arXiv subjects

David Hilditch

Publications and source records attributed to David Hilditch.

At least 37 records · Page 2Linked to original sources

arXiv2023

Boson star head-on collisions with constraint-violating and constraint-satisfying initial data

Simulations of binary collisions involving compact objects require initial data that satisfy the constraint equations of general relativity. For binary boson star simulations it is common practice to use a superposition of two isolated star solutions to construct an approximate solution to the constraint equations. Such superposed data is simple to set up compared to solving these equations explicitly, but also introduces extra constraint violations in the time evolution. In this work we investigate how physical observables depend on the quality of initial data in the case of head-on boson star collisions. In particular we compare results obtained from data prepared using four different methods: the standard method to superpose isolated stars, a heuristic improvement to this superposition technique and two versions of this data where excess constraint violations were removed through a conformal thin-sandwich solver. We find that differences in the time evolutions are dominated by differences in the way the two superposition methods differ, whereas additionally constraint solving the superposed data has smaller impact. The numerical experiments are conducted using the pseudo-spectral code bamps. Our work demonstrates that bamps is a code suited for generating high accuracy numerical waveforms for boson star collisions due to the exponential convergence in the polynomial resolution of the numerical approximation.

gr-qc↗

arXiv2023

Numerical convergence of model Cauchy-characteristic extraction and matching

Gravitational waves provide a powerful enhancement to our understanding of fundamental physics. To make the most of their detection we need to accurately model the entire process of their emission and propagation toward interferometers. Cauchy-characteristic extraction and matching are methods to compute gravitational waves at null infinity, a mathematical idealization of detector location, from numerical relativity simulations. Both methods can in principle contribute to modeling by providing highly accurate gravitational waveforms. An underappreciated subtlety in realizing this potential is posed by the (mere) weak hyperbolicity of the particular PDE systems solved in the characteristic formulation of the Einstein field equations. This shortcoming results from the popular choice of Bondi-like coordinates. So motivated, we construct toy models that capture that PDE structure and study Cauchy-characteristic extraction and matching with them. Where possible we provide energy estimates for their solutions and perform careful numerical norm convergence tests to demonstrate the effect of weak hyperbolicity on Cauchy-characteristic extraction and matching. Our findings strongly indicate that, as currently formulated, Cauchy-characteristic matching for the Einstein field equations would provide solutions that are, at best, convergent at an order lower than expected for the numerical method, and may be unstable. In contrast, under certain conditions, the extraction method can provide properly convergent solutions. Establishing however that these conditions hold for the aforementioned characteristic formulations is still an open problem.

gr-qc↗

arXiv2023

Formulation Improvements for Critical Collapse Simulations

The precise tuning required to observe critical phenomena in gravitational collapse poses a challenge for most numerical codes. First, threshold estimation searches may be obstructed by the appearance of coordinate singularities, indicating the need for a better gauge choice. Second, the constraint violations to which simulations are susceptible may be too large and force searches to terminate prematurely. This is a particularly serious issue for first order formulations. We want our adaptive pseudospectral code bamps to be a robust tool for the study of critical phenomena so, having encountered both of these difficulties in work on the vacuum setting, we turn here to investigate these issues in the classic context of a spherically symmetric massless scalar field. We suggest two general improvements. We propose a necessary condition for a gauge choice to respect discrete self-similarity (DSS). The condition is not restricted to spherical symmetry and could be verified with any 3+1 formulation. After evaluating common gauge choices against this condition, we suggest a DSS-compatible gauge source function in generalized harmonic gauge (GHG). To control constraint violations, we modify the constraint damping parameters of GHG, adapting them to collapse spacetimes. This allows us to improve our tuning of the critical amplitude for several families of initial data, even going from 6 up to 11 digits. This is the most precise tuning achieved with the first order GHG formulation to date. Consequently, we are able to reproduce the well known critical phenomena as well as competing formulations and methods, clearly observing up to 3 echoes.

gr-qc↗

arXiv2023

Critical phenomena in the collapse of gravitational waves

Fine-tuning generic but smooth spherically-symmetric initial data for general relativity to the threshold of dynamical black hole formation creates arbitrarily large curvatures, mediated by a universal self-similar solution that acts as an intermediate attractor. For vacuum gravitational waves, however, these critical phenomena have been elusive. We present, for the first time, excellent agreement among three independent numerical simulations of this collapse. Surprisingly, we find no universality, and observe approximate self-similarity for some families of initial data but not for others.

gr-qc↗

arXiv2023

Trapped surface formation for the Einstein-Scalar system

We consider the formation of trapped surfaces in the evolution of the Einstein-scalar field system without symmetries. To this end, we follow An's strategy to analyse the formation of trapped surfaces in vacuum and for the Einstein-Maxwell system. Accordingly, we set up a characteristic initial value problem (CIVP) for the Einstein-Scalar system with initial data given on two intersecting null hypersurfaces such that on the incoming slince the data is Minkowskian whereas on the outgoing side no symmetries are assumed. We obtain a scale-critical semi-global existence result by assigning a signature for decay rates to both the geometric quantities and the scalar field. The analysis makes use of a gauge due to J. Stewart and an adjustment of the Geroch-Held-Penrose (GHP) formalism, the T-weight formalism, which renders the connection between the Newman-Penrose (NP) quantities and the PDE analysis systematic and transparent.

gr-qc↗

arXiv2023

3D Evolution of a Good-Bad-Ugly-F Model on Compactified Hyperboloidal Slices

The Good-Bad-Ugly-F model is a system of semi-linear wave equations that mimics the asymptotic form of the Einstein field equations in generalized harmonic gauge with specific constraint damping and suitable gauge source functions. These constraint additions and gauge source functions eliminate logarithmic divergences appearing at the leading order in the asymptotic expansion of the metric components. In this work, as a step towards using compactified hyperboloidal slices in numerical relativity, we evolve this model numerically in spherical symmetry, axisymmetry and full 3d on such hyperboloidal slices. Promising numerical results are found in all cases. Our results show that nonlinear systems of wave equations with the asymptotics of the Einstein field equations in the above form can be reliably captured within hyperboloidal numerical evolution without assuming symmetry.

gr-qc↗

arXiv2023

Critical phenomena in the collapse of quadrupolar and hexadecapolar gravitational waves

We report on numerical simulations of critical phenomena near the threshold of black hole formation in the collapse of axisymmetric gravitational waves in vacuum. We discuss several new features of our numerical treatment, and then compare results obtained from families of quadrupolar and hexadecapolar initial data. Specifically, we construct (nonlinear) initial data from quadrupolar and hexadecapolar, time-symmetric wavelike solutions to the linearized Einstein equations (often referred to as Teukolsky waves), and evolve these using a shock-avoiding slicing condition. While our degree of fine-tuning to the onset of black-hole formation is rather modest, we identify several features of the threshold solutions formed for the two families. Both threshold solutions appear to display an at least approximate discrete self-similarity with an accumulation event at the center, and the characteristics of the threshold solution for the quadrupolar data are consistent with those found previously by other authors. The hexadecapolar threshold solution appears to be distinct from the quadrupolar one, providing further support to the notion that there is no universal critical solution for the collapse of vacuum gravitational waves.

gr-qc↗

arXiv2023

Adaptive hp-Refinement for Spectral Elements in Numerical Relativity

When a numerical simulation has to handle a physics problem with a wide range of time-dependent length scales, dynamically adaptive discretizations can be the method of choice. We present a major upgrade to the numerical relativity code bamps in the form of fully adaptive, physics-agnostic hp-refinement. We describe the foundations of mesh refinement in the context of spectral element methods, the precise algorithm used to perform refinement in bamps, as well as several indicator functions used to drive it. Finally, we test the performance, scaling, and the accuracy of the code in treating several 1d and 2d example problems, showing clear improvements over static mesh configurations. In particular, we consider a simple non-linear wave equation, the evolution of a real scalar field minimally coupled to gravity, as well as nonlinear gravitational waves.

gr-qc↗

arXiv2023

Normal modes of Proca fields in AdS spacetime

A normal mode analysis for Proca fields in the anti-de Sitter (AdS) spacetime is given. It is found that the equations for the Proca field can be decoupled analytically. This is performed by changing the basis of the vector spherical harmonics (VSH) decomposition. The normal modes and the normal mode frequencies of the Proca equation in the AdS spacetime are then analytically determined. It is also shown that the Maxwell field can be recovered by taking the massless limit of the Proca field with care so that the nonphysical gauge modes are eliminated.

gr-qc↗

arXiv2022

Curvature and dynamical spacetimes: can we peer into the quantum regime?

Stationary compact astrophysical objects such as black holes and neutron stars behave as classical systems from the gravitational point of view. Their (observable) curvature is everywhere "small". Here we investigate whether mergers of such objects, or other strongly dynamical spacetimes such as collapsing configurations, may probe the strong-curvature regime of General Relativity. Our results indicate that dynamical black hole spacetimes always result in a modest increase $\sim 3$ in the Kretschmann scalar, relative to the stationary state. Our results show that the Kretschmann scalar can dynamically increase by orders of magnitude, during the gravitational collapse of scalar fields, and that the (normalized) peak curvature does not correspond to that of the critical solution. Nevertheless, without fine tuning of initial data, this increase lies far below that needed to render quantum-gravity corrections important.

gr-qc↗

arXiv2022

The good-bad-ugly system near spatial infinity on flat spacetime

A system of equations that serves as a model for the Einstein field equation in generalised harmonic gauge called the good-bad-ugly system is studied in the region close to null and spatial infinity in Minkowski spacetime. This analysis is performed using H. Friedrich's cylinder construction at spatial infinity and defining suitable conformally rescaled fields. The results are translated to the physical set up to investigate the relation between the polyhomogeneous expansions arising from the analysis of linear fields using the $i^0$-cylinder framework and those obtained through a heuristic method based on Hörmander's asymptotic system.

gr-qc↗

arXiv2022

Shock-avoiding slicing conditions: tests and calibrations

While the 1+log slicing condition has been extremely successful in numerous numerical relativity simulations, it is also known to develop "gauge-shocks" in some examples. Alternative "shock-avoiding" slicing conditions suggested by Alcubierre prevent these pathologies in those examples, but have not yet been explored and tested very broadly. In this paper we compare the performance of shock-avoiding slicing conditions with those of 1+log slicing for a number of "text-book" problems, including black holes and relativistic stars. While, in some simulations, the shock-avoiding slicing conditions feature some unusual properties and lead to more "gauge-dynamics" than the 1+log slicing condition, we find that they perform quite similarly in terms of stability and accuracy, and hence provide a very viable alternative to 1+log slicing.

gr-qc↗

arXiv2022

Regularizing Dual-Frame Generalized Harmonic Gauge at Null Infinity

The dual-frame formalism leads to an approach to extend numerical relativity simulations in generalized harmonic gauge (GHG) all the way to null infinity. A major setback is that without care, even simple choices of initial data give rise to logarithmically divergent terms that would result in irregular variables and equations on the compactified domain, which would in turn prevent accurate numerical approximation. It has been shown, however, that a suitable choice of gauge and constraint addition can be used to prevent their appearance. Presently we give a first order symmetric hyperbolic reduction of general relativity in GHG on compactified hyperboloidal slices that exploits this knowledge and eradicates these log-terms at leading orders. Because of their effect on the asymptotic solution space, specific formally singular terms are systematically chosen to remain. Such formally singular terms have been successfully treated numerically in toy models and result in a formulation with the desirable property that unphysical radiation content near infinity is suppressed.

gr-qc↗

arXiv2022

Peeling in Generalized Harmonic Gauge

It is shown that a large class of systems of non-linear wave equations, based on the good-bad-ugly model, admit formal solutions with polyhomogeneous expansions near null infinity. A particular set of variables is introduced which allows us to write the Einstein field equations in generalized harmonic gauge as a good-bad-ugly system and the functional form of the first few orders in such an expansion is found by applying the aforementioned result. Exploiting these formal expansions of the metric components, the peeling property of the Weyl tensor is revisited. The question addressed is whether or not the use of generalized harmonic gauge, by itself, causes a violation of peeling. Working in harmonic gauge, it is found that log-terms that prevent the Weyl tensor from peeling do appear. The impact of gauge source functions and constraint additions on the peeling property is then considered. Finally, the special interplay between gauge and constraint addition, as well as its influence on the asymptotic system and the decay of each of the metric components, is exploited to find a particular gauge which suppresses this specific type of log-term to arbitrarily high order.

gr-qc↗

arXiv2022

Evolution of Brill waves with an adaptive pseudospectral method

As a first application of the new adaptive mesh functionality of the the pseudospectral numerical relativity code bamps, we evolve twist-free, axisymmetric gravitational waves close to the threshold of collapse. We consider six different one-parameter families of Brill wave initial data; two centered and four off-centered families. Of these the latter have not been treated before. Within each family we tune the parameter towards the threshold of black hole formation. The results for centered data agree with earlier work. Our key results are first, that close to the threshold of collapse the global peak in the curvature appears on the symmetry axis but away from the origin, indicating that in the limit they will collapse around disjoint centers. This is confirmed in three of the six families by explicitly finding apparent horizons around these large curvature peaks. Second, we find evidence neither for strict discrete-self-similarity nor for universal power-law scaling of curvature quantities. Finally, as in Ledvinka & Khirnov's recent study, we find approximately universal strong curvature features. These features appear multiple times within individual spacetimes close to the threshold and are furthermore present within all six families.

gr-qc↗

arXiv2022

Gauge structure of the Einstein field equations in Bondi-like coordinates

The characteristic initial (boundary) value problem has numerous applications in general relativity (GR) involving numerical studies, and is often formulated using Bondi-like coordinates. Recently it was shown that several prototype formulations of this type are only weakly hyperbolic. Presently we examine the root cause of this result. In a linear analysis we identify the gauge, constraint and physical blocks in the principal part of the Einstein field equations in such a gauge, and show that the subsystem related to the gauge variables is only weakly hyperbolic. Weak hyperbolicity of the full system follows as a consequence in many cases. We demonstrate this explicitly in specific examples, and thus argue that Bondi-like gauges result in weakly hyperbolic free evolution systems under quite general conditions. Consequently the characteristic initial (boundary) value problem of GR in these gauges is rendered ill-posed in the simplest norms one would like to employ. The possibility of finding good alternative norms, in which well-posedness is achieved, is discussed. So motivated, we present numerical convergence tests with an implementation of full GR which demonstrate the effect of weak hyperbolicity in practice.

gr-qc↗

arXiv2022

Quasinormal modes of Proca fields in a Schwarzschild-AdS spacetime

We present new results concerning the Proca massive vector field in a Schwarzschild-AdS black hole geometry. We provide a first principles analysis of Proca vector fields in this geometry using both the vector spherical harmonic (VSH) separation method and the Frolov-Krtouš-Kubizňák-Santos (FKKS) method that separates the relevant equations in spinning geometries. The analysis in the VSH method shows, on one hand, that it is arduous to separate the scalar-type from the vector-type polarizations of the electric sector of the Proca field, and on the other hand, it displays clearly the electric and the magnetic mode sectors. The analysis in the FKKS method is performed by taking the nonrotating limit of the Kerr-AdS spacetime, and shows that the ansatz decouples the polarizations in the electric mode sector even in the nonrotating limit. On the other hand, it captures only two of the three possible polarizations, the magnetic mode sector is missing. The reason for the absence of this polarization is related to the degeneracy of the principal tensor in static spherical symmetric spacetimes. The degrees of freedom and quasinormal modes in both separation methods of the Proca field are found. The frequencies of the quasinormal modes are also computed. For the electric mode sector in the VSH method the frequencies are found through an extension, which substitutes number coefficients by matrix coefficients, of the Horowitz-Hubeny numerical procedure, whereas for the magnetic mode sector in the VSH method and the electric sector of the FKKS method it is shown that a direct use of the procedure can be made. The values of the quasinormal mode frequencies obtained for each method are compared and showed to be in good agreement with each other. This further supports the analytical approaches presented here for the behavior of the Proca field in a Schwarzschild-AdS black hole background.

gr-qc↗

arXiv2021

Comparison of linear Brill and Teukolsky waves

Motivated by studies of critical phenomena in the gravitational collapse of vacuum gravitational waves we compare, at the linear level, two common approaches to constructing gravitational-wave initial data. Specifically, we construct analytical, linear Brill wave initial data and compare these with Teukolsky waves in an attempt to understand the different numerical behavior observed in dynamical (nonlinear) evolutions of these two different sets of data. In general, the Brill waves indeed feature higher multipole moments than the quadrupolar Teukolsky waves, which might have provided an explanation for the differences observed in the dynamical evolution of the two types of waves. However, we also find that, for a common choice of the Brill-wave seed function, all higher-order moments vanish identically, rendering the (linear) Brill initial data surprisingly similar to the Teukolsky data for a similarly common choice of its seed function.

gr-qc↗