arXiv subjects

David Wittman

Publications and source records attributed to David Wittman.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

arXiv2026

X-SORTER (X-ray Survey Of meRging clusTErs in Redmapper): X-ray and Spectroscopic Characterization of 12 Optically Selected Galaxy Cluster Merger Candidates

Merging galaxy clusters offer a unique probe of dark matter (DM) interactions through the spatial offsets between galaxies, the intracluster medium, and the DM halo. Systems that are binary, near the plane of the sky, and observed shortly after first pericenter provide the cleanest constraints on the DM self-interaction cross-section. The X-SORTER (X-ray Survey Of meRging clusTErs in redMaPPer) program aims to systematically identify such mergers using optical indicators of binarity in the redMaPPer cluster catalog and to follow up promising candidates with X-ray and spectroscopic observations. We select massive clusters where the top redMaPPer brightest cluster galaxy (BCG) probability is below 0.98, the top two BCGs are separated by at least 0.95 arcmin, and the optical richness exceeds $\lambda = 120$. We present XMM and Keck/DEIMOS observations of twelve clusters with no previous XMM-Newton or Chandra archival data meeting these criteria. The X-ray data reveal that most targets are morphologically disturbed, with several clear post-pericenter, dissociative systems exhibiting X-ray peaks between the BCGs. Spectroscopy confirms cluster membership and rules out foreground or background contamination. Together, these results demonstrate that optical BCG properties provide an efficient means of identifying dynamically active clusters, including clean dissociative mergers suitable for detailed, multi-wavelength studies of dark matter and cluster evolution.

astro-ph.CO↗

arXiv2025

A Very Rich Bimodal Galaxy Cluster Merger: RXC J0032.1+1808

The galaxy cluster RXC J0032.1+1808 has been well-studied with optical imaging and gravitational lensing mass maps, both of which reveal an elongated morphology in the north-south direction. We find that its X-ray morphology is bimodal, suggesting that it is in the process of merging; combined with a previously reported detection of a radio relic, we suggest that the system is seen after first pericenter. We extract the global X-ray temperature and unabsorbed luminosity from archival XMM-Newton data, finding $T_X=8.5^{+1.1}_{-0.9}$ keV and $L_X=1.04 \pm 0.03 \times 10^{45}$ erg s$^{-1}$ at 90\% confidence in the $0.5$--$10.0$ keV energy range. We conduct a redshift survey of member galaxies and find that the line-of-sight relative velocity between the two subclusters is $76\pm364$ km/s. We use publicly available hydrodynamic simulations to show that it cannot be a head-on merger, that it is observed ${\approx}395$--560 Myr after pericenter, and that the viewing angle must be one that foreshortens the apparent subcluster separation by a factor ${\approx}2$.

astro-ph.HE↗

arXiv2025

Fisher Matrix for Beginners

The Fisher information matrix is used widely in astronomy (and presumably other fields) to forecast the precision of future experiments while they are still in the design phase. Although many sources describe the mathematics of the formalism, few sources offer simple examples to help the beginner. This pedagogical document works through a few simple examples to develop conceptual understanding of the applications.

astro-ph.IM↗

arXiv2025

Discovery and Multi-Wavelength Analysis of a New Dissociative Galaxy Merger: The Champagne Cluster

We report the discovery of a new binary galaxy cluster merger, the Champagne Cluster (RM J130558.9+263048.4), using a detection method that identifies dynamically active clusters in the redMaPPer SDSS DR8 photometric galaxy cluster catalog. The Champagne Cluster exhibits the classic X-ray morphology of a post-pericenter dissociative galaxy cluster merger: an X-ray peak located between two galaxy overdensities at the same redshift. We conducted a Keck/DEIMOS survey and obtained redshifts for {\bfseries 102} member galaxies. The redshift analysis indicates a relative velocity of 411 $\pm$ 180 km/s between the two subclusters, which suggests that the merger is happening near the plane of the sky. We estimated the bulk temperature (8.20 $\pm 1.2$ keV) and total X-ray luminosity (7.29 $\pm$ 0.19 $\times$ $10^{44}$ erg $\times$ $s^{-1}$) of the intracluster medium using $\textit{Chandra}$ archival data. We used the $\textit{ClusterPyXT}$ software to make a temperature map, and we compared it to hydrodynamic simulations to constrain the time since pericenter (TSP), the impact parameter, and the mass ratio. We found two scenarios that matched our data: a returning system with an impact parameter of 0 and TSP of 2.2 Gyr, and an outbound system with an impact parameter of 500 kpc and TSP of 0.4 Gyr. Both scenarios have a mass ratio of 1:10.

astro-ph.CO↗

arXiv2024

Line of Sight Bias in Dark Matter Inferences from Galaxy Cluster Mergers

In collisions of galaxy clusters, the lack of displacement between dark matter and galaxies suggests that the dark matter scattering depth is small. This yields an upper limit on the dark matter cross section if the dark matter column density is known. We investigate a bias in such constraints: the measured column density (along the line of sight, using gravitational lensing) is lower than that experienced by a dark matter particle, as follows. Dark matter halos are triaxial and generally collide along their major axes, yielding a high scattering column density -- but the merger is obvious only to observers whose line of sight is nearly perpendicular to that axis, yielding a low observed column density. We trace lines of sight through merging halos from the BigMDPL n-body simulation, both with and without mock observational effects. We find that a hypothetical skewer through the center of the halo along the merger axis (more precisely, along the current separation vector of the two halos) has nearly twice the column density of a typical line of sight. With weak lensing measurements, which involve some spatial averaging, this ratio is reduced to 1.25, suggesting that existing constraints on the scattering cross section are biased high by about 25%.

astro-ph.CO↗

arXiv2024

Improving Precision in Kinematic Weak Lensing with MIRoRS: Model-Independent Restoration of Reflection Symmetries

We present a novel, model-independent technique for fitting the cross-component of weak lensing shear, $\gamma_\times$, along a line of sight by combining kinematic and photometric measurements of a single lensed galaxy. Rather than relying on parametric models, we fit for the shear parameter that best transforms the velocity field to restore its underlying symmetries, while also incorporating photometric data for the change in position angle due to shear. We first validate our technique with idealized mock data, exploring the method's response to variations in shear, position angle, inclination, and noise. On this idealized mock data, our combined kinematic and photometric model demonstrates superior performance compared to traditional parametric or kinematic-only approaches. We also explore the effects of asymmetric warps and show that rotation direction can impart a small bias on the fit of $\gamma_\times$. Subsequently, we apply our method to a dataset of 358 halos from the Illustris TNG simulations, achieving a notable reduction in the uncertainty of $\gamma_\times$ to 0.039, marking a substantial improvement over previous analysis of the dataset with a parametric model. Finally, we introduce an outlier rejection method based on Moran's $I$ test for spatial autocorrelation. Identifying and filtering out halos with spatially correlated residuals reduces the overall uncertainty to 0.028. Our results underscore the efficacy of combining kinematic and photometric data for weak lensing studies, providing a more precise and targeted measurement of shear along an individual line of sight.

astro-ph.CO↗

arXiv2024

Weak-Lensing Characterization of the Dark Matter in 29 Merging Clusters that Exhibit Radio Relics

We present a multiwavelength analysis of 29 merging galaxy clusters that exhibit radio relics. For each merging system, we perform a weak-lensing analysis on Subaru optical imaging. We generate high-resolution mass maps of the dark matter distributions, which are critical for discerning the merging constituents. Combining the weak-lensing detections with X-ray emission, radio emission, and galaxy redshifts, we discuss the formation of radio relics from the past collision. For each subcluster, we obtain mass estimates by fitting a multi-component NFW model with and without a concentration-mass relation. Comparing the two mass estimate techniques, we find that the concentration-mass relation underestimates (overestimates) the mass relative to fitting both parameters for high- (low-) mass subclusters. We compare the mass estimates of each subcluster to their velocity dispersion measurements and find that they preferentially lie below the expected velocity dispersion scaling relation, especially at the low-mass end (~$10^{14}\ M_\odot$). We show that the majority of the clusters that exhibit radio relics are in major mergers with a mass ratio below 1:4. We investigate the position of the mass peak relative to the galaxy luminosity peak, number density peak, and BCG locations and find that the BCG tends to better trace the mass peak position. Finally, we update a golden sample of 8 galaxy clusters that have the simplest geometries and can provide the cleanest picture of the past merger, which we recommend for further investigation to constrain the nature of dark matter and the acceleration process that leads to radio relics.

astro-ph.CO↗

arXiv2023

Distribution of H-alpha Emitters in Merging Galaxy Clusters

Studies of star formation in various galaxy cluster mergers have reached apparently contradictory conclusions regarding whether mergers stimulate star formation, quench it, or have no effect. Because the mergers studied span a range of time since pericenter (TSP), it is possible that the apparent effect on star formation is a function of TSP. We use a sample of 12 bimodal mergers to assess the star formation as a function of TSP. We measure the equivalent width of the H-alpha emission line in ${\sim}100$ member galaxies in each merger, classify galaxies as emitters or non-emitters, and then classify emitters as star-forming galaxies (SFG) or active galactic nucleus (AGN) based on the [NII] $\lambda6583$ line. We quantify the distribution of SFG and AGN relative to non-emitters along the spatial axis defined by the subcluster separation. The SFG and AGN fractions vary from merger to merger, but show no trend with TSP. The spatial distribution of SFG is consistent with that of non-emitters in eight mergers, but show significant avoidance of the system center in the remaining four mergers, including the three with the lowest TSP. If there is a connection between star formation activity and TSP, probing it further will require more precise TSP estimates and more mergers with TSP in the range of 0-400 Myr.

astro-ph.GA↗

arXiv2023

Weak-Lensing Analysis of the Complex Cluster Merger Abell 746 with Subaru/Hyper Suprime-Cam

The galaxy cluster Abell 746 (A746; $z$=0.214), featuring a double radio relic system, two isolated radio relics, a possible radio halo, disturbed V-shaped X-ray emission, and intricate galaxy distributions, is a unique and complex merging system. We present a weak-lensing analysis of A746 based on wide-field imaging data from Subaru/Hyper Suprime-Cam observations. The mass distribution is characterized by a main peak which coincides with the center of the X-ray emission. At this main peak, we detect two extensions toward the north and west, tracing the cluster galaxy and X-ray distributions. Despite the ongoing merger, our estimate of the A746 global mass $M_{500}=4.4\pm1.0\times10^{14}~M_{\odot}$ is consistent with the previous results from SZ and X-ray observations. We conclude that reconciling the distributions of mass, galaxies, and intracluster medium with the double radio relic system and other radio features remains challenging.

astro-ph.GA↗

arXiv2023

A New Dissociative Galaxy Cluster Merger: RM J150822.0+575515.2

Galaxy cluster mergers that exhibit clear dissociation between their dark matter, intracluster gas, and stellar components are great laboratories for probing dark matter properties. Mergers that are binary and in the plane of the sky have the additional advantage of being simpler to model, allowing for a better understanding of the merger dynamics. We report the discovery of a galaxy cluster merger with all these characteristics and present a multiwavelength analysis of the system, which was found via a search in the redMaPPer optical cluster catalog. We perform a galaxy redshift survey to confirm the two subclusters are at the same redshift (0.541, with $368\pm519$ km s$^{-1}$ line-of-sight velocity difference between them). The X-ray morphology shows two surface-brightness peaks between the BCGs. We construct weak lensing mass maps that reveal a mass peak associated with each subcluster. Fitting NFW profiles to the lensing data, we find masses of $M_{\rm 200c}=36\pm11\times10^{13}$ and $38\pm11\times10^{13}$ M$_\odot/h$ for the southern and northern subclusters respectively. From the mass maps, we infer that the two mass peaks are separated by $520^{+162}_{-125}$ kpc along the merger axis, whereas the two BCGs are separated by 697 kpc. We also present deep GMRT 650 MHz data to search for a radio relic or halo, and find none. Using the observed merger parameters, we find analog systems in cosmological n-body simulations and infer that this system is observed between 96-236 Myr after pericenter, with the merger axis within $28^{\circ}$ of the plane of the sky.

astro-ph.CO↗

arXiv2023

A New Galaxy Cluster Merger Capable of Probing Dark Matter: Abell 56

We report the discovery of a binary galaxy cluster merger via a search of the redMaPPer optical cluster catalog, with a projected separation of 535 kpc between the BCGs. Archival XMM-Newton spectro-imaging reveals a gas peak between the BCGs, suggesting a recent pericenter passage. We conduct a galaxy redshift survey to quantify the line-of-sight velocity difference ($153\pm281$ km/s) between the two subclusters. We present weak lensing mass maps from archival HST/ACS imaging, revealing masses of $M_{200}=4.5\pm0.8\times10^{14}$ and $2.8\pm0.7\times10^{14}$ M$_\odot$ associated with the southern and northern galaxy subclusters respectively. We also present deep GMRT 650 MHz data revealing extended emission, 420 kpc long, which may be an AGN tail but is potentially also a candidate radio relic. We draw from cosmological n-body simulations to find analog systems, which imply that this system is observed fairly soon (60-271 Myr) after pericenter, and that the subcluster separation vector is within 22$^\circ$ of the plane of the sky, making it suitable for an estimate of the dark matter scattering cross section. We find $\sigma_{\rm DM}=1.1\pm0.6$ cm$^2$/g, suggesting that further study of this system could support interestingly tight constraints.

astro-ph.CO↗

arXiv2022

Testing Velocity-Field Lensing on IllustrisTNG Galaxies

Weak gravitational lensing shear could be measured far more precisely if information about unlensed attributes of source galaxies were available. Disk galaxy velocity fields supply such information, at least in principle, with idealized models predicting orders of magnitude more Fisher information when velocity field observations are used to complement images. To test the level at which realistic features of disk galaxies (warps, bars, spiral arms, and other substructure) inject noise or bias into such shear measurements, we fit an idealized disk model, including shear, to unsheared galaxies in the Illustris TNG100 simulation. The inferred shear thus indicates the extent to which unmodeled galaxy features inject noise and bias. We find that $\gamma_+$, the component of shear parallel to the galaxy's first principal axis, is highly biased and noisy because disks violate the assumption of face-on circularity, displaying a range of intrinsic axis ratios ($0.85\pm0.11$). The other shear component, $\gamma_\times$, shows little bias and is well-described by a double Gaussian distribution with central core scatter $\sigma_{\text{core}} \approx$ 0.03, with low-amplitude, broad wings. This is the first measurement of the natural noise floor in the proposed velocity-field lensing technique. We conclude that the technique will achieve impressive precision gains for measurements of $\gamma_\times$, but little gain for measurements of $\gamma_+$.

astro-ph.IM↗

arXiv2021

Exemplary Merging Clusters: Weak-lensing and X-ray Analysis of the Double Radio Relic Merging Galaxy Clusters MACS 1752.0+4440 and ZWCL 1856.8+6616

The investigation of merging galaxy clusters that exhibit radio relics is strengthening our understanding of the formation and evolution of galaxy clusters, the nature of dark matter, the intracluster medium, and astrophysical particle acceleration. Each merging cluster provides only a single view of the cluster formation process and the variety of merging clusters is vast. Clusters hosting double radio relics are rare and extremely important because they allow tight constraints on the merger scenario. We present a weak-lensing and X-ray analysis of MACSJ1752.0+4440 ($z$=0.365) and ZWCL1856.8+6616 ($z$=0.304), two double radio relic clusters. Our weak-lensing mass estimates show that each cluster is a major merger with approximately 1:1 mass ratio. The total mass of MACSJ1752.0+4440 (ZWCL1856.8+6616) is $M_{200}=14.7^{+3.8}_{-3.3}\times10^{14}\ $M$_\odot$ ($M_{200}=2.4^{+0.9}_{-0.7}\times10^{14}\ $M$_\odot$). We find that these two clusters have comparable features in their weak-lensing and gas distributions, even though the systems have vastly different total masses. From the likeness of the X-ray morphologies and the remarkable symmetry of the radio relics, we propose that both systems underwent nearly head-on collisions. However, revelations from the hot-gas features and our multiwavelength data analysis suggest that ZWCL1856.8+6618 is likely at a later merger phase than MACSJ1752.0+4440. We postulate that the SW radio relic in MACSJ1752.0+4440 is a result of particle re-acceleration.

astro-ph.GA↗

arXiv2021

Precision Weak Gravitational Lensing Using Velocity Fields: Fisher Matrix Analysis

Weak gravitational lensing measurements based on photometry are limited by shape noise, the variance in the unknown unlensed orientations of the source galaxies. If the source is a disk galaxy with a well-ordered velocity field, however, velocity field data can support simultaneous inference of the shear, inclination, and position angle, virtually eliminating shape noise. We use the Fisher Information Matrix formalism to forecast the precision of this method in the idealized case of a perfectly ordered velocity field defined on an infinitesimally thin disk. For nearly face-on targets one shear component, $γ_\times$, can be constrained to $0.003\frac{90}{I_0}\frac{25}{n_{\rm pix}}$ where $I_0$ is the S/N of the central intensity pixel and $n_{\rm pix}$ is the number of pixels across a diameter enclosing 80\% of the light. This precision degrades with inclination angle, by a factor of three by $i{=}50^\circ$. Uncertainty on the other shear component, $γ_+$, is about 1.5 (7) times larger than the $γ_\times$ uncertainty for targets at $i=10^\circ$ ($50^\circ$). For arbitrary galaxy position angle on the sky, these forecasts apply not to $γ_+$ and $γ_\times$ as defined on the sky, but to two eigenvectors in $(γ_+, γ_\times,μ)$ space where $μ$ is the magnification. We also forecast the potential of less expensive partial observations of the velocity field such as slit spectroscopy. We conclude by outlining some ways in which real galaxies depart from our idealized model and thus create random or systematic uncertainties not captured here. In particular, our forecast $γ_\times$ precision is currently limited only by the data quality rather than scatter in galaxy properties because the relevant type of scatter has yet to be measured.

astro-ph.CO↗

arXiv2019

Chandra Observations of the Spectacular A3411-12 Merger Event

We present deep Chandra observations of A3411-12, a remarkable merging cluster that hosts the most compelling evidence for electron re-acceleration at cluster shocks to date. Using the $Y_X-M$ scaling relation, we find $r_{500} \sim 1.3$ Mpc, $M_{500} = (7.1 \pm 0.7) \times 10^{14} \ M_{\rm{\odot}}$, $kT=6.5\pm 0.1$ keV, and a gas mass of $M_{\rm g,500} = (9.7 \pm 0.1) \times 10^{13} M_\odot$. The gas mass fraction within $r_{500}$ is $f_{\rm g} = 0.14 \pm 0.01$. We compute the shock strength using density jumps to conclude that the Mach number of the merging subcluster is small ($M \leq 1.15_{-0.09}^{+0.14}$). We also present pseudo-density, projected temperature, pseudo-pressure, and pseudo-entropy maps. Based on the pseudo-entropy map we conclude that the cluster is undergoing a mild merger, consistent with the small Mach number. On the other hand, radio relics extend over Mpc scale in the A3411-12 system, which strongly suggests that a population of energetic electrons already existed over extended regions of the cluster.

astro-ph.HE↗

arXiv2019

Dynamics of Merging Galaxy Clusters from Simulated Analogs

Merging galaxy clusters may provide a unique window into the behavior of dark matter and the evolution of member galaxies. To interpret these natural collider experiments we must account for how much time has passed since pericenter passage (TSP), the maximum relative speed of the merging subclusters, merger phase (outbound after first pericenter or returning for second pericenter), and other dynamical parameters that are not directly observable. These quantities are often inferred from staged simulations or analytical timing arguments that include neither substructure, large-scale structure, nor a cosmologically motivated range of impact parameters. We include all these effects by extracting dynamical parameters from analog systems in a cosmological n-body simulation, and we present constraints for 11 observed systems. The TSP and viewing angles we derive are consistent with those of staged hydrodynamical simulations, but we find lower maximum speeds. Compared to the analytical MCMAC method we find lower TSP, and viewing angles that put the separation vector closer to the plane of the sky; we attribute this to the MCMAC assumption of zero pericenter distance. We discuss potential extensions to the basic analog method as well as complementarities between methods.

astro-ph.CO↗

arXiv2019

Probing the Fundamental Nature of Dark Matter with the Large Synoptic Survey Telescope

Astrophysical and cosmological observations currently provide the only robust, empirical measurements of dark matter. Future observations with Large Synoptic Survey Telescope (LSST) will provide necessary guidance for the experimental dark matter program. This white paper represents a community effort to summarize the science case for studying the fundamental physics of dark matter with LSST. We discuss how LSST will inform our understanding of the fundamental properties of dark matter, such as particle mass, self-interaction strength, non-gravitational couplings to the Standard Model, and compact object abundances. Additionally, we discuss the ways that LSST will complement other experiments to strengthen our understanding of the fundamental characteristics of dark matter. More information on the LSST dark matter effort can be found at https://lsstdarkmatter.github.io/ .

astro-ph.CO↗

arXiv2019

Brightest Cluster Galaxy Alignments in Merging Clusters

The orientations of brightest cluster galaxies (BCGs) and their host clusters tend to be aligned, but the mechanism driving this is not clear. To probe the role of cluster mergers in this process, we quantify alignments of 38 BCGs in 22 clusters undergoing major mergers (up to $\sim 1$ Gyr after first pericenter). We find alignments entirely consistent with those of clusters in general. This suggests that alignments are robust against major cluster mergers. If, conversely, major cluster mergers actually help orient the BCG, such a process is acting quickly because the orientation is in place within $\sim 1$ Gyr after first pericenter.

astro-ph.CO↗