SearcharxivSearch

arXiv subjects

Esther M. Hu

Publications and source records attributed to Esther M. Hu.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

Identifying catastrophic outlier photometric redshift estimates in the COSMOS field with machine learning methods

We present the result of two binary classifier ensembled neural networks to identify catastrophic outliers for photo-z estimates within the COSMOS field utilizing only 8 and 5 photometric band passes, respectively. Our neural networks can correctly classify 55.6% and 33.3% of the true positives with few to no false positives. These methods can be used to reduce the errors caused by the errors in redshift estimates, particularly at high redshift. When applied to a larger data set with only photometric data available, our 8 band pass network increased the number of objects with a photo-z greater than 5 from 0.1% to 1.6%, and our 5 band pass network increased the number of objects with a photo-z greater than 5 from 0.2% to 1.8%.

astro-ph.GA

The Evolution of the Ultraluminous Ly-alpha Luminosity Function over z=5.7-6.6

Ultraluminous Lyman alpha (Lya) emitting galaxies (ULLAEs) with log L (Lya)>43.5 erg/s near the epoch of reionization (z>5) make up the bright end of the LAE luminosity function (LF) and may provide insight into the process of reionization, including the formation of ionized bubbles around these extreme systems. We present a spectroscopic LF for ULLAEs at z=5.7. We used data from the HEROES ~45 sq. deg Subaru Hyper Suprime-Cam survey, which is centered on the North Ecliptic Pole and has both broadband (grizY) and narrowband (NB816 and NB921) imaging, to select candidate ULLAEs based on a NB816 excess and a strong broadband Lyman break. We spectroscopically observed 17 ULLAE candidates with DEIMOS on Keck II. We confirmed 12 as LAEs at z=5.7, 9 of which are ULLAEs. The remaining sources are an AGN at z=5.7, an [OIII]5007 emitter at z=0.63, a red star, and two spectroscopic non-detections. Using the 9 confirmed ULLAEs, we construct a ULLAE LF at z=5.7. After applying a comprehensive incompleteness correction, we compare our new z=5.7 LF with our recent z=6.6 LF and with other LFs from the literature to look for evolution at the ultraluminous end. We find the overall ratio of the z=5.7 to z=6.6 ULLAE comoving number densities to be 1.92 (+1.12, -0.71), which corresponds to a LF offset of 0.28 (+0.20, -0.20) dex.

astro-ph.GA

Subaru/HSC z-Broadband Excess Selection of Extreme Emission Line Galaxies at z<1

We present a search for extreme emission line galaxies (EELGs) at z<1 in the COSMOS and North Ecliptic Pole (NEP) fields with imaging from Subaru/Hyper Suprime-Cam (HSC) and a combination of new and existing spectroscopy. We select EELGs on the basis of substantial excess flux in the z broadband, which is sensitive to H$α$ at 0.3<z<0.42 and [OIII]$λ$5007 at 0.7<z<0.86. We identify 10,470 galaxies with z excesses in the COSMOS dataset and 91,385 in the NEP field. We cross-reference the COSMOS EELG sample with the zCOSMOS and DEIMOS 10k spectral catalogs, finding 1395 spectroscopic matches. We made an additional 71 (46 unique) spectroscopic measurements with Y<23 using the HYDRA multi-object spectrograph on the WIYN 3.5m telescope, and 204 spectroscopic measurements from the DEIMOS spectrograph on the Keck II telescope, providing a total of 1441/10,470 spectroscopic redshifts for the EELG sample in COSMOS (~14%). We confirm that 1418 (~98%) are H$α$ or [OIII]$λ$5007 emitters in the above stated redshift ranges. We also identify 240 redshifted H$α$ and [OIII]$λ$5007 emitters in the NEP using spectra taken with WIYN/HYDRA and Keck/DEIMOS. Using broadband selection techniques in g-r-i color space, we distinguish between H$α$ and [OIII]$λ$5007 emitters with 98.6% accuracy. We test our EELG selection by constructing H$α$ and [OIII]$λ$5007 luminosity functions and comparing to recent literature results. We conclude that broadband magnitudes from HSC, the Vera C. Rubin Observatory, and other deep optical multi-band surveys can be used to select EELGs in a straightforward manner.

astro-ph.GA

The Ultraluminous Lyman Alpha Luminosity Function at z=6.6

We present the luminosity function (LF) for ultraluminous Ly$α$ emitting galaxies (LAEs) at z = 6.6. We define ultraluminous LAEs (ULLAEs) as galaxies with logL(Ly$α$) > 43.5 erg s$^{-1}$. We select our main sample using the g', r', i', z', and NB921 observations of a wide-area (30 deg$^2$) Hyper Suprime-Cam survey of the North Ecliptic Pole (NEP) field. We select candidates with g', r', i' > 26, NB921 $\leq$ 23.5, and NB921 - z' $\leq$ 1.3. Using the DEIMOS spectrograph on Keck II, we confirm 9 of our 14 candidates as ULLAEs at z = 6.6 and the remaining 5 as an AGN at z = 6.6, two [OIII]$λ$5007 emitting galaxies at z = 0.84 and z = 0.85, and two non-detections. This emphasizes the need for full spectroscopic follow-up to determine accurate LFs. In constructing the ULLAE LF at z = 6.6, we combine our 9 NEP ULLAEs with two previously discovered and confirmed ULLAEs in the COSMOS field: CR7 and COLA1. We apply rigorous corrections for incompleteness based on simulations. We compare our ULLAE LF at z = 6.6 with LFs at z = 5.7 and z = 6.6 from the literature. Our data reject some previous LF normalizations and power law indices, but they are broadly consistent with others. Indeed, a comparative analysis of the different literature LFs suggests that none is fully consistent with any of the others, making it critical to determine the evolution from z = 5.7 to z = 6.6 using LFs constructed in exactly the same way at both redshifts.

astro-ph.GA

Complex Lyman Alpha Profiles in Redshift 6.6 Ultraluminous Lyman Alpha Emitters

We report on a search for ultraluminous Lyman alpha emitting galaxies (LAEs) at z=6.6 using the NB921 filter on Hyper Suprime-Cam on the Subaru telescope. We searched a 30 degree squared area around the North Ecliptic Pole, which we observed in broadband g', r', i', z', and y' and narrowband NB816 and NB921, for sources with NB921 < 23.5 and z' - NB921 > 1.3. This corresponds to a selection of log L(Ly-alpha) > 43.5 erg/s. We followed up seven candidate LAEs (out of thirteen) with the Keck DEIMOS spectrograph and confirmed five z=6.6 LAEs, one z=6.6 AGN with a broad Ly-alpha line and a strong red continuum, and one low-redshift ([OIII]5007) galaxy. The five ultraluminous LAEs have wider line profiles than lower luminosity LAEs, and one source, NEPLA4, has a complex line profile similar to that of COLA1. In combination with previous results, we show that the line profiles of the z=6.6 ultraluminous LAEs are systematically different than those of lower luminosity LAEs at this redshift. This result suggests that ultraluminous LAEs generate highly ionized regions of the intergalactic medium in their vicinity that allow the full Lyman alpha profile of the galaxy---including any blue wings---to be visible. If this interpretation is correct, then ultraluminous LAEs offer a unique opportunity to determine the properties of the ionized zones around them, which will help in understanding the ionization of the z ~ 7 intergalactic medium. A simple calculation gives a very rough estimate of 0.015 for the escape fraction of ionizing photons, but more sophisticated calculations are needed to fully characterize the uncertainties.

astro-ph.GA

The UV-continuum properties of Ly alpha selected galaxies at z=6.5

We report the first space-based very deep near-infrared continuum observations of a uniform sample of z = 6.5 galaxies with log(L(L_alpha)) = 42.5 - 43 erg/s selected from narrow-band line searches and with spectroscopically confirmed Ly alpha emission. The 1.4 micron HST WFC3 observations are deep enough (AB(1 sigma) = 28.75) to measure individual continuum magnitudes at this redshift for all of the objects. We compare the results with continuum-selected samples at the same redshift and find that Ly alpha emission is present in 24% of all galaxies with M_AB(1350 A) < -20 at z = 6.5. The error in this quantity is dominated by systematic uncertainties, which could be as large as multiplicative factors of three. The Ly alpha galaxies are extended but small (size < 1 kpc), and have star formation rates of approximately 10 Msun/yr. We find a mean L(Ly alpha)/(nu L_nu) at 1400A of 0.08, with the seven objects showing a range from 0.026 to 0.26, implying that there is little sign of destruction of the Ly alpha line. All of the properties of the z = 6.5 sample appear to be very similar to those of Ly alpha emitters at lower redshifts.

astro-ph.CO

Ly alpha emitting galaxies as early stages in galaxy formation

We present optical spectroscopy of two samples of GALEX grism selected Ly alpha emitters (LAEs): one at z=0.195-0.44 and the other at z=0.65-1.25. We have also observed a comparison sample of galaxies in the same redshift intervals with the same UV magnitude distributions but with no detected Ly alpha. We use the optical spectroscopy to eliminate active galactic nuclei (AGNs) and to obtain the optical emission-line properties of the samples. We compare the luminosities of the LAEs in the two redshift intervals and show that there is dramatic evolution in the maximum Ly alpha luminosity over z=0-1. Focusing on the z=0.195-0.44 samples alone, we show that there are tightly defined relations between all of the galaxy parameters and the rest-frame equivalent width (EW) of H alpha. The higher EW(H alpha) sources all have lower metallicities, bluer colors, smaller sizes, and less extinction, consistent with their being in the early stages of the galaxy formation process. We find that 75 +- 12% of the LAEs have EW(H alpha)>100 Angstrom, and, conversely, that 31 +/- 3% of galaxies with EW(H alpha)>100 Angstrom are LAEs. We correct the broadband magnitudes for the emission-line contributions and use spectral synthesis fits to estimate the ages of the galaxies. We find a median age of 1.1x10^{8} yr for the LAE sample and 1.4x10^{9} yr for the UV-continuum sample without detected Ly alpha. The median metallicity of the LAE sample is 12+log(O/H)=8.24, or about 0.4 dex lower than the UV-continuum sample.

astro-ph.CO

Deep Spectroscopy of Ultra-Strong Emission Line Galaxies

Ultra strong emission-line galaxies (USELs) with extremely high equivalent widths (EW(H beta) > 30A) can be used to pick out galaxies of extremely low metallicity in the z=0-1 redshift range. Large numbers of these objects are easily detected in deep narrow band searches and, since most have detectable [OIII] 4363, their metallicities determined using the direct method. These large samples hold the possibility for determining if there is a metallicity floor for the galaxy population. Here we describe results of an extensive spectroscopic follow-up of the Kakazu et al. (2007) catalog of 542 USELs using the DEIMOS spectrograph on Keck, with high S/N spectra of 348 galaxies. The two lowest metallicity galaxies in our sample have 12+log(O/H)=6.97+/-0.17 and 7.25+/-0.03 -- values comparable to the lowest metallicity galaxies found to date. We determine an empirical metallicity-R23 parameter relation for our sample, and compare this to the relationship for low redshift galaxies. The determined metallicity-luminosity relation is compared with those of magnitude selected samples in the same redshift range. The emission line selected galaxies show a metal-luminosity relation where the metallicity decreases with luminosity and they appear to define the lower bound of the galaxy metallicity distribution at a given continuum luminosity. We also compute the H alpha luminosity function of the USELs as a function of redshift and use this to compute an upper bound on the Ly alpha emitter luminosity function over the z=0-1 redshift range.

astro-ph.CO

Mapping the Youngest Galaxies to Redshift One

We describe results of a narrow band search for ultra-strong emission line galaxies (USELs) with EW(H beta) > 30 A. 542 candidate galaxies are found in a half square degree survey using two ~100 Angstrom 8150 A and 9140 A filters with Subaru/SuprimeCam. Followup spectroscopy for randomly selected objects in the sample with KeckII/DEIMOS shows they consist of [OIII] 5007, [OII] 3727, and H alpha selected strong-emission line galaxies at intermediate redshifts (z < 1), and Ly alpha emitting galaxies at high-redshift (z >> 5). We determine the H beta luminosity functions and the star formation density of the USELs, which is 5-10% of the value found from ultraviolet continuum objects at z=0-1, suggesting they correspond to a major epoch in galaxy formation at these redshifts. Many USELs show the temperature-sensitive [OIII] 4363 auroral lines and about a dozen have oxygen abundances characteristic of eXtremely Metal Poor Galaxies (XMPGs). These XMPGs are the most distant known today. Our high yield rate of XMPGs suggests this is a powerful method for finding such populations. The lowest metallicity measured in our sample is 12+log(O/H) = 7.06 (6.78-7.44), close to the minimum metallicity found in local galaxies. The luminosities, metallicities and star formation rates of USELs are consistent with the strong emitters being start-up intermediate mass galaxies and suggest that galaxies are still forming in relatively chemically pristine sites at z < 1.

astro-ph

The Stellar Population of Lyman-alpha Emitting Galaxies at z ~ 5.7

We present a study of three Lyman-alpha emitting galaxies (LAEs), selected via a narrow-band survey in the GOODS northern field, and spectroscopically confirmed to have redshifts of z ~ 5.65. Using HST ACS and Spitzer IRAC data, we constrain the rest-frame UV-to-optical spectral energy distributions (SEDs) of the galaxies. Fitting stellar population synthesis models to the observed SEDs, we find best-fit stellar populations with masses between ~ 10^9 - 10^10 M_sun and ages between ~ 5 - 100 Myr, assuming a simple starburst star formation history. However, stellar populations as old as 700 Myr are admissible if a constant star formation rate model is considered. Very deep near-IR observations may help to narrow the range of allowed models by providing extra constraints on the rest-frame UV spectral slope. Our narrow-band selected objects and other IRAC-detected z ~ 6 i'-dropout galaxies have similar 3.6 um magnitudes and z' - [3.6] colors, suggesting that they posses stellar populations of similar masses and ages. This similarity may be the result of a selection bias, since the IRAC-detected LAEs and i'-dropouts probably only sample the bright end of the luminosity function. On the other hand, our LAEs have blue i' - z' colors compared to the i'-dropouts, and would have been missed by the i'-dropout selection criterion. A better understanding of the overlap between the LAE and the i'-dropout populations is necessary in order to constrain the properties of the overall high-redshift galaxy population, such as the total stellar mass density at z ~ 6.

astro-ph

Spectroscopic Studies of z~5.7 and z~6.5 Galaxies: Implications for Reionization

The recent development of large, complete samples which identify high-redshift galaxies at z~5.7 and z~6.5 from deep, wide-field surveys provides detailed information on the earliest galaxies, their numbers, spatial and kinematic distributions, and implications for early reionization of the IGM. In this contribution we present results of spectroscopic studies of z~5.7 and z~6.5 galaxies identified from our deep, Lyman alpha narrowband and multicolor surveys conducted with the SuprimeCam mosaic CCD camera on the 8.3-m Subaru telescope and observed with the DEIMOS multi-object spectrograph on Keck. The luminosity function of the z~6.5 galaxies is shown to be similar to the luminosity function of the z~5.7 galaxy samples, suggesting that a substantial star-forming population is already in place at z~6.5. Comparisons of both individual and stacked spectra of galaxies in these two samples show that the Lyman alpha emission profiles, equivalent widths, and continuum break strengths do not substantially change over this redshift interval. The wide-field nature of the surveys also permits mapping the large-scale distribution of the high-redshift galaxies in spatial structures extending across individual SuprimeCam fields (~60 Mpc). Field-to-field variations in the number of objects at z~6.5 may shortly be able to place constraints on the porosity of the reionization boundary.

astro-ph

The Team Keck Treasury Redshift Survey of the GOODS-North Field

We report the results of an extensive imaging and spectroscopic survey in the GOODS-North field completed using DEIMOS on the Keck II telescope. Observations of 2018 targets in a magnitude-limited sample of 2911 objects to R=24.4 yield secure redshifts for a sample of 1440 galaxies and AGN plus 96 stars. In addition to redshifts and associated quality assessments, our catalog also includes photometric and astrometric measurements for all targets detected in our R-band imaging survey of the GOODS-North region. We investigate various sources of incompleteness and find the redshift catalog to be 53% complete at its limiting magnitude. The median redshift of z=0.65 is lower than in similar deep surveys because we did not select against low-redshift targets. Comparison with other redshift surveys in the same field, including a complementary Hawaii-led DEIMOS survey, establishes that our velocity uncertainties are as low as 40 km/s for red galaxies and that our redshift confidence assessments are accurate. The distributions of rest-frame magnitudes and colors among the sample agree well with model predictions out to and beyond z=1. We will release all survey data, including extracted 1-D and sky-subtracted 2-D spectra, thus providing a sizable and homogeneous database for the GOODS-North field which will enable studies of large scale structure, spectral indices, internal galaxy kinematics, and the predictive capabilities of photometric redshifts.

astro-ph

The Luminosity Function of Lyman Alpha Emitters at Redshift z~5.7

We report results of a deep wide-field narrowband survey for redshift z~5.7 Ly alpha emitters carried out with SuprimeCam on Subaru 8.3-m telescope. Deep narrowband imaging of the SSA22 field through a 120 A bandpass filter centered at 8150 A was combined with deep multicolor RIz' SuprimeCam broadband imaging, and BVRZ imaging taken with CFHT's CFH12K camera to select high-redshift galaxy candidates. Spectroscopic observations were made using the new wide-field multi-object DEIMOS spectrograph on Keck for 22 of the 26 candidate objects. Eighteen objects were identified as z~5.7 Lyman alpha emitters, and a further nineteenth candidate was identified based on an LRIS spectrum. At the 3.3 A resolution of the DEIMOS spectra the asymmetric profile for Ly alpha emission with its steep blue fall-off can be clearly seen. We use this to describe the distribution of equivalent widths and the continuum color break properties for z~5.7 Ly alpha galaxies compared with foreground objects. The large majority (>75%) of Ly alpha lines have rest frame equivalent widths less than 240 A and can be understood in terms of young star forming galaxies with a Salpeter initial mass function for the stars. With narrowband selection criteria of I-N > 0.7 and N<25.05 (AB mags) we find a surface density of Ly alpha emitters of 0.03 per square arcminute per (deltaz=0.1) to a limiting flux just under 2e-17 erg/cm2/s. The luminosity function of the Ly alpha emitters is similar to that at lower redshifts to the lowest measurable luminosity of 1e43 ergs/s as is the universal star formation rate based on their continuum properties. We note that the objects are highly structured in both spatial and spectral properties on the angular scale of the fields (~60 Mpc), and that multiple fields will have to be averaged to accurately measure their ensemble properties.

astro-ph

The Extended Emission-Line Region of 4C 37.43

We have explored the nature of the extended emission-line region around the z=0.37 quasar 4C 37.43, using extensive ground-based and HST imaging and spectroscopy. The velocity field of the ionized gas shows gradual gradients within components but large jumps between components, with no obvious global organization. The HST [O III] image shows radial linear features on the east side of the QSO that appear to mark the edges of an ionization cone. Concentrating on the bright emission peaks ~4\arcsec$ east of the quasar, we find through modeling that we require at least two density regimes contributing significantly to the observed emission-line spectrum: one with a density of ~2 cm^-3, having essentially unity filling factor, and one with a density of ~500 cm^-3, having a very small (~10^-5) filling factor. Because the temperatures of these two components are similar, they cannot be in pressure equilibrium, and there is no obvious source of confinement for the dense regions. We estimate that the dense regions will dissipate on timescales <~10^4 years and therefore need to be continuously regenerated, most likely by shocks. Because we know that some QSOs, at least, begin their lives in conjunction with merger-driven massive starbursts in their host galaxies, an attractive interpretation is that the extended emission region comprises gas that has been expelled as a result of tidal forces during the merger and is now being shocked by the galactic superwind from the starburst. This picture is supported by the observed distribution of the ionized gas, the presence of velocities ranging up to ~700 km s^{-1}, and the existence of at least two QSOs having similarly luminous and complex extended emission regions that are known to have ultra-luminous IR galaxy hosts with current or recent starbursts.

astro-ph

A Redshift z = 6.56 Galaxy Behind the Cluster Abell 370

We report the discovery of a redshift z=6.56 galaxy lying behind the cluster Abell 370. The object HCM 6A was found in a narrowband imaging survey using a 118 Angstrom bandpass filter centered at 9152 Ang in the LRIS camera on the 10 m Keck II Telescope. Candidate Lyman alpha emitters were identified by the equivalent width of the emission and the absence of lower wavelength flux in ultradeep broadband images. HCM6A is the first galaxy to be confirmed at redshift z>6, and has W_lambda(observed)=190 Angstroms, flux = 2.7 x 10^-17 erg cm^-2 s^-1. Spectra obtained with LRIS confirm the emission line and the continuum break across the line, and show an asymmetric line profile with steep fall-off on the blue side. Deep Subaru near-infrared CISCO images in J, H and K' which extend the sampled continuum to longer wavelengths give a consistent estimate of the continuum flux density in these line-free regions of 2.6+/-0.7 x 10^-30 erg cm^-2 s^-1 Hz^-1. The line width and strength, asymmetric profile, and very deep spectral break are only consistent with the interpretation of the line as a redshifted Lyman alpha feature. From the detailed lensing model of this cluster, we estimate a lensing amplification of 4.5 for this galaxy, which is located slightly over an arcminute from the center of the cluster, for an unlensed flux of 6.5 x 10^-18 erg cm^-2 s^-1. The presence of such a galaxy suggests that the reionizing epoch is beyond z=6.6.

astro-ph

Galaxies at z>5: The View from Hawaii

We review the properties of z>5 galaxies studied with HST and with the Keck telescopes, and discuss the detectability of Lyman alpha emission-line galaxies out to z~6.5 based on these data and ongoing narrowband imaging surveys. The brightest sources may show (R-Z) color breaks, although the high sky background at Z (lambda_{eff} ~ 9200 Ang), makes such observations challenging for typical faint sources. Keck LRIS observations of the z=5 SDSS quasar and z>5 galaxies observed with HST in the HDF show that the strength of the Lyman break is evolving more slowly than extrapolations from models at z~3 would predict.

astro-ph

Limits on the Gunn-Peterson Effect at z = 5

We report new limits on the Gunn-Peterson effect at a redshift near 5 using spectroscopic observations of the z = 5 Sloan Digital Sky Survey quasar, J033829.31+002156.3, made with the LRIS and HIRES spectrographs on the Keck telescopes. Lower resolution spectrophotometrically calibrated observations made with LRIS over the wavelength region 4500-9600 angstroms were used to obtain a continuum shape and to flux calibrate much higher resolution (R = 36,000) observations made with HIRES. The LRIS data show an Oke D_A index of 0.75. Portions of the HIRES spectrum return to near the extrapolated continuum level. Including both statistical and systematic errors we place an upper limit of tau = 0.1 on the regions of minimum opacity. We argue that, even if this opacity arises in underdense regions of the intergalactic gas, we require a high value of the metagalactic ionizing flux at these redshifts ($J_ν \gg 4 \times 10^{-23}~{\rm ergs cm^{-2} s^{-1} Hz^{-1} sr^{-1}}$ at $z\sim4.72$) to produce a solution which is consistent with even minimum nucleosynthesis estimates of the baryon density. We also report the presence of a Mg II absorption system of extremely high equivalent width ($W_{λ,rest}(2796)=1.73$ Å) at z=2.304.

astro-ph

An Extremely Luminous Galaxy at z=5.74

We report the discovery of an extremely luminous galaxy lying at a redshift of z=5.74, SSA22-HCM1. The object was found in narrowband imaging of the SSA22 field using a 105 Angstrom bandpass filter centered at 8185 Angstroms during the course of the Hawaii narrowband survey using LRIS on the 10 m Keck II Telescope, and was identified by the equivalent width of the emission W_lambda(observed)=175 Angstroms, flux = 1.7 x 10^{-17} erg cm^{-2} s^{-1}). Comparison with broadband colors shows the presence of an extremely strong break (> 4.2 at the 2 sigma level) between the Z band above the line, where the AB magnitude is 25.5, and the R band below, where the object is no longer visible at a 2 sigma upper limit of 27.1 (AB mags). These properties are only consistent with this object's being a high-z Ly alpha emitter. A 10,800 s spectrum obtained with LRIS yields a redshift of 5.74. The object is similar in its continuum shape, line properties, and observed equivalent width to the z=5.60 galaxy, HDF 4-473.0, as recently described by Weymann et al. (1998), but is 2-3 times more luminous in the line and in the red continuum. For H_0 = 65 km s^{-1} Mpc^{-1} and q_0 = (0.02, 0.5) we would require star formation rates of around (40, 7) solar masses per year to produce the UV continuum in the absence of extinction.

astro-ph