during the MFR formation and eruption process in our MHD simulation can be divided into four stages. The first stage shows the CS forming and gradually lengthening. Resistive instabilities that disrupt the CS mark the beginning of the second stage. Magnetic islands disappear in the third stage and reappear in the fourth stage. Synthetic images and light curves of the seven Solar Dynamics Observatory/Atmospheric Imaging Assembly (AIA) channels, i.e., 9.4 nm, 13.1 nm, 17.1 nm, 19.3 nm, 21.1 nm, 30.4 nm, and 33.5 nm, and the 3-25 keV thermal X-ray are obtained with forward-modeling analysis. The loop-top source and the coronal sources of the soft X-ray are reproduced in forward modeling. The light curves of the seven SDO/AIA channels start to rise once resistive instabilities develop. The light curve of the 3-25 keV thermal X-ray starts to go up when the reconnection rate reaches one of its peaks. Quasiperiodic pulsations (QPPs) appear twice in the SDO/AIA 17.1 nm, 21.1 nm, and 30.4 nm channels, corresponding to the period of chaotic (re)appearance and CS-guided displacements of the magnetic islands. QPPs appear once in the SDO/AIA 9.4 nm and 33.5 nm channels after the disruption of the CS by resistive instabilities and in the 19.3 nm channel when the chaotic motion of the magnetic islands reappears.

astro-ph.SR↗

A comprehensive comparison of relativistic particle integrators

We compare relativistic particle integrators commonly used in plasma physics showing several test cases relevant for astrophysics. Three explicit particle pushers are considered, namely the Boris, Vay, and Higuera-Cary schemes. We also present a new relativistic fully implicit particle integrator that is energy conserving. Furthermore, a method based on the relativistic guiding center approximation is included. The algorithms are described such that they can be readily implemented in magnetohydrodynamics codes or Particle-in-Cell codes. Our comparison focuses on the strengths and key features of the particle integrators. We test the conservation of invariants of motion, and the accuracy of particle drift dynamics in highly relativistic, mildly relativistic, and non-relativistic settings. The methods are compared in idealized test cases, i.e., without considering feedback on the electrodynamic fields, collisions, pair creation, or radiation. The test cases include uniform electric and magnetic fields, $\mathbf{E}\times\mathbf{B}$-fields, force-free fields, and setups relevant for high-energy astrophysics, e.g., a magnetic mirror, a magnetic dipole, and a magnetic null. These tests have direct relevance for particle acceleration in shocks and in magnetic reconnection.

astro-ph.IM↗

Quasi-periodic Fast Propagating Magnetoacoustic Waves during the Magnetic Reconnection Between Solar Coronal Loops

Employing Solar Dynamics Observatory/Atmospheric Imaging Assembly (AIA) multi-wavelength images, we have presented coronal condensations caused by magnetic reconnection between a system of open and closed solar coronal loops. In this Letter, we report the quasi-periodic fast magnetoacoustic waves propagating away from the reconnection region upward across the higher-lying open loops during the reconnection process. On 2012 January 19, reconnection between the higher-lying open loops and lower-lying closed loops took place, and two sets of newly reconnected loops formed. Thereafter, cooling and condensations of coronal plasma occurred in the magnetic dip region of higher-lying open loops. During the reconnection process, disturbances originating from the reconnection region propagate upward across the magnetic dip region of higher-lying loops with the mean speed and mean speed amplitude of 200 and 30 km s$^{-1}$, respectively. The mean speed of the propagating disturbances decreases from $\sim$230 km s$^{-1}$ to $\sim$150 km s$^{-1}$ during the coronal condensation process, and then increases to $\sim$220 km s$^{-1}$. This temporal evolution of the mean speed anti-correlates with the light curves of the AIA 131 and 304 Å~channels that show the cooling and condensation process of coronal plasma. Furthermore, the propagating disturbances appear quasi-periodically with a peak period of 4 minutes. Our results suggest that the disturbances represent the quasi-periodic fast propagating magnetoacoustic (QFPM) waves originating from the magnetic reconnection between coronal loops.

astro-ph.SR↗

Solar Magnetic Flux Rope Eruption Simulated by a Data-Driven Magnetohydrodynamic Model

The combination of magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) simulation and multi-wavelength observations is an effective way to study mechanisms of magnetic flux rope eruption. We develop a data-driven MHD model using the zero-$β$ approximation. The initial condition is provided by nonlinear force-free field derived by the magneto-frictional method based on vector magnetic field observed by the Helioseismic and Magnetic Imager (HMI) aboard the Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO). The bottom boundary uses observed time series of the vector magnetic field and the vector velocity derived by the Differential Affine Velocity Estimator for Vector Magnetograms (DAVE4VM). We apply the data-driven model to active region 11123 observed from 06:00 UT on 2011 November 11 to about 2 hours later. The evolution of the magnetic field topology coincides with the flare ribbons observed in the 304 and 1600 Å$ $ wavebands by the Atmospheric Imaging Assembly. The morphology, propagation path, and propagation range of the flux rope are comparable with the observations in 304 Å. We also find that a data-constrained boundary condition, where the bottom boundary is fixed to the initial values, reproduces a similar simulation result. This model can reproduce the evolution of a magnetic flux rope in its dynamic eruptive phase.

astro-ph.SR↗

Solar flares and Kelvin-Helmholtz instabilities: A parameter survey

Hard X-ray (HXR) sources are frequently observed near the top of solar flare loops, and the emission is widely ascribed to bremsstrahlung. We here revisit an alternative scenario which stresses the importance of inverse Compton processes and the Kelvin- Helmholtz instability (KHI) proposed by Fang et al. (2016). This scenario adds a novel ingredient to the standard flare model, where evaporation flows from flare-impacted chromospheric foot-points interact with each other near the loop top and produce turbulence via KHI. The turbulence can act as a trapping region and as an efficient accelerator to provide energetic electrons, which scatter soft X-ray (SXR) photons to HXR photons via the inverse Compton mechanism. This paper focuses on the trigger of the KHI and the resulting turbulence in this new scenario. We perform a parameter survey to investigate the necessary ingredients to obtain KHI through interaction of chromospheric evaporation flows. When turbulence is produced in the loop apex, an index of -5/3 can be found in the spectra of velocity and magnetic field fluctuations. The KHI development and the generation of turbulence are controlled by the amount of energy deposited in the chromospheric foot-points and the time scale of its energy deposition, but typical values for M class flares show the KHI development routinely. Asymmetry of energy deposition determines the location where the turbulence is produced, and the synthesized SXR light curve shows a clear periodic signal related to the sloshing motion of the vortex pattern created by the KHI.

astro-ph.SR↗

Coronal condensations caused by magnetic reconnection between solar coronal loops

Employing Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO)/Atmospheric Imaging Assembly (AIA) multi-wavelength images, we report the coronal condensation during the magnetic reconnection (MR) between a system of open and closed coronal loops. Higher-lying magnetically open structures, observed in AIA 171 A images above the solar limb, move downward and interact with the lower-lying closed loops, resulting in the formation of dips in the former. An X-type structure forms at the interface. The interacting loops reconnect and disappear. Two sets of newly-reconnected loops then form and recede from the MR region. During the MR process, bright emission appears sequentially in the AIA 131 A and 304 A channels repeatedly in the dips of higher-lying open structures. This indicates the cooling and condensation process of hotter plasma from ~0.9 MK down to ~0.6 MK, and then to ~0.05 MK, also supported by the light curves of the AIA 171 A, 131 A, and 304 A channels. The part of higher-lying open structures supporting the condensations participate in the successive MR. The condensations without support by underlying loops then rain back to the solar surface along the newly-reconnected loops. Our results suggest that the MR between coronal loops leads to the condensation of hotter coronal plasma and its downflows. MR thus plays an active role in the mass cycle of coronal plasma because it can initiate the catastrophic cooling and condensation. This underlines that the magnetic and thermal evolution has to be treated together and cannot be separated, even in the case of catastrophic cooling.

astro-ph.SR↗